Speedtribes's Reviews > Manta's Gift

Manta's Gift by Timothy Zahn

by
123494
's review
Oct 27, 10

bookshelves: sci-fi

Avatar before Avatar came out. The main male protagonist is whiny and unlikeable - but he's supposed to be that way. He does grow and change throughout the story, but I wish he'd done so a little more and sooner. I wish there'd be a some more politics or lifestyle sorts of things for both the human and alien sides, but that would be like saying an action movie should have been a mini series. Fun and sturdy writing.

It also avoids a lot of the racial issues the Avatar movie had by having aliens that are, well, alien enough to justify their being unable to do certain things humans are capable of. Who knew lacking prehensile thumbs, and well, HANDS, would have such a profound effect on a race's ability to create industry and tech? *laugh*

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Manta's Gift.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Brownbetty (new)

Brownbetty Oh man, yes, to the whiny protagonist. I mean, I made it past that, but I almost didn't.


Speedtribes Brownbetty wrote: "Oh man, yes, to the whiny protagonist. I mean, I made it past that, but I almost didn't."

Yeah, I wanted to punch him so many times. The only reason I stuck through it was that he was supposed to be that way and it wasn't some case where the author was blind to how truly unlikable his main chara was.


back to top