Chrissie's Reviews > Nicholas and Alexandra

Nicholas and Alexandra by Robert K. Massie

by
632247
's review
Jun 19, 13

bookshelves: bio, soviet-union, favorites, history
Read from March 06 to 14, 2011

NO SPOILERS!!!

On completion: I very highly recommend this book to those interested in Nicholas and Alexandra Romanov, to anyone interested in Russian history, to those interested in the beginning of Bolshevism in Russia and also to those who enjoy historical biographies written by talented authors. Massie can write. He knows his subject, in and out, backward and forward. There are detailed notes to every chapter. You never have to doubt the accuracy of that which you are reading. He analyzes all the possibilities. Moreover, he does all this without ever boring the reader. I feel I truly understand who Nicholas, Alexandra and Alexis were as people. I come away with an understand of who these individuals really were. No other books I have read has ever done this to wonderfully. The book included photos and a family tree.

You do have to be awake to read the book :0). At one point there I was getting kind of tired..... Beyond praising the book, I praise the author. Massie has written a book on Peter the Great, Peter the Great: His Life and World, and it is said he will come out with a book on Catherine the Great in November, Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman. I want to read both very, very much. I find none of them available in Kindle, which is quite a disappointment......but I haven't given up searching.

If you like crime novel, read this instead! This is the real thing.

Oh, one more thing, you must read this book to learn about Rasputin and hemophilia! And if there is a moral to the book, it is tell people what is going on. If you don't, others will dream up a bunch of incorrect explanations.

Through page 358: This book gives an engaging and very clear odescription of the time period leading up to WW1. The author explains in both in broad terms and then with nteresting details. I must say very clearly that this book is detailed, and it is a book of history. There are sections where I am fatigued by military strategies and battles. To say this doesn't happen would be untrue. Or maybe I am just plain tired and should go to bed.....

Through page 161: The research is thorough and impeccable. There are tons of details, but never do I feel swamped. I believe some sections will appeal to one reader and others to another. None is boring. I was less drawn to the detailed analysis of the 1905 Revolution, but then the next chapter switched to life at Tsarskoe Selo, and I was enchanted. The Catherine and Alexander Palaces situated on the grounds, although diametrically different, are both beautifully described. Then the text goes on to describe the minute characteristics of the five children and Alexandra. You cannot leave this chapter without feeling immersed into each one's personal traits. All is documented and accurately portrayed. And terribly interesting.

Through Part One, page 114: The book details the political alliances and military occurences taking place at the beginning tof the 20th century. To enjoy this book you must be interested in history. The Russian war against Japan, the French, English and German alliances, Kaiser William II's maneuvering all of this is discussed.

Throgh: page 77: If you are curious about the last Tsar of Russia, read this book. It will not disappoint. You are given a thorough understanding of what shaped Nicholas and Alexandra. Childhood experiences are always life-determining, and here they are laid out in a clear and interesting manner. You understand why Alexandra is shy, why she feels a kinship with the Russian people, the serfs freed by Alexander II, rather than the elite. You come to understand why, in turn, she was not welcomed by the Russian elite, at least not now in the beginning, immediately after her marriage with Nicholas. You come to understand the tension that arose between her and the Empress Dowager. Alexandra's German mother died when she was five. She was primarily raised by her grandmother, Queen Victoria. She and Nicholas were married only one week after the funeral of Nicholas' father. His death was unexpected. He was only 49! She was forced to convert to the Russian Orthodox Church from the Lutheran faith, a prerequisite for the marriage. She was totally unprepared for what lay before her. And the same was true for Nicholas. It was a marriage of love, they chose each other, and they got their way. Of course there were several important leaders that approved!

Not only do we learn about Nicholas and Alexandra in a fascinating manner, but also other individuals. We learn of Lenin's (Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov's)youth.

He was an excellent student in school, and when the other Ulyanov children brought their marks home and solemnly reported them to their parents, Volodya (as he was called at home) simply burst through the door and up the stairs, shouting "Excellent in everything!"(page 76)

His mother, Maria Blank, was a Volga German. Enough! If you find this fascinating I recommend the book to you.

**********************************

Having just begun the book, I am blown over by the author's way with words. Wow, can Robert Massie describe landscapes so you can see them, sparkle or huddle in the cold. I am not going to tell you what the book is about. For that you can read the book description. Here follows a quote so you can taste the writing:

Despite the Mediterranean style, St. Petersburg was a northern city where the Arctic latitudes played odd tricks with light and time. Winter nights began early in the afternoon and lasted until the middle of the following morning. Icy winds and whistling snowstorms swept across the flat plain surrounding the city to lash the walls and the windows of the Renaissance palaces and freeze the Neva hard as steel. Over the baroque spires and the frozen canals danced the strange fires of the aurora borealis. Occasionally a brilliant day would break the gloomy monotony. The sky would turn a crystal blue and the snowflakes on the trees, rooftops and gilded domes would sparkle with sunlight so bright that the eye could not bear the dazzling glare. Winter was a great leveler. Tsar, priest and factory worker all layered themselves in clothing and upon coming in from the street, headed straight to the bubbling samovar for a glass of hot tea. (page 7)

Don't you want to be there and breathe in the cold crisp air? Doesn't the teas scorch your throat? For me, how a book is written is much more important than the plot line! This is beautiful writing, and the author wonderfully blends in history so you do not even know you are learning! I like this book

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Nicholas and Alexandra.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-50 of 61) (61 new)


message 1: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura I'm planning to read this book, I will wait for your review then.


