Nikki's Reviews > Speak
Speak
by Laurie Halse Anderson (Goodreads Author)
by Laurie Halse Anderson (Goodreads Author)
Fourth book for the readathon.
I've been meaning to read Speak for a while. I heard about it when it was banned by some school or other, and the main issue involved -- rape, although there are others -- is something that interests me, in fiction. I wanted to know how it was handled in a YA novel.
Turns out, reasonably well. I'm not sure if cynical is the right word for it, but the voice of the narrator didn't quite work for me, anyway. She seemed a bit too cool and analytical about it all, though I'm sure there are teens like that. Possibly even my sister. Anyway, I thought it was mostly well-handled. I don't remember teachers or school being quite like that -- it's a technicolour, extra-dramatic version -- but I identified with a lot of it. I identified with not being able to speak out, too.
So, should it be banned in schools? No. There are kids out there who need it. Sure, it's not a pretty story, but it's not an endless pit of despair, either. I'm sure it's helping people find their voices.
I've been meaning to read Speak for a while. I heard about it when it was banned by some school or other, and the main issue involved -- rape, although there are others -- is something that interests me, in fiction. I wanted to know how it was handled in a YA novel.
Turns out, reasonably well. I'm not sure if cynical is the right word for it, but the voice of the narrator didn't quite work for me, anyway. She seemed a bit too cool and analytical about it all, though I'm sure there are teens like that. Possibly even my sister. Anyway, I thought it was mostly well-handled. I don't remember teachers or school being quite like that -- it's a technicolour, extra-dramatic version -- but I identified with a lot of it. I identified with not being able to speak out, too.
So, should it be banned in schools? No. There are kids out there who need it. Sure, it's not a pretty story, but it's not an endless pit of despair, either. I'm sure it's helping people find their voices.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Speak.
sign in »

