Regina's Reviews > The Secret History

The Secret History by Donna Tartt

by
3104032
's review
Jun 26, 11

bookshelves: available-at-library, literature, book-club-10-11, available-audio-library, owned-kindle, favorites, favorite-authors, award-winner
Recommended to Regina by: Gena
Recommended for: Fans of Tana French, Fans of psychological thrillers
Read from June 09 to 26, 2011

This book embodies everything that I love in fiction, it is a perfect example of why I love to read. Every word and phrase that appears on the pages of this book (and it is pages, as this book is not available in ebook format as of yet!) is so beautiful and so rich. Everytime I sat down to read this book, I felt as if I was in the midst of eating a perfectly cooked filet mignon and a very rich but salty potato side dish accompanied by a strong red wine. This book was a true treat for my senses. It is a character driven book, the characters are central and the tale is about them – not about their surroundings or their events. It is the characters that rule this tale. So what was this book about? Excess, consumption, greed, selfishness, loss of innocence, pack think and ego maniacs – sound delicious?

The setting for this tale is a small, secluded (and mythical) Vermont liberal arts college populated by elite students. The story is told from the point of view of a male transfer student who is running from his blue collar background and his disinterested parents. He escapes into a group of students who have further secluded themselves from the student body even more in this remote environment. Richard – the protagonist – begins to study classics, focusing on Greek and attempts to pretend he is someone he is not - privileged, wealthy, elite. The circle of friends he finds himself among, appear to all be very wealthy and focused on academics in a way that is very odd for modern college students. They are extremely insular, not willing to permit anyone into their ranks. Richard, now admitted after he demonstrates his knowledge of ancient Greek, begins crafting himself in the image of those around him. The opening scene (in fact the prologue) begins with a murder scene, there is no mystery here. The reader knows who dies and how. The murderers are clear, there is no question as to motive. The focus of the story are the events leading up to the murder and the murders aftermath on its participants. What Tartt unwraps for the reader is a very disturbing tale. Will a need to fit in trump morality? What needs to happen for a person to separate from a group focused on hurting those around them? Or will most people just follow the group, no matter the evil effects on those around them? What is the greater good – is it the survival of a group of friends? The story is about loss of innocence, the extreme focus inward to the neglect of else, and group think. It is a beautiful and haunting tale. I thoroughly enjoyed every minute spent reading this book.

Readers who enjoyed Tana French’s The Likeness, will enjoy this book.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Secret History.
sign in »

Quotes Regina Liked

Donna Tartt
“Beauty is rarely soft or consolatory. Quite the contrary. Genuine beauty is always quite alarming.”
Donna Tartt, The Secret History

Donna Tartt
“Beauty is terror. Whatever we call beautiful, we quiver before it.”
Donna Tartt, The Secret History

Donna Tartt
“I suppose at one time in my life I might have had any number of stories, but now there is no other. This is the only story I will ever be able to tell.”
Donna Tartt, The Secret History

Donna Tartt
“It is easy to see things in retrospect. But I was ignorant then of everything but my own happiness, and I don’t know what else to say except that life itself seemed very magical in those days: a web of symbol, coincidence, premonition, omen. Everything, somehow, fit together; some sly and benevolent Providence was revealing itself by degrees and I felt myself trembling on the brink of a fabulous discovery, as though any morning it was all going to come together–my future, my past, the whole of my life–and I was going to sit up in bed like a thunderbolt and say oh! oh! oh!”
Donna Tartt, The Secret History


Reading Progress

06/13/2011
1.0% "This is so damned good!"
06/16/2011
10.0% "Dark, with a little bit of scary around the edges. Loving this book."
06/21/2011
30.0% "This book is just so darned good!"
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-32 of 32) (32 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Kerstin I read this years ago and absolutely loved it! Glad you're enjoying it as well.


Regina I saw you gave It 5 stars. It is such a great book.


Kerstin I remember I loved all the characters, including their flaws. The author fleshed them out so beautifully. I may have to do a re-read sometime soon :)


Regina Kerstin have you read her other book?


Kerstin No, I haven't read it yet. The book-blurb never excited me all that much and a few people I know who really loved "The Secret History" were less than impressed by it. I may pick it up eventually though.


Regina I just checked my GR friends and they also gave it a significantly lower rating as well!


message 7: by D.G. (new)

D.G. Sounds great! My library has it so I'm just adding it to my wish list right now. :)


Regina It is a beautifully rich book. Kinda like eating a steak dinner with a beautiful potato side dish and a very rich red wine.


message 9: by Flannery (new) - added it

Flannery You didn't even have to write a review. After you wrote that fans of Tana French and psychological thrillers would like it, I was in. I still enjoyed the review, though:)


message 10: by Tatiana (new) - added it

Tatiana It all does sound delicious, Regina:)


Galla I remember really liking this one, too. I'm tempted to re-read it now.


