Catherine's Reviews > The Iron Duke
The Iron Duke (Iron Seas, #1)
by Meljean Brook (Goodreads Author)
by Meljean Brook (Goodreads Author)
Catherine's review
bookshelves: steampunk, romance, series, first-reads-arcs-won-a-copy, to-buy, bad-childhood, crime-police-mystery-private-invest, england, excellent, fantasy-paranormal-sci-fi, historical, halfbreed, read-2010, rape-abuse, zombie, adventure
Sep 19, 10
bookshelves: steampunk, romance, series, first-reads-arcs-won-a-copy, to-buy, bad-childhood, crime-police-mystery-private-invest, england, excellent, fantasy-paranormal-sci-fi, historical, halfbreed, read-2010, rape-abuse, zombie, adventure
Read from September 18 to 19, 2010
I won this ARC in a contest at Dear Author.
I have a confession to make... I was afraid to read this book. I have a serious love affair with this author's Guardian series. I mean, how many of my Goodreads friends did I nag into reading it lately? Five? I know they finally broke down and read it just to shut me up, but that's okay, because they loved it anyway and I got more people to talk about it with. So, I was afraid something would happen and I wouldn't be able to get into the new series and I'd lose a favorite author. Thank God I slapped the neurotic out of myself and read it! It was great!
So this is an alternate view of England. Two hundred years ago some of the English, now referred to as bounders, fled the Horde and only returned to England after the Iron Duke had broken the Horde control. The bounders aren't very popular because they've come back to try to claim their titles and their land and are rich, while the people of England who stayed and suffered are poor. The Horde hid nanoagents (or bugs) in the sugar they traded with England. When the time was right, they activated the bugs and thus began the Horde control. Nine years ago, the Iron Duke had broken the Horde control on England. For his trouble, his pirating was pardoned and his was awarded a Dukedom.
This book opens with Mina Wentworth being called to the house of the Iron Duke to investigate a murder. She works for the Metropolitan Police Force and is very good at her job. The Iron Duke, Rhys Trahaearn, is willing to let her investigate, but wants to be involved and informed of all the particulars. Because of his particular status in England, Mina is forced to agree.
It took me a while to figure out exactly why Mina was a pariah in her own society. I don't know if the author was slowly hinting at it, or if I'm just slow, but it took me a while to figure out exactly who the Horde were and why her connection to them would be easy to spot. I was expecting something to do with the nanos or prosthetics. I had a lightbulb moment midway through and felt really dumb. Please let it have been the author's plan and not me being dense! :P Once I figured it out, those insults made a lot more sense...
The beginning of this book was hard for me to get into. Not because of the writing or the characters or anything, it just took me a while to fully acquaint myself with the technology aspect of it. I've got to admit, I find it a lot easier to watch a steampunk movie than read a steampunk book. A movie requires much less understanding for me than a book, and I'll own it - I just don't understand engines. The details start coming about engines and machines and it just blows my mind. So, I think this won't affect anyone who understands these aspects better than I do. I struggled for a while, but did eventually understand the technology and the world. But that lack of understanding isn't unique to this book. I always feel it when reading steampunk. It's just me.
I loved the characters in this book! Not just Mina and Rhys, but the side characters too. Yasmeen, Lady Cosair, a merchant captain with a bad ass attitude. Archimedes Fox, the adventurer who seems to have quite an attachment to one of the other characters. Scarsdale, an excellent character who despairs about Trahaearn's blunt speech and who is incapable of getting onto an airship without being extremely drunk, drugged, or knocked out. And then there's Mina's coworker, Constable Newberry... What an absolute sweetie. I really enjoyed his relationship and loyalty to Mina.
Mina was an excellent heroine. She's smart and assessing at all times. She doesn't go looking for trouble, but she won't back down either. The years under Horde control have had a huge impact on her. She will not be controlled again. Not by a person, and not by her own emotions. Her situation in life is so sad. Where can she go so people will look at her and see something other than the Horde? She is constantly having to hide in the shadows and prove her own worth. Poor girl. She lives in fear, although it is not always apparent. Fear of being controlled, fear of being hurt, fear of being the cause of her family's suffering. Her every action is influenced by those fears.
Rhys is a hero who just wants to be ignored. He likes the power and influence his name gives him, but he doesn't want the hero worship. He doesn't want people to look at him and thank him, it makes him uncomfortable. The public takes his image and runs with it and no one seems to care about the truth of his past. He doesn't care, a lie can serve him better than the truth at times. Unfortunately, he seems to forget the image he has been given and pushes Mina and tests her, not knowing that she's judging his actions by who she thinks he is.
