Jenny's Reviews > I Am Number Four

I Am Number Four by Pittacus Lore

by
3649640
's review
Oct 21, 10

bookshelves: kids-ya, spec-fiction
Recommended for: Fans of Heroes
Read from September 20 to 23, 2010

Just discovered through the I Am Number Four movie website (due for release 2011) that the author of this work is in fact James Frey, known for his best-selling so-called memoir, which proved to be a pack of lies: A Million Little Pieces. Not sure I'm happy putting money in this con's pocked.

To the book: Love the premise. Who can resist a story about aliens masquerading as humans, hiding from a despicable race of killers? Well, not me. This is the story of number four, one of nine children sent to earth to escape a ravaged race. Now the bad guys are hunting each down one by one -- in order, I might add. Number four and his carer move frequently and change identities, but it doesn't stop the vampirish baddies finding them. Maybe they should have thought to bed down in a nice, quiet Armish community. What ensues (naturally) is a battle, which at its conclusion sets things up nicely for the next five or so books to come in this new series.

There's lots of secret superhero stuff and action here so kids should be happy. From a writer's perspective, the story is lacking on oh so many fronts: dead-pan narration, cliched cardboard characters and a very predictable plot that offers absoltuely no surprises. Given that I could say the same about Twilight, that hardly means much.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read I Am Number Four.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Matthew Thats exactly how I felt when I found out James Frey wrote this book. I felt tricked and ripped off. If James Frey actually put his name on this book...no one would pick it up.


message 2: by Kelly (new)

Kelly James Frey is nothing but cocky and arrogant. I read "A Million Little Pieces" way back in the day. I have to say, I still have a grudge, but watching the trailer for "I Am Number Four" looks awesome. Who knows.....might pick it up.


Jenny Matthew wrote: "Thats exactly how I felt when I found out James Frey wrote this book. I felt tricked and ripped off. If James Frey actually put his name on this book...no one would pick it up."

Ripped-off is right. I wish I'd known before buying the book. Why is it these types of people always do well?


back to top