Regina Thanks everyone! Sounds odd, but I am looking forward to a re-read in the future.


message 13: by D.G. (new)

D.G. Did you listen to this one Regina? I just found out that the author is doing the narration and want to find out if she's any good.


Regina I read it DG. I did download the audio from overdrive. It has 28 parts. I listened to the free sample on audible.com and read the reviews on audible. I also listened to snippets here and there. Ultimately I deleted the audio. I preferred reading it bc it is such a rich and satisfying text and I hate to say it, but I didnt like her narrated version. Also the author is from Missippi, the setting though is on Vermont and involves characters from California, st louis, new York and Boston - but the author/narrator reads the book with her southern accent. I also just did not care for her voice. I say listen to the sample on audible.com.


message 15: by D.G. (new)

D.G. I'll listen to the sample but I can tell just by your description that I won't like it. As soon as I realized the author was doing the narration, I was very skeptical that it would be any good, I mean, how many authors are really good actors and can do a good job narrating a book?


Regina I agree!! Also the story is told from a man's first person POV and the author narrating is a female!


Catie Yeah, I downloaded the audio last night, but I'll probably just delete it...I saw that it was the author narrating and that always makes me nervous.


message 18: by D.G. (new)

D.G. Regina wrote: "I agree!! Also the story is told from a man's first person POV and the author narrating is a female!"

Oh yeah...great idea.

Unless Dickens comes back from the death to narrate his books (he was famous for performing scenes of his books in theaters), I don't think it's a good idea for an author to do this. Leave the narration to the professionals so they can do justice to your story!


Catie Yeah, the only author that I know of who has pulled it off is Neil Gaiman. He actually does a fabulous job!


Regina Tina Fey did a fabulous job narrating Bossypants but that is different. :)

I keep meaning to read American Gods. Maybe I will do the audio.


Catie Oh yeah, I forgot about Bossypants! I guess that is different. I've also heard that David Cross does a funny narration of his book I Drink for a Reason.


Megan Clarke yeah! love that you loved this. gena got me to read it as well and it is one of my favorite books. perfectly written.


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

Fantastic review Regina. I have to admit I'm not a huge DT fan, but you've summed up the book nicely.


Regina Megan, I enjoyed this book so much -- I am thrilled it was Genea's wedding anniversary but sad she missed our discussion. Lauren did not read it (if you can believe that!) -- so it was a milder and shorter discussion -- still fun though. I cannot wait to read Tartt's other book. I know it has gotten less appreciation, but I just love how she puts words together. I heard she is working on a 3rd book, I hope she hurries up. 3 books writen over 2.5-3 decades, hmmmm.

Moss I remember you sayng that in a forum, but thank you for still enjoying my review!


message 25: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Nice review. I read Tartt's "The Little Friend" a few years ago, and I loved it. Now that I've read your review, I am inclined to pick up SH much sooner.


Catie Wow, I just re-read this and it's amazing how much we agreed on. It's obvious that we had a lot of the same thoughts about this book! So, let's chat! What are your questions?


Annabel Smith I did like the moral element of this but I think the characters needed more development.


Regina Annabel, I have heard other people say that. Which characters did you think needed to be developed more? It is a weird dichotomy it is both character and story driven, but in the end maybe more story driven?


Annabel Smith To some extent all the big 6 were a bit wishy washy to me. For a long time i felt that Henry, Francis and Charles were basically the same and it took ages to start to separate them as characters. Henry's nebulousness made sense as the book progressed but Francis was a pretty redundant character really. And Richard was very weak - although again, that was part of the story. I read a really scathing review which criticised vanillas character for being basically decorative and I couldn't help but agree. I think she did her best characterisation on the peripheral characters - people like Judy Poovey were much more real to me than the 6 central characters.


Regina That is interesting. I see what you are saying, although for me it didn't seem to be missing form the storyline.

Have you read anything by Tana French? Her book The Likeness (which should be read after In The Woods) is similar in many ways to The Secret History. But I think French does a very good job at characterization.


Annabel Smith Haha I just noticed my iPhone changed "Camilla's" to vanillas - which given my criticisms is quite appropriate!

Thanks for the tip on Tana French.


Regina Funny! I noticed that too.


back to top