Rhys had a really harsh childhood that has shaped his view of the world and his relationships to people. He values people by their use to them and keeps them or discards them depending on their value. He knows that everyone has a price, and has no problem with manipulating someone into the situation he wants them to be in. Thank goodness for Scarsdale. He's the voice of reason telling Rhys when he's fumbling things with his pursuit of Mina. I cracked up at the severe understatement of the term, "bad sport," that Rhys and Scarsdale kept throwing around. I loved Rhys though, because once he figured out that his manipulation was doing more harm than good he dropped it and started tweaking another angle.
There is a part in this book that I think is going to make some readers uncomfortable. I, personally, loved that it was there and that they had to deal with it in an honest and adult way. It was, sincerely, an honest mistake. Rhys didn't mean to do it like that, and Mina couldn't help her reaction. I loved how it all worked out.
Can I just point out that there are zombies in here! How cool is that? I didn't read the summary of the book, I just wanted it based on the author, so they were a big surprise. I loved their roll and I loved the explanation for their existence!
The only problem I had was toward the end. Mina and Rhys and their total miscommunication made me want to smack their heads together. It totally fit with their characters, and the fact that they seem to speak a different language at times, but I still found it a bit frustrating. I just wanted to sit them both down and have an intervention! But it was wonderful too.
I cannot wait to read the next book!!!
I have a confession to make... I was afraid to read this book. I have a serious love affair with this author's Guardian series. I mean, how many of my Goodreads friends did I nag into reading it lately? Five? I know they finally broke down and read it just to shut me up, but that's okay, because they loved it anyway and I got more people to talk about it with. So, I was afraid something would happen and I wouldn't be able to get into the new series and I'd lose a favorite author. Thank God I slapped the neurotic out of myself and read it! It was great!
So this is an alternate view of England. Two hundred years ago some of the English, now referred to as bounders, fled the Horde and only returned to England after the Iron Duke had broken the Horde control. The bounders aren't very popular because they've come back to try to claim their titles and their land and are rich, while the people of England who stayed and suffered are poor. The Horde hid nanoagents (or bugs) in the sugar they traded with England. When the time was right, they activated the bugs and thus began the Horde control. Nine years ago, the Iron Duke had broken the Horde control on England. For his trouble, his pirating was pardoned and his was awarded a Dukedom.
This book opens with Mina Wentworth being called to the house of the Iron Duke to investigate a murder. She works for the Metropolitan Police Force and is very good at her job. The Iron Duke, Rhys Trahaearn, is willing to let her investigate, but wants to be involved and informed of all the particulars. Because of his particular status in England, Mina is forced to agree.
It took me a while to figure out exactly why Mina was a pariah in her own society. I don't know if the author was slowly hinting at it, or if I'm just slow, but it took me a while to figure out exactly who the Horde were and why her connection to them would be easy to spot. I was expecting something to do with the nanos or prosthetics. I had a lightbulb moment midway through and felt really dumb. Please let it have been the author's plan and not me being dense! :P Once I figured it out, those insults made a lot more sense...
The beginning of this book was hard for me to get into. Not because of the writing or the characters or anything, it just took me a while to fully acquaint myself with the technology aspect of it. I've got to admit, I find it a lot easier to watch a steampunk movie than read a steampunk book. A movie requires much less understanding for me than a book, and I'll own it - I just don't understand engines. The details start coming about engines and machines and it just blows my mind. So, I think this won't affect anyone who understands these aspects better than I do. I struggled for a while, but did eventually understand the technology and the world. But that lack of understanding isn't unique to this book. I always feel it when reading steampunk. It's just me.
I loved the characters in this book! Not just Mina and Rhys, but the side characters too. Yasmeen, Lady Cosair, a merchant captain with a bad ass attitude. Archimedes Fox, the adventurer who seems to have quite an attachment to one of the other characters. Scarsdale, an excellent character who despairs about Trahaearn's blunt speech and who is incapable of getting onto an airship without being extremely drunk, drugged, or knocked out. And then there's Mina's coworker, Constable Newberry... What an absolute sweetie. I really enjoyed his relationship and loyalty to Mina.
