Eric's Reviews > The City of Ember

The City of Ember by Jeanne DuPrau

by
697371
's review
Jan 05, 08

bookshelves: science-fiction, young-adult
Read in January, 2006

The City of Ember is a young adult novel that is a fantastic allegory for spiritual awakening, though I have no idea if it was intended as such. The story is of a girl who lives in an underground and completely self-contained city created by the “Builders.” The population of the city knows of nothing outside the city, in fact, though they speak English many of the words in it like “sky” are not understood in any terms but metaphorically. The problem is that the city is falling apart, the lights are going out, the vast stores of supplies of light bulbs, canned food, and vitamins are running out. The reader is in on a worse calamity, namely, that a secret message in a timed lock box that was left by the Builders, which was meant to be handed down from mayor to mayor and that would open just in time to explain to the city dwellers how to get out of the city, was lost many generations back. Well, being a young adult novel it’s pretty predictable in that the box is in our hero’s closet, but a nice turn of events it is found by our hero’s baby sister who chews on it for a while before our hero gets her hands on it leaving the message is only partially legible. So the bulk of the story is the deciphering of the message, followed by the experience of trying to communicate its contents to the adults, who of course don’t accept the message (where else is there but here?) which is the equivalent of all prophets experiences of rejection by the status-quo. And finally, there is the adventure of eventual escape.
This book reworks the universal theme of Plato’s cave, and of all mysticism. What we think of as the whole universe is but shadow, and further, that to enter that “kingdom of heaven” you must be like a child. The insight that this version of that universal story led me to is part of the answer to why childishness is a necessary component of the transformation. Children haven’t yet become someone. Which means who they are is not yet at stake. For some reason our culture has this question “what are you going to be when you grow up?” Think about the hidden structures and assumptions in that question. Who are you? Have you figured it out yet? Is what you do, who you are? Is what you believe who you are? Is who you associate with who you are? I write these questions myself in shadow not in the condition of childishness, and with all of this, as Quaker’s say, “a notion,” i.e. not something that I have experienced, but rather something I think. But this thing that is mostly a notion for me, that the distinction between notional and experiential living is key to awakening, I am begining in small ways to actually experience.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The City of Ember.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Rachelle Interesting take on the book. I hadn't seen it that way. So what do you make of the "believers"? I took it to be somewhat anti-religious in that the believers where the kooks who kind of stood around singing and waiting for someone to save them rather than do something useful.


Darryl Rachelle wrote: "I took it to be somewhat anti-religious in that the believers where the kooks who kind of stood around singing and waiting..."

That was my take on it too, but the author doesn't really explore that avenue enough to make it a meaningful part of the plot. We get to make of it what we will. But based on what I've read about the third book in the series, our impression is no accident.


Eric There is a world of a difference between religiosity (being a "believer") and true spiritual awakening. Perhaps she has the believers in there precisely to point this out. Perhaps the believers are akin to the fundamentalists of our world today, who carry on an echo of what was once a spiritual awakening for a previous age, but no longer has relevance and, more importantly, is not born from personal authentic experience, but held to by supposed "faith" which is actually a mental attachment.


Lauren Interesting analysis. I didn't think of Plato's allegory of the cave until I read your review, but now that I'm thinking about it, that's a great comparison. That definitely helps me get past the childish (simplistic?) writing style for a book classified as YA.


David I liked your interpretation. My take on the book's primary theme, however, was the need to take care of the earth. The believers I took as those who use Jesus's return as a justification for not caring about stewardship over nature.


message 6: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Parrado i haven't read the book but as to our interpretation i think i might like it so i will definetly try and read it. thanks.



message 7: by Paulette (new)

Paulette I joined Goodreads as a way to get an idea about what books are worth reading through reader reviews. The Ember series came up as complimentary to some of my favourites and your review has tickled my curiousity so thanks, thats what I want from a review.


Mandie Mc I saw it as a spiritual awakening, too. An awakening from the deep, dark world of "where else is there but here? Our way is the only possible way. We are the only light in the darkness" to realizing that sometimes you have to challenge the authorities (even the religious ones) who SAY they are doing "what's best" and think for yourself (as the mayor says, curiosity is seen as bad, just as in most conservative religions). When you do that, you find out there's a big, beautiful world waiting for you, of things you never knew.


Reagan U enjoyed it as well


back to top