Chrissie OK. Isn't the quote beautiful?


message 3: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura splendid!!


message 4: by Gundula (new) - added it

Gundula I think my library might even have this!!


Chrissie Gundula, it ought to. Massie is very well known. Let me finish it and see if it continues this good. I am only on page 30.


message 6: by Gundula (new) - added it

Gundula Chrissie wrote: "Gundula, it ought to. Massie is very well known. Let me finish it and see if it continues this good. I am only on page 30."

I've got way too much to read at the moment anyhow (and it always takes me ages to write reviews). I hope the book continues to be good.


Chrissie I hope so too. I think it will.


message 8: by Naomi (new)

Naomi I can't wait to see your take on this. These individuals have always fascinated me...


Chrissie I have read others about them. They are fascinating.


message 10: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Have you read Catherine the Great? A very interesting book and the author kindly accepted my invitation to join GR.


message 11: by Chrissie (last edited Mar 07, 2011 11:48am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chrissie Laura, I haven't read it, but I do have it on my lists. I think they read this in the European Royalty Group awhile back. Massie's book on Catherine the Great is coming out in November.


message 12: by Elli (new)

Elli I ordered the PBS DVD of Catherine the Great from Netflix and we'll see what that's like. Thought I ordered House of Day, House of Night from the Library and what came was E.E. in it's Cyrillic alphabet language!


message 13: by Elli (new)

Elli Yowtch!


Chrissie Elli, what does Yowtch mean? Good luck with your purchases! What you don't know Cyrillic languages?! ;0) Well I don't either.


message 15: by Emily (new) - added it

Emily I have this book on my shelf and it has sat there for years. You are inspiring me to pick it up and start reading.


Chrissie It is definitely good. I have remorse now b/c I got my Kindle today. I want to read a book on that. I mean, it is so much easier reading from the Kindle than the small text in a book! I have paper books I MUST read. I WANT to read them. T I have some great books waiting to be read, but the big font is so very, very nice in the Kindle.

Emily, this is a fabulous book.


message 17: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Beautiful review, Chrissi. The story is so intriguing.

I'm glad to see that you received your Kindle and that you like it.


Chrissie Thanks Barbara, I adore the large clear text. Why did I wait so long?!


message 19: by Chelsea (new) - added it

Chelsea Chrissie, Thanks for the great update on N&A. I'm sold, it is going on TBR.


Chrissie It is ahistory book, but extremely well told!


message 21: by Jasja (new)

Jasja My mum has been raving about this book... and now you have me thiking I really should borrow it from her one day. And good to see you are enjoying your ereader ! :-)


Chrissie Eclipse, I can only read one book at a time. I have to finish my DTB before I start Ava's Man on the Kindle. I couldn't possible give up N&A. I have experimented with the reading font and totally love it! However it is harder to find ebooks for the Kindle that I want to read than normal DTB. I have over 100 DTB which I have bought and intend to read. I am NOT going to buy the same book in two versions.

I suggest you borrow your Mom's book. Occasionally Moms know what they are talking about. Me, I do hate when books are pushed down my throat. I joined a Eastern European Challenge and immediately got annoyed and found a million other books I wanted to read. .....

BTW this author also has a book on Peter the Great and in November there will be a book on Cathrine the Great. What is annoying is that I cannot find any of them as ebooks! I am not buying more DTB until I finish the ones I have. Maybe....unless I get weak. No, it would be stupid to buy more DTB.


message 23: by Natalie (new) - added it

Natalie Chrissie, I used to read articles about the last Russian rulers, their son Alexis, Rasputin and so on. But a voluminous book - didn't read! It's very nice you've told about it, I've added the book.


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Vegan Chrissie, I'm so happy you loved this as much as I did when I read it decades ago!


message 25: by Kathy (new) - added it

Kathy Chrissie, thanks for recommending this book. I love to read about Nicholas and Alexandra and their family. I used to be obsessed (not in a bad way) with Anastasia.


Chrissie I have read numerous books about the last tsar. I think the laxt one I read was The Kitchen Boy: A Novel of the Last Tsar. Sure it was a fun book of historical fiction, but we are talking about two completely different kinds of books. I am sold on Massie. I will in the future always pick a book by him if he has written on a given subject which I am intersted in. The writing is thorough, accurate and engaging from start to finish.

