Robin's Reviews > The Red Queen

The Red Queen by Philippa Gregory

by
Nophoto-f-50x66
's review
Nov 16, 10

bookshelves: historical-fiction
Read in November, 2010

I have no idea if Margaret Beaufort was as she is depicted by Gregory, but her fictional alter ego is the most unlikeable person to spend hours with that I have come across in a novel in years. The first-person narrative gave little escape from this fanatical and self-absorbed woman. Henry Tudor's ascension to the throne as Henry VII is a a fascinating and unlikely story, but neither mother, the true believer in his destiny despite its apparent impossibility, nor Henry VII (whom I am more familiar with historically) are going to win any warmth of personality awards. Margaret Beaufort had a rough life in many ways, and maybe her single-minded devotion to see her son, a virtual stranger, on the English throne as the last of the Lancasters is admirable at times, but neither of these characters have personalities that make for good company, and Gregory did little but superficially give understanding to who they were or why Jasper Tudor or anyone else should love Margaret. I found the character studies very superficial and no reward for my perseverance in finishing the novel.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Red Queen.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Leah (new) - rated it 1 star

Leah I completely agree. I'm not quite done with the book but your review is so close to what I would write. I can't stand Margaret and that is making it very very hard to read this book. I've put it down numerous times thinking I wouldn't finish it, but alas I've decided to read it. But I swear if Margaret makes one more reference to Joan of Arc I'm going to just throw this book down and be done!


Robin Leah wrote: "I completely agree. I'm not quite done with the book but your review is so close to what I would write. I can't stand Margaret and that is making it very very hard to read this book. I've put it do..."

Leah, somehow I missed your comment, but thanks for the fellow-feeling. I am right there with you on the Joan of Arc references! Makes one want to burn something at the stake.


Nancy I am barely past page 100 - right now I am feeling very sorry for Margaret. She must become more unlikeable as the book goes on?


Robin Nancy, I did feel pity for her at times, but I also most found her unlikeable even at those times, and the longer I read the more that outweighed any victimization and the pity it evoked. You will have to let me know when you finish.


Nancy I spent most of the morning reading up on Margaret Beaufort, The War of Roses and other involved people - Richard III, the Princes in the Tower, her husbands, her son and grandson. Ruthless people for ruthless times. I will keep checking in as I continue reading. I have ordered The White Queen to read next.


Nancy I agree with you - Margaret Beaufort was a nasty piece of work. Single minded, ruthless, unreasonable. The only compliment that I can think to give her is she loved her son.


Robin Nancy,
Sorry I missed your comments. Usually I get an e-mail. Missed that she'd written a White Queen. Have to check it out, but I agree about the time being ruthless and ugly. I have read a lot of history of the time previously, but I have just traced ancestors to the period and more than a handful were beheaded during the period for being on the wrong side of a battle.


Nancy The White Queen is a GOOD book! I have learned so much about English history. The White Queen was not liked by the English - she was viewed as avaricious (and she was) but the book, The White Queen, presents a much more sympathetic view.


Sheryl I completely agree with your assessment.


message 10: by Nicki (new) - added it

Nicki As much as I love Philippa Gregory's books, I don't think she writes as well from a powerful woman's point of view than from those with less power, such as Mary Boleyn or Jane Boleyn. I didn't like her writing as Margaret, Mary Queen Of Scots and least fo all as Catherine Howard.


back to top