Shanshad Whelan's Reviews > Web of Lies
Web of Lies (Elemental Assassin, #2)
by Jennifer Estep (Goodreads Author)
by Jennifer Estep (Goodreads Author)
Shanshad Whelan's review
bookshelves: fantasy, series, urban-fantasy
Aug 23, 10
bookshelves: fantasy, series, urban-fantasy
Read in August, 2010
I really really wish I could say I liked this book--I like a lot of the worldbuilding, and the plotting is rather entertaining. There's steamy romance, a hard nosed assassin with a good heart and a great talent for cooking. There are some fascinating secondary characters. I have a minor grievance with opting for ice rather than water and stone rather than earth as the major elemental powers against fire and air, but that's authorial choice.
This big problem, and the reason I had to put this book down is that the author keeps repeating descriptions, explanations and phrases about her characters, motivation, landscape etc. I don't mind a little catch-up at the beginning of a story. I easily forgave the first chapters of rehashing, since every series author has to do some of it. But it didn't stop. I don't need to have Sophia's goth character mentioned every time she steps in screen. I don't need to know again that Finn is a ladykiller and a financial criminal. I don't need to have Caine's conflict with liking Gin reiterated again and again.
Please Please more show less tell. We don't need endlessly to be reminded of traits and the like. We know by now Southland is dangerous, that the Pork Pit means everything to Gin, that Sophia talks in grunts. Tell the audience once and then trust them to remember the details and simply show your characters without adding the narrative to explain them.
I can't finish this book. If there's one deathsong for me in a book that I should otherwise like, it's writing that keeps tripping me up and making me annoyed. Simon Green does it to me too, for different reasons. I really wanted to like Estep's series, but after this, I think I'll leave it to others.
This big problem, and the reason I had to put this book down is that the author keeps repeating descriptions, explanations and phrases about her characters, motivation, landscape etc. I don't mind a little catch-up at the beginning of a story. I easily forgave the first chapters of rehashing, since every series author has to do some of it. But it didn't stop. I don't need to have Sophia's goth character mentioned every time she steps in screen. I don't need to know again that Finn is a ladykiller and a financial criminal. I don't need to have Caine's conflict with liking Gin reiterated again and again.
Please Please more show less tell. We don't need endlessly to be reminded of traits and the like. We know by now Southland is dangerous, that the Pork Pit means everything to Gin, that Sophia talks in grunts. Tell the audience once and then trust them to remember the details and simply show your characters without adding the narrative to explain them.
I can't finish this book. If there's one deathsong for me in a book that I should otherwise like, it's writing that keeps tripping me up and making me annoyed. Simon Green does it to me too, for different reasons. I really wanted to like Estep's series, but after this, I think I'll leave it to others.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Web of Lies.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Marcia
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Sep 03, 2010 10:33am
The repetitions drove me crazy, too. I'm glad to hear I wasn't the only one.
reply
|
flag
*
Wow - my thoughts exactly! Another benefit of cutting out the repeats? A shorter book... trying to finish a 400 page book is rather daunting if I'm not fully immersed in the story! Still trying at the moment...Update: Finally settled into the story about halfway through the book - worth the initial struggle I do believe. I will certainly try my luck with the third book! =)
