oliviasbooks's Reviews > Ballad: A Gathering of Faerie

Ballad by Maggie Stiefvater

by
2843533
4,5 stars!! I am quite overwelmed by how much I liked Ballad, since after reading Lament I expected a sequel that would also barely make it into the "It-was-enjoyable-but-didn't-touch-me" category. In most cases sequels even take a slight - or not so slight - drop for me. Surprisingly Ballad turned out to be what I wished Lament had been: A beautiful but eerie story in which humans meet dangerous, but alluring and likable faeries. Both worlds are shaken up. Both main characters change because of the encounter. James was the character I liked best in Lament, anyway. And his story told in turns with faerie muse Nuala tucked at my heart strings in a way Deidre's narration would not and could not. (Oh, how I wished for a miracle in the end! A sure sign of success of the author's efforts to engage the reader.) I was so very afraid of Nuala hurting James in the beginning, but after a few chapters she started to grow on me, which is how it should be in my opinion. Ballad, which was featuring Deidre, too, in the form of unsent text messages, confirmed my slight dislike of "the cloverhand" and opened my eyes to why Lament and I could not and did not really click. A short comment on the cover: It fits "like a fist on an eye" as we would say in German.

P.S.: I am sorry, Jessi, for stowing Ballad away on my keepers shelf after having set up your hope. Borrowing is certainly possible ;-).

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ballad.
sign in »

Quotes oliviasbooks Liked

Maggie Stiefvater
“I tried to picture her in a class, any class, anywhere on campus, and failed miserably. I pictured her frolicking in a forest glade around some guy she'd just sacrificed to a heathen god. That image worked way better.”
Maggie Stiefvater, Ballad: A Gathering of Faerie

Maggie Stiefvater
“Eleanor's voice was below zero. 'My finest horse to whichever faerie in this room brings me that woman's left eye.'

My thoughts exactly.”
Maggie Stiefvater, Ballad: A Gathering of Faerie

Maggie Stiefvater
“M'Dear," I said cordially, "Your butt's blocking my bumper. Do you think you could move your loitering five feet to the south and let me leave?”
Maggie Stiefvater, Ballad: A Gathering of Faerie


Reading Progress

12/08/2010 page 32
9.0% "So far it's not bad. Ms. Stiefvater's writing is good - as always."
12/09/2010 page 143
41.0% "Definitely better than Lament, but I think having read Lament before helps." 1 comment
12/10/2010 page 240
68.0% "I've got that awful feeling that it will end tragically ..."
show 4 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Corinne (new) - added it

Corinne I'm looking forward to your review ;). Lament was not that bad, but it simply didn't catch me like other books about faeries´, but I still want to give it a try.


message 2: by Janina (new)

Janina Sounds good. Do I have to read Lament before Ballad or could I just give this one a try as a stand-alone?


message 3: by oliviasbooks (last edited Dec 12, 2010 01:42am) (new) - rated it 4 stars

oliviasbooks Hmmm. I think Ballad is written for people who have read Lament. For instance you are never told who 'Luke' is and what happenend between him and Deidre - or also why Deidre is so negatively important to the fairies (It's hinted at). Deidre is but a side figure in Ballad, but I think it would annoy me a little not to be in the know. Still, you, as an experienced reader, would manage. And maybe it would annoy you more afterwards that you had spent time and money on Lament. Who knows...


message 4: by Morgan (new)

Morgan F I was about to ask the same question as Janina. For some reason, my library has Ballad, but not Lament, and I'm always tempted to pick it up.


oliviasbooks Have a try. If there will be question marks forming in your head you can always ask me. If you are lucky I'll remember.


message 6: by oliviasbooks (last edited Dec 12, 2010 06:55am) (new) - rated it 4 stars

oliviasbooks And Morgan ... you'll like James. He is cocky, unafraid and quite manly. You couldn't call him a human copy of Sam, no.


message 7: by Morgan (new)

Morgan F Haha. Maybe I'll check it out next time I go then.


Stefanie Yesssss! I'm glad you liked this!


Lamia great review :) I have mixed feelings about Lament because, like you, I didn't really connect with Deirdre and I just wanted to give James a hug through the entire thing, so your review gives me hope for Ballad.
Why oh why do YA heroines always have to pick the new, dark, mysterious guy over the loyal, funny and lovable best friend?


oliviasbooks Lamia wrote: "great review ... Why oh why do YA heroines always have to pick the new, dark, mysterious guy over the loyal, funny and lovable best friend? "

First: Thank you! And second: Exactly my question!


back to top