Kari's Reviews > I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You

I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You by Ally Carter
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Oct 14, 10

bookshelves: books-i-own, read-teen

Completely unique and overall light and air, I'd Tell You I Love You but Then I'd Have to Kill You is a quick read with high interest. This book has an imaginative and descriptive world along with fun characters and a strong voice. It's also a great mix of teenage girl and the world Carter has built.

Cammie is a fun and sprightly character with a comical nature. Her asides and extra thoughts bring character and humor to the book. Despite her unconventional upbringing as the daughter of spies, and now a student of a secret spy school, Cammie's age still comes through the pages. Her relationship with her mom is close- for spies- and adds a great element to the overall story. Though seemingly the leader of her small group of friends, primarily because she's the narrator, Cammie gets along easily with people and shares her problems, for the most part, with them. The overall lack of any animosity between the set also makes this book a great, light read.

Bex and Liz are constantly present and their strong personalities also come through. Bex is tough skinned and would be able to hold her own in any fight even if she wasn't a spy, while Liz prefers the comfort of science over knowing how to take someone out with a magazine. Both girls add something to not only each other and Cammie but the plot as well. Macey, the new student and their roommate, also drives the plot in her own way. Josh is a great love interest- caring and sweet. The glimpses of his family life also make a great addition, overall, and build his character strongly.

One of the most entertaining aspects of this book was watching the girls try to decode boys. Isolated in an all girl's school, with little outside contact, boys are an even bigger mystery than normal. That is, until Macey shows up from a life of private schools and already knowing plenty about boys. Their conversations and determination to figure out Josh is filled with comical banter and scientific focus. The over analysis of most everything related to Josh is reminiscent of many teenage girls, spies or not, and holds a strong age-related element as a result.

The world is a fantastically well built one. Carter constantly slips in small things to bring the school and methods to life, along with remind the reader of the different mindset and view Cammie has a result of her upbringing. From Gallagher Girl inventions to underground top secret classrooms, Carter has not slacked off with her world.

The plot itself is entertaining, focusing both on introducing the characters and worlds while also sticking to the set premise. The pace stays steady with plenty of small things to fill in the gaps between the larger events and the final scenes are filled with action and entertainment. The writing is good, giving Cammie a strong voice and really seeming like something she'd say and holds a simplistic nature in terms of getting everything across.

Overall, this one is a great read when you're in the mood for a light pick me up. Despite some of the sadder parts, it maintains an upbeat air overall. Tying up much of the prominent plot points of this book, it also leaves things open for the next installment without any major cliffhangers in the process.


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You.
sign in »

No comments have been added yet.