Paul's Reviews > The Looming Tower: Al Qaeda and the Road to 9/11
The Looming Tower: Al Qaeda and the Road to 9/11
by Lawrence Wright
by Lawrence Wright
Paul's review
bookshelves: i-bet-i-never-finish-these, history-will-teach-us-nothing
Jan 18, 13
bookshelves: i-bet-i-never-finish-these, history-will-teach-us-nothing
Read in February, 2011
You can be nerdy and geeky and boring about all manner of things, railway timetables, cricket, fine wine, Marvel comics, Beatles flipsides, the confectionary you used to scoff when you were little (ah the nostalgic sweetmeats of childhood, how much of a lump in your throat were they then and still are now), campy 70s sitcoms, Jean-Marie Straub movies, the best places to go backpacking in Andalucia, bootlegs of the Velvet Underground, and so on boringly and tediously.
Turns out you can be geeky and tedious about 9/11 too. But perhaps not too surprising, as 90% of this book is about that shadowy alphabet world of espionage, counter-espionage, counter-counter-espionage and lots of sweaty men trying to pluck the one shiny needle of truth from the haystack of rancid "intelligence" that the world of spy vs spy vs spy showers like golden rain bountifully, munificently, all over the place in this information-soaked fun-packed palace of stupefied over-eaters we call the western world. Three blind counter-terrorist agencies - see how they run - they all ran after the farmer's wife - which was a grave error as she knew very little about al-Qaeda, as it turned out, after some strenuous waterboarding.
Anyway, I couldn't hack it, it made me feel slightly ill. Too much stuff about two giant boys towns, one better dressed than the other one, but only slightly.
Dispiriting is not the word.
Disgusting may be.
This has been another bad-tempered rant from your friend Paul Bryant of Nottingham. He ought to know better, but he doesn't.
Thank you for your patience.
Turns out you can be geeky and tedious about 9/11 too. But perhaps not too surprising, as 90% of this book is about that shadowy alphabet world of espionage, counter-espionage, counter-counter-espionage and lots of sweaty men trying to pluck the one shiny needle of truth from the haystack of rancid "intelligence" that the world of spy vs spy vs spy showers like golden rain bountifully, munificently, all over the place in this information-soaked fun-packed palace of stupefied over-eaters we call the western world. Three blind counter-terrorist agencies - see how they run - they all ran after the farmer's wife - which was a grave error as she knew very little about al-Qaeda, as it turned out, after some strenuous waterboarding.
Anyway, I couldn't hack it, it made me feel slightly ill. Too much stuff about two giant boys towns, one better dressed than the other one, but only slightly.
Dispiriting is not the word.
Disgusting may be.
This has been another bad-tempered rant from your friend Paul Bryant of Nottingham. He ought to know better, but he doesn't.
Thank you for your patience.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Looming Tower.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-11 of 11) (11 new)
date
newest »
newest »
after reading half of this book only one song seems appropriateYou can’t depend on your family
You can’t depend on your friends
You can’t depend on a beginning
You can’t depend on an end
You can’t depend on intelligence
Ooohhh, you can’t depend on god
You can only depend on one thing
You need a busload of faith to get by, watch, baby
Busload of faith to get by
Busload of faith to get by
Busload of faith to get by
You need a busload of faith to get by
You can depend on the worst always happening
You can depend on a murderer’s drive
You can bet that if he rapes somebody
There’ll be no trouble having a child
You can bet that if she aborts it
Pro-lifers will attack her with rage
You can depend on the worst always happening
You need a busload of faith to get by, yeah
You can’t depend on the goodly hearted
The goodly hearted made lamp-shades and soap
You can’t depend on the sacrament
No father, no holy ghost
You can’t depend on any churches
Unless there’s real estate you want to buy
You can’t depend on a lot of things
You need a busload of faith to get by, woh
You can’t depend on no miracle
You can’t depend on the air
You can’t depend on a wise man
You can’t find ’em because they’re not there
You can depend on cruelty
Crudity of thought and sound
You can depend on the worst always happening
You need a busload of faith to get by, ha
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBIleh...
Well, I think there may be better things to do with your time. But that's my opinion. As you see, I have a shelf called "History will teach us nothing" and I'm almost serious about that.
I honestly thought this book was for people who wanted some general background information about the whole thing rather than being geeky about it (but then I am a geek so..) Thought he generally kept his material accessible when compared to other non fiction writers I've come across who can't help getting all technical about their subject of interest even when writing for joe public. Shame you didn't like it, but a good rant about a book you didn't like is always cool :)
thanks... I think with some subjects the problem is focus - the JFK assassination is another example - the non-specialist either gets a superficial account or a hyper-detailed specialist version with a million footnotes.
For me the most interesting thing about this book was that it exposed 9/11 not as some grand conspiracy of evil genius but talked of a reassuringly incompetent level of human error in dealing with the perceived threat of Al- Qaeda. Take your point though even if I think it did a decent job of straddling the superficial and the specialist.



I always take books like this on my holidays, but never get to read them. Not even half-way.
Where do we discuss your VU boots?