Kathy, all the rumore about Anastasia are discussed. Massie never presents one version. He presents all the possibilities, shows the evidence and explains why he draws a given conclusion. The reader is free to have a different opinion if he so chooses. Massie uses this style through the whole book.

Lisa, I just loved it! Now I really want to find more by this author but in a Kindle format if possible. The Library of Congress might be able to help me with access to the Open Library, but it does seem a long procedure. We'll see what I can find out.

Natalie, I would love to hear your views on this book!

I really am glad you enjoyed my review, and I REALLY hope it pushes you to pick up this or another book by Massie! I am sold on this author.


Chrissie YAY, for Susanna! It was her that really pushed me to read this book, now rather than later. Also she has fixed the book description. It was depressing seeing the previos one that was so totally wrong for such a wonderful book!!!


message 28: by Julia (new) - added it

Julia chrissie, thanks for the recommendation - sounds interesting...


Chrissie This author makes everything he touches upon interesting.


message 30: by Gundula (new) - added it

Gundula I am going to try to order the book from the library again, they have it, but there was a line-up before, I guess the author is quite popular.


Susanna I believe he talks more about Anastasia in The Romanovs: the Final Chapter.

I have enjoyed everything of Massie's that I've read.

Chrissie - no problem!


Chrissie Susanna, I have written to Ramdom House, the publisher, asking if they couldn't make Massie's books available for Kindle. It doesn't hurt to try.

Kathy, maybe Susanna's book suggestion is the best for you.


message 33: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Vegan Chrissie wrote: "Susanna, I have written to Ramdom House, the publisher, asking if they couldn't make Massie's books available for Kindle. It doesn't hurt to try."

Chrissie. Great move! I hope they will. I think you should ask for all the books you're interested in. Why not try?!


Rebecca Huston It is an excellent book. While the final sections of the book are a bit dated (It was written in 1968, after all), what there is is spot on. I'm really looking forward to his biography of Catherine the Great, due later on this year. Excellent review, btw.


Chrissie Lisa, I did!

Rebecca, thank you.


Susanna There's sort of an "updated" version of the story from Massie, in his The Romanovs: the Final Chapter.


Chrissie Susanna, I have added this book too! For those too impatient to wait, look at this review of the book:
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

It does have spoilers, but for heavens sake this is history!


Susanna Psst, kid! The Titanic sinks!


message 39: by rivka (new)

rivka :faint:


message 40: by Chrissie (last edited Mar 16, 2011 11:22am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chrissie Susanna, oh really?! That's news. Jeeze, now you spoiled that for me too! Chuckles!

And rivka, he's a cutie.


message 41: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Rivka, I love it!! How do you do that??


message 42: by rivka (new)

rivka I use this Firefox extension for most of my smileys.


message 43: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Thank you, Rivka. I don't use it.


Chrissie Rivka, I keep away for all such gimmicks. I would rather not mess up my computer! I am not taking any chances, so thanks, but no thanks.


message 45: by Anita (new)

Anita Dalton Oooo... I am going to have to read this. I have always been fascinated by Alexandra Romanov. She married magical thinking with hard reality in a bizarre manner that I can never read too much about. Great review!


message 46: by Elli (new)

Elli Chrissie wrote: "Elli, what does Yowtch mean? Good luck with your purchases! What you don't know Cyrillic languages?! ;0) Well I don't either."

It's just that I was not prepared to open my new book, my eagerly awaited next read and to have my expectant mood knocked out from my seeing pages of print in a "no way" language. That's what I meant by Yowtch. Probably about like a pin stuck into a balloon!


message 47: by Elli (new)

Elli My present read, the Pict by Jack Dixon is moving rather quickly and is interesting. It has plenty of action and is described through the eyes of an heroic warrior. His tactical insights and his insistence on making use of the knowledge gained from wiser elders are noteworthy. Particularly the equivalent of freedom fighters on the home front which the Pict tribes were, and the far more numerous Roman army with different motivation, mainly either advancement or accepting this choice of saving your life and possible citizenship after defeat.


message 48: by Noran (new) - added it

Noran Miss Pumkin thanks for the excellent review--will have to add this one to my piles of books. :)


Chrissie Anita and Noran, thank you very much for telling me you liked my review/reviews. Maybe my exuberance for the author showed through! You know since I have joined GR I rarely read more than one book by the same author. There are so many authors begging to be read, so why stick with one? But, but, but when you run into an author such as Robert K. Massie all my rules go out the window. I am dying to read his next book which will be coming out later this year, the one on Catherine the Great! My only complaint is that his books are not available on Kindle, which I find easier to read. If they existed on Kindle I would go and buy them all - that is how good this author is! You know non-fiction never has to be boring; unfortunately it often is.

Elli, no I understand! Good word to remember!


Susanna Massie is really good, and a great read - I, too, am looking forward to his Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman.


« previous 1
back to top