karen's Reviews > Shackleton's Stowaway
Shackleton's Stowaway
by Victoria McKernan
by Victoria McKernan
many many animals were harmed in the writing of this story. and "good" animals, too, not just the necessary "starving in antarctica" ones that you have to kill for survival. there are awful penguin-clubbing sequences, some euthanasia of dogs and a cat, and lots of seals make their way into seal heaven. there is also one awesome amputation scene.disney will never option this story. there are very few places to insert singing mice (twss) but it is a true account of a young boy who stowed away on shackleton's ill-fated antarctic exploration, and details the cold, starvation, seasickness, and madness in very real and graphic terms.
so take everything i said about everest and double it. if everest hates you, antarctica hates your whole family past, present, and future. antarctica is having a fine time just floating in the cold icebergy, seal-filled water and resents it when humans decide to drop by unannounced. and like that one time those roaches tried to live in my cupboards - all shall be destroyed.
but i loved this book. i love survival stuff, to be sure, but particularly cold-weather survival. having read this, the terror, brian's winter, peak, into thin air, and aurororama all within the past year - i will not be making any arctic voyages anytime soon, thank you. but i will read about it all cozy in my slanket.and now i really want to read endurance.
but i still have some teen fiction on the syllabus to endure (yuk yuk chortle) first.
so take everything i said about everest and double it. if everest hates you, antarctica hates your whole family past, present, and future. antarctica is having a fine time just floating in the cold icebergy, seal-filled water and resents it when humans decide to drop by unannounced. and like that one time those roaches tried to live in my cupboards - all shall be destroyed.
but i loved this book. i love survival stuff, to be sure, but particularly cold-weather survival. having read this, the terror, brian's winter, peak, into thin air, and aurororama all within the past year - i will not be making any arctic voyages anytime soon, thank you. but i will read about it all cozy in my slanket.and now i really want to read endurance.
but i still have some teen fiction on the syllabus to endure (yuk yuk chortle) first.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Shackleton's Stowaway.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-21 of 21) (21 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Ronyell
(new)
Nov 26, 2010 09:17pm
Awesome review Karen!!
reply
|
flag
*
The Shackleton epic fucking rules. A total monarch of survival stories. I remember something sorta touching about how they did keep their dogs for as long as reasonably possible, while continuing to feed them penguin scraps and whatnot. Shackleton's like 800 mile journey through the freezing, hurricane-ridden ocean, in a tiny row boat? A m a z i n g shit right there. Yes, I get enthusiastic about this one.
yeah - i liked almost all the books in the "adventure" category for this class. probably because i am so outdoorsy and physically fit.
If I were visiting in February I'd insist we don parkas and go to a park to "play Shackleton" like a bunch of weirdo kids from the 30's or somethin'.
Karen, did you ever read the essay on Arctic/Antarctica survival books in Ex Libris: Confessions of a Common Reader?
karen wrote: "we can do that in may, though, right? it would just be less realistic."Yes! I like the way you think. We'll be committed for seeming (?) insane though, running about, screaming about penguin meat in the middle of a beautiful spring day. Although, given the population of crazies in The Big City we'd hardly be noticeable at all on anyone's insanity meter.
(P.S. Anyone else not getting e-mail updates from GR lately?)
no, i never did read that!! hurrah!! more things to add to the piles!!every day i have book avalanches, so my house is like everest in this way. but it is nothing like antarctica
karen wrote: "no, i never did read that!! hurrah!! more things to add to the piles!!"I think you will like it. She's a little sappy at points but clever. She has a great essay on trying to combine her bookshelves with her husband's and trying to get rid of duplicates.
karen wrote: "it is tiny, so i may be able to speedread it at work..."Oh! She also loves Charles Lamb. I would never have read him without her and he is very clever and funny.
Maybe you should come over here. There are plenty of leftover Thanksgiving treats on tap. Pork pie, too.
