Kristen Mcchesney's Reviews > Charles and Emma: The Darwins' Leap of Faith

Charles and Emma by Deborah Heiligman

by
Nophoto-f-50x66
's review
Oct 30, 10

bookshelves: non-fiction

Over the summer, I read Creation: The True Story of Charles Darwin by Randal Keynes (after hearing Keynes talk about his book on NPR). I thought the book Creation was an interesting look at how Darwin came to his belifs and how he "evolved" in thought over time. A main theme of Creation was how the death of Annie influenced Darwin and his thoughts on religion, evolution and humanity. And while I found the book interesting I wanted more on the Darwin's personal story. The book Charles and Emma provided a link between Darwin in theory and Darwin the man. I found this book incredibily fascinating and the details of the age, the family, and Darwin's work all merged together in an engaging manner. I think that this book can serve many purposes and topical interests - religion, family, science, and Victorian housholds and norms. Yet, while I liked the scienctific aspects of the story and appreciate how it would be diffuclt to write a book on Darwin without discussing theory and science - the details, at times, seemed a bit intense for a YA book. I think that many students wouldn't be able to fully connect with the more nuanced parts of Darwin's work. However, showing in detail the two sides of Darwin (the personal and the professional) was really enjoyable and showed the complexities of people. All told - I really enjoyed reading this and felt that my understanding of not only Darwin and his theories, but the entire scope of British soceity in the 1800s was expanded by this very well-thoughtout, well-research and well-written account of the lives of Charles and Emma Darwin.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Charles and Emma.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Ci546_manuelanavarro I agree with your comment about the scientific aspect of the book, it was too much for me. I have a student in my class who I think reads more then I do and even he returned this book after reading only a few pages. I guess I am just not that interested in Charles Darwin's work. I didn't mind the time period details or the personal information on the family, but the narration of his work became exhausting and honestly dreadful for me. I didn't think I would finish it.


Kristen Mcchesney I think that having read the other book about Darwin, which was really heavily scientific - this booked seemed more readable. But, I agree with you that kids, unless they really liked science or had an interest in Darwin, wouldn't really connect with anything in this story.


back to top