Jim Coughenour's Reviews > Silence
Silence
by Jan Costin Wagner
by Jan Costin Wagner
A few years ago I read Ice Moon, the first of Jan Costin Wagner's novels to be translated into English, and I was immediately curious about the next. Wagner is German, but his Detective Kimmo Joentaa is Finnish. His plots are set in Turku and Helsinki, amid forests and lakes and the abundant natural beauty of Finland's climate and geography. For a Californian like me, the landscape described through Joentaa's eyes is enough to set me dreaming of endless snowy nights or a midnight sun flickering on the dead calm of an isolated lake.
Silence is the second in the series. Joentaa is still grieving over the wife he was grieving over in the first book, but this melancholy aspect isn't as lachrymose as it sounds. The plot in the second book has to do with the long-ago abduction, rape and murder of a young girl, an unsolved case that haunts its original investigator even beyond his retirement. When it all seems to happen again (the same spot, method, etc.) the plot picks up again.
What sets Wagner's version of this standard trope apart is the delicacy with which he handles all the characters, including the killer and his inadvertent accomplice, the parents of the missing girls, and the handful of detectives drawn into the mystery. Sometimes critics characterize policiers being hard-boiled; I'd say this one is basted. Each narrative layer is seasoned and gently positioned, until the story achieves its final form, perfectly composed. Wagner's books aren't for readers who want pulse-pounding action, they're for the more contemplative sort who are willing to savor the sorrow, defeats and small human victories along the way to finding the killer – who by the end, is somehow beside the point. A finely spun tale of grief and unexpected compassion.
Silence is the second in the series. Joentaa is still grieving over the wife he was grieving over in the first book, but this melancholy aspect isn't as lachrymose as it sounds. The plot in the second book has to do with the long-ago abduction, rape and murder of a young girl, an unsolved case that haunts its original investigator even beyond his retirement. When it all seems to happen again (the same spot, method, etc.) the plot picks up again.
What sets Wagner's version of this standard trope apart is the delicacy with which he handles all the characters, including the killer and his inadvertent accomplice, the parents of the missing girls, and the handful of detectives drawn into the mystery. Sometimes critics characterize policiers being hard-boiled; I'd say this one is basted. Each narrative layer is seasoned and gently positioned, until the story achieves its final form, perfectly composed. Wagner's books aren't for readers who want pulse-pounding action, they're for the more contemplative sort who are willing to savor the sorrow, defeats and small human victories along the way to finding the killer – who by the end, is somehow beside the point. A finely spun tale of grief and unexpected compassion.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Silence.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lambert
(new)
-
added it
Mar 24, 2013 01:06am
I just watched the German language film version of The Silence and it is one of the most haunting and thought-provoking police procedurals I have seen in a long time. I have yet to read the book but your review, where you talk of savouring the sorrows, defeats and small human victories reminds me of The Reader (although that is quite a different genre).
reply
|
flag
*
Hi Lambert – I recently watched that movie too – quite original in the way it presented the story. As I recall (I read The Silence 2-3 years ago) in the novel the detective is not quite as damaged as the one in the film. The book develops differently, but the truth is I can't remember exactly how it ended. I think they caught the killer, but maybe not. If you check out the book, let me know.
