Jay's Reviews > For Whom the Bell Tolls

For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 06, 16

really liked it
bookshelves: literature-united-states
Read from August 29 to September 05, 2011 — I own a copy , read count: 2

In Spain of the post-Franco years, and especially since the opening of the archives of the old Soviet Union, the debate about the role of the Communist in the Second Republic both before and during Franco’s rebellion has increased with renewed intensity. It has long been clear that the war was not a simple black-and-white conflict between a freely elected liberal democratic State (the Republic), on one side, and an insurgent authoritarian Fascism, on the other.

The historian Stanley Payne has argued that Russia’s subvention of the Republic both before and after 1936 was far more extensive than many once thought--that the Communist party played a more integral role in Spain and in the war itself than historians and other researchers had previously suggested. Even if his conclusion that the Republic was moving toward a Communist totalitarianism well before the military’s 1936 intervention is not universally accepted, it is certain that the Republic (a coalition of Anarchists, Socialists, Communists and Republicans) was ill disposed to grant the right wing (a grouping of Church, Military and Fascists) any position in the political arena. It also seems clear that the West’s economic embargo did not drive the Republic into Russia’s hands. The Republican government’s links to Moscow, which supplied that government with armaments and strategy, were cemented well before that embargo.

Hemingway’s “For Whom the Bell Tolls” (published in 1940) emerged out of a simpler, less
Machiavellian view of Spain and its civil war – one that circulated outside of Spain and that romanticized the Republican cause and minimized Russia’s pernicious intervention. Hemingway’s novel—its plot and characters-- is certainly compelling and continues to rank among his best writing even given some of the negative criticism of the language which was intended to reflect the more informal colloquial Spanish spoken by the characters. But, as a window on the Spanish and their Civil War, the novel is fundamentally unreliable. Although Hemingway worked as a journalist in Spain during a large part of the conflict, he was curiously disengaged in many respects from the complexities of politics as they played out in Spain through 1939. His time in Madrid in the Hotel Florida, as Hemingway himself describes it, was far less political or doctrinaire than social. He certainly never embraced the ideology of any of the Communist parties. He did, however, emerge as a spokesperson for the myths forged by the Stalinists.

When I first read “For Whom the Bell Tolls” as a teenager in 1956, I found both the setting and the politics of the war described by Hemingway as engaging as the novel’s more transcendental themes. I had no reason to doubt the authenticity of Hemingway’s voice in regard to Spain and the Civil War. Robert Jordan, the young American academic fighting in Spain as part of the International Brigades on the side of the Republic, carried me into the mountains around Segovia and into a Spain of matadors, peasants and shepherds. And, although Hemingway described atrocities on both sides of the conflict [Pilar’s account of Pablo’s sacking of a small mountain town in the environs of Avila is quite chilling], the Republican guerrillas cemented my sympathies for what I saw as their democratic crusade. As Robert Jordan, I was a Republican. As Robert Jordan, I fell in love with María. And similar to Jordan, I saw the war and the inevitability of a victory of Franco’s Nationalists as the death of truth and idealism in Spain itself. Liberal Democracy defeated at the hands of Twentieth Century Fascism. Here was the image: Robert Jordan’s commitment to blowing up a bridge was a Twentieth Century reenactment of El Cid’s battle against the Moors.

Having re-read “For Whom the Bell Tolls” in 2011, after years of studying Spanish history and culture and of living in the country itself off and on during Franco’s dictatorship, I now find it flawed as a view of the Spaniards and of their Civil War. On the other hand, the work’s themes—death, honor, commitment, love—and Hemingway’s treatment of them is far more meaningful for me than the novel’s physical setting and its portrayal of the Spaniards submerged in civil war. Hemingway’s treatment of those themes engaged me in 2011 as much as the novel did in 1956.

13 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read For Whom the Bell Tolls.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

02/13 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-1 of 1) (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Greta It has been a few since my husband read "For Whom the Bell Tolls" at bedtime for many weeks. It helped me get to sleep often from boredom with the story, until the ending which made this one of my favorite Hemingway stories. I also lived in Spain during Franco's reign in the late 1960's which added to my interest in Hemingway's accounts of Spain and it's people.

back to top