Mina was an excellent heroine. She's smart and assessing at all times. She doesn't go looking for trouble, but she won't back down either. The years under Horde control have had a huge impact on her. She will not be controlled again. Not by a person, and not by her own emotions. Her situation in life is so sad. Where can she go so people will look at her and see something other than the Horde? She is constantly having to hide in the shadows and prove her own worth. Poor girl. She lives in fear, although it is not always apparent. Fear of being controlled, fear of being hurt, fear of being the cause of her family's suffering. Her every action is influenced by those fears.
Rhys is a hero who just wants to be ignored. He likes the power and influence his name gives him, but he doesn't want the hero worship. He doesn't want people to look at him and thank him, it makes him uncomfortable. The public takes his image and runs with it and no one seems to care about the truth of his past. He doesn't care, a lie can serve him better than the truth at times. Unfortunately, he seems to forget the image he has been given and pushes Mina and tests her, not knowing that she's judging his actions by who she thinks he is.
Rhys had a really harsh childhood that has shaped his view of the world and his relationships to people. He values people by their use to them and keeps them or discards them depending on their value. He knows that everyone has a price, and has no problem with manipulating someone into the situation he wants them to be in. Thank goodness for Scarsdale. He's the voice of reason telling Rhys when he's fumbling things with his pursuit of Mina. I cracked up at the severe understatement of the term, "bad sport," that Rhys and Scarsdale kept throwing around. I loved Rhys though, because once he figured out that his manipulation was doing more harm than good he dropped it and started tweaking another angle.
There is a part in this book that I think is going to make some readers uncomfortable. I, personally, loved that it was there and that they had to deal with it in an honest and adult way. It was, sincerely, an honest mistake. Rhys didn't mean to do it like that, and Mina couldn't help her reaction. I loved how it all worked out.
Can I just point out that there are zombies in here! How cool is that? I didn't read the summary of the book, I just wanted it based on the author, so they were a big surprise. I loved their roll and I loved the explanation for their existence!
The only problem I had was toward the end. Mina and Rhys and their total miscommunication made me want to smack their heads together. It totally fit with their characters, and the fact that they seem to speak a different language at times, but I still found it a bit frustrating. I just wanted to sit them both down and have an intervention! But it was wonderful too.
I cannot wait to read the next book!!!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Iron Duke.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 09/18/2010 | page 3 |
|
1.0% | "Ooh. How very intriguing already. The Horde hid nanoagents in sugar and now no one will eat it! Except for beet sugar..." 12 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 16 |
|
5.0% | "In this book people who have the nanos in their body are politely called Enhanced and impolitely called Buggers. I was pretty confused about the "Buggers" for a few pages. LOL." 20 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 33 |
|
10.0% | ""He had no use for cowards, especially those who turned and ran. Did they think he wouldn't chase after them?"" 4 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 36 |
|
11.0% | ""Yet just by looking at her, desire twisted in his gut--not sexual hunger, but an urgent need to possess."" 2 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 39 |
|
12.0% | "Oh shit! Just found out why the mom has mirrored eyes. No, Mina doesn't have them too." 13 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 45 |
|
13.0% | "I find it amusing that everyone gets sirred, even the women." 4 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 69 |
|
21.0% | ""Why did he still intend to pursue her? Somehow, she'd made a critical error. She wouldn't have thought that threatening a man's privates would encourage him, but--Oh, blue heavens. She'd fired back. Though she'd been outgunned, she'd challenged the Iron Duke. So she was a fool."" 9 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 76 |
|
23.0% | ""Deliberately, he gripped her shoulders and steered her back against the pub's brick wall, holding her there for a long second. As if satisfied, he let her go and walked away. Mina shook her head in disbelief. Did he think she would remain here, as if magnetized to the building?" - LOL!" 13 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 85 |
|
25.0% | "Zombie alert!" 14 comments |
| 09/18/2010 | page 118 |
|
35.0% | ""Aghast, Yasmeen gaped at her before looking to the duke. "It's worse than I thought. Not just the Horde, not just the police--you're keeping company with someone who has principles." "Unfortunately," Trahaearn said."" |
| 09/19/2010 | page 141 |
|
42.0% | """And inspector..." He strode forward and stared down at her, his gaze fierce. "You run. Because I am not taking a zombie into my bed." Mina's mouth dropped open, and he bent his head as if to kiss her. She jammed her gun barrel under his chin. He grinned."" 11 comments |
| 09/19/2010 | page 144 |
|
43.0% | ""The first opportunity he got, Rhys was going to shag her blind." - LOL" 27 comments |
| 09/19/2010 | page 176 |
|
52.0% | "This is so good! It took me a bit to get into the swing of the technology, but everything is simply wonderful now!" 1 comment |
| 09/19/2010 | page 215 |
|
64.0% | "I love the side characters. Yasmeen, Fox, and especially Scarsdale. I love him the best." 2 comments |
| 09/19/2010 | page 236 |
|
70.0% | "I'm so sorry for both of them. :( He didn't mean it and she couldn't help it." 6 comments |
| 09/19/2010 | page 252 |
|
75.0% | "I just found out the reason for his earrings. *sniff*" 15 comments |
Comments (showing 1-42 of 42) (42 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Sep 19, 2010 12:02pm
I am so excited to read this book!
