Erica's Reviews > Gregor and the Curse of the Warmbloods
Gregor and the Curse of the Warmbloods (Underland Chronicles, #3)
by Suzanne Collins, Paul Boehmer
by Suzanne Collins, Paul Boehmer
Erica's review
bookshelves: animals, audiobook, evil-creatures, fantasy, growing-up, meh, men-and-boys, other-worlds, sisters, unengaging
Sep 15, 10
bookshelves: animals, audiobook, evil-creatures, fantasy, growing-up, meh, men-and-boys, other-worlds, sisters, unengaging
Read in September, 2010
Have these Underlanders ever, since Mr. Sandwich took them below, had a non-prophecy day? It seems to me that Gregor is always hopping down the air shaft to go fufill some underground prophecy and no one bats an eye (or eyes a bat, ha ha ha), like prophecy-fulfilling is a daily thing, something everyone knows about and engages in from birth. Like breathing and eating. It makes me think that Sandwich and others scheduled every day from now until the series ends with prophecy-doing.
Getting Gregor to the Underland is beginning to feel contrived, the prophecies even more so. I think it would have been easier to just lump all the cryptic rhymes together to form one quest that could take place over the course of the many books.
These are beginning to take on the Harry Potter rhythm I often find so frustrating: Start at home where things are rough (in Gregor's case, it's near-poverty and a missing parent, rather than living in a closet in the home of gluttonous relatives), go to a magical place, do something great, then return home. Next book, start again.
I will keep listening to the series; I like the idea. I like the cockroaches. And, amazingly enough, Gregor is growing and maturing. There's enough there that makes me want to continue the story, but the individual books are becoming harder and harder for me to follow without a lot of heavy sighing.
Getting Gregor to the Underland is beginning to feel contrived, the prophecies even more so. I think it would have been easier to just lump all the cryptic rhymes together to form one quest that could take place over the course of the many books.
These are beginning to take on the Harry Potter rhythm I often find so frustrating: Start at home where things are rough (in Gregor's case, it's near-poverty and a missing parent, rather than living in a closet in the home of gluttonous relatives), go to a magical place, do something great, then return home. Next book, start again.
I will keep listening to the series; I like the idea. I like the cockroaches. And, amazingly enough, Gregor is growing and maturing. There's enough there that makes me want to continue the story, but the individual books are becoming harder and harder for me to follow without a lot of heavy sighing.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Gregor and the Curse of the Warmbloods.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Tim
(new)
Sep 16, 2010 11:57am
More tedious, repetitive fantasy. Blehhh.
reply
|
flag
*
You know, Tim, the original plot is a good idea. It's aimed at the 8-12 age group and is imaginative enough to spark interest and even (don't laugh) discussion. Because of that, I am disappointed the manifestation doesn't live up to the overall design and even more disappointed with that tedious repetition.
Are you familiar with the Hero's Journey? It's a format that most fantasy follows, so there is a reason why it seems "reptitive": http://www.mcli.dist.maricopa.edu/smc...Though I do agree that following a prophecy in every book is starting to get a bit old.
Hey, that's a handy little explanation sheet, Becky! I rather like that. I wish I'd have had access to it back in my college years; I so would have referenced it endlessly.In this particular case, though, I felt one prophecy had already been fulfilled so why do new prophecies centered around the same people keep popping up? I thought it was a bit of a cop-out. Gregor should have come up with his own quests, not been victim to prophecy after prophecy.
