Hayden's Reviews > The Lying Game

The Lying Game by Sara Shepard
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Lying Game is the first book in Shepard's The Lying Game series, which is pretty obvious, but I felt like informing you regardless. The premise of the book involves three things I have very-little-to-no experience with in my entire history of reading:
1) identical twins
2) identities
3) such well-done and dramatic TENSION

Ms. Sara Shepard is the Goddess of Tension. She kinda seriously needs this shirt.

1) Identical Twins
The only book I think I've ever read that stars identical twins is Identical, but that is on such a different wavelength than The Lying Game that they're pretty hard to compare. The plot of The Lying Game revolves around long-lost twin sisters, Emma and Sutton, who arrange to meet in Sutton's current town of residency (I think I remember it being Tucson!). Emma stumbles upon a YouTube video of Sutton being strangled with a necklace by a mysterious figure, and the video has no sound, so she can't tell who the strangler is. She hunts Sutton down on Facebook and arranages to meet in Tucson. There's only one problem with this arrangement: Sutton is dead.
And that, my friends, is the big bomb that drops in the introduction/prologue of The Lying Game: Sutton is dead, and she's watching over everything Emma does.
Emma goes to Tucson to meet Sutton, snd she is coerced into pretending to be Sutton (after all, they're identical twins, and they look exactly the same) to figure out who murdered her.
To me, this premise is ingenious, for one because it's never been done before (like the overused I-don't-know-what-you-are-but-I-love-you-anyway trope that occurs in 99.8% of YA PNR) and for two because it's just SO FREAKING COOL!

2) Identities
The topic of becoming another identity has interested me for the longest time, and it's probably one of the reasons I was so drawn to this book. The way Shepard writes Emma, Sutton and their differences is mind-blowing. She's truly a talented woman.

3) The Tension
Oh my God the tension.

Shepard writes tension like high school students write crappy essays. Except, without the crappy part. And without the essays part. And with the tension part.
Be warned if you're going to read this: the tension is so high you will never want to put it down. Not unless the next one is within a ten-mile radius of you and you have a car or some other valid type of transportation excluding your feet of course because who wants to walk ten miles just to get a sequel, especially if the weather isn't nice and you're not presentable and you don't want to do anything except sit there and think about the book you just read and its sequel which is not in your hands but it should be but it's not?

The one thing I didn't like about the book: the product placements. I'm pretty sure there were above 10 iPhone references, not to mention countless other things. It kind of dragged down the story for me. It was still great, but it could've used a little less iThing references.
1 like · Likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Lying Game.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

01/01/2011 page 7
2.0% "What makes me think I'm going to like this A LOT more than the Pretty Little Liars series? Oh, maybe the fact that a different designer name isn't mentioned in every sentence??"
09/06/2011 page 39
13.0% "Definitely has me interested so far, to say the least. This is my 2nd read, but to be fair, the first time I skimmed a little (A LOT)."
09/06/2011 page 75
24.0% "Thrilling book."
09/06/2011 page 105
34.0% "This is good. Very good. Tension is high, and I love it."
09/06/2011 page 110
36.0% "Lots of iThing references."
09/06/2011 page 118
38.0% "Her friends are absolute bitches." 3 comments
09/06/2011 page 127
41.0% "Dang. This is actually really well-written and absorbing if I SLOW DOWN..."
09/06/2011 page 136
44.0% "Note to self for review: -tense -fast-paced -PopCulture REFERENCES!"
09/08/2011 page 254
83.0% "Ethan is AMAZING. I lurve him (and that's more than I can say about any of the other characters)."
show 2 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Holly (new)

Holly hey Hayden! u shud help me find a book! :P im looking for a fiction book that can let my m ind fly wild! like in Eragon and Warriors!

Hayden Holly wrote: "hey Hayden! u shud help me find a book! :P im looking for a fiction book that can let my m ind fly wild! like in Eragon and Warriors!"

1) Eragon sucked.
2) Hmmm... maybe Uglies?
3) Maybe The Warrior Heir.
4) Or The Looking Glass Wars.

back to top