reply
|
flag
*
I didn't want to stop. I kept telling myself Just a few more chapters. Oh, it's an action scene, I can't stop now. Wait, things are getting intense. -Eh, screw it. Just finish it!
Yes! I do the same thing! And then you hit that mark, where you are at less than 100 pages to go and are fully wrapped up in the climax... and there's no stopping now.
You trying to say something??? LOL! No, my husband let me sleep in and kept the kids from bothering me. So I got about 5 1/2 hours of sleep still.
Catherine...You totally stayed up later than I did reading. LOL! It was only 3:00am for me. I can't wait for your review.
UniquelyMoi *~*Dhestiny*~* wrote: "Don't wait too long! I want your review! LOL"It's coming! It will be up today!
Ally wrote: "Catherine...You totally stayed up later than I did reading. LOL! It was only 3:00am for me. I can't wait for your review."It just means you have more restraint than I do. My husband woke up at 4, looked at the clock, looked at me, told me I was an addict and he hoped the book was good, and rolled over and went back to sleep. :)
Catherine wrote: "Ally wrote: "Catherine...You totally stayed up later than I did reading. LOL! It was only 3:00am for me. I can't wait for your review."It just means you have more restraint than I do. My husb..."
LOL!!!
LOL. Well, wow, your husband took it well! And even enabled you. ;) I can think of a few dudes that wouldn't be that nice. Harrumph. LOL.
This book sounds awesome. I have to ask you something:
SPOILER (?)
I noticed you have this in the rape-abuse category. Does it have rape in it? Because I really try to avoid books that deal with it.
message 20:
by
UniquelyMoi *Dhestiny* BlithelyBookish
(last edited Sep 19, 2010 04:20pm)
(new)
-
added it
Great review!! I really think that all these steampunk authors should post photos or drawings of all of their contraptions. Can't wait to read it.
Thanks everyone! I hope you guys like it too if you decide to read it. I would love pictures too AH. With machines I'm a visual person because I just don't understand them enough to picture it all in my head. My husband starts talking about engines and exhausts and transmissions, etc. and it just blows my mind.
Great review cath!You always seem to be winning things, while I haven't won anything in my entire life! hehe. :P
new_user wrote: "Hmn, so from your description it sounds like the hero might be more whole than the heroine?"Can you clarify a little? I'm not sure exactly what you mean.
Catherine wrote: "new_user wrote: "Hmn, so from your description it sounds like the hero might be more whole than the heroine?"Can you clarify a little? I'm not sure exactly what you mean."
Hmmmmn. Basically, I mean the heroine has more insecurities than the hero. What do you think?
Yes, I would say that's accurate. He has insecurities, but his don't interfere with his opportunities the way that hers do. But hers aren't just insecurities. They're results of the way society treats her. Like I said, she's something of a pariah. His insecurities are there, but more doors are open to him and he has more confidence because of the awe he inspires as the Iron Duke. If he murdered someone the government would pardon him just because of who he is and what he represents to England.
Is a lot of the book spent dwelling on these insecurities? I have a hard time stomaching it from the hero and even less so from the heroine, LOL.
No....not per se. There's not focus specifically on them or a lot of "woe is me"-ing, but they help shape their attitudes and play an important role in their actions and decisions. So...yes and no.
I completely agree on the beginning and the confusion regarding Mina's pariah status. There was a lot of [ebook] page turning back and forth to figure it out, so it was *initially* frustrating. However, Trahaearn and his quiet and lethal intensity is greatly making this book worthwhile, among other things :) I'm on the last few chapters and trying to slooowwwly prolong the end! But I definitely connected with your review. Great work!
Lychee wrote: "I completely agree on the beginning and the confusion regarding Mina's pariah status. There was a lot of [ebook] page turning back and forth to figure it out, so it was *initially* frustrating. How..."I'm glad you loved it too!




