Laura the Highland Hussy's Reviews > The Madness of Lord Ian Mackenzie
The Madness of Lord Ian Mackenzie (Highland Pleasures, #1)
by Jennifer Ashley (Goodreads Author)
by Jennifer Ashley (Goodreads Author)
Laura the Highland Hussy's review
bookshelves: highlander-books
Jul 26, 11
bookshelves: highlander-books
Read from July 25 to 28, 2010
I was super excited to read this book, seeing as everyone loved this book, and I love Jennifer Ashley/Allyson James. I was not disappointed. This has one of the best storylines I've ever read. I won't summarize since so many people have reviewed and/or summarized, but can I just say "Wow."
Lord Ian Mackenzie is the youngest of 4 brothers and he has a slight disability. He doesn't understand emotion. For example, he can play a piano piece perfectly after only having heard it once, but he can't feel the emotion behind it. Or he knows that one applauds after a show, or at the opera, but he doesn't get why. Lord Ian is intelligent, highly so..a genius with numbers and odds, so an acquaintance of his asks his opinion on his bride-to-be. Lord Ian has her investigated, and he feels Beth is too good for the likes of Mather. so not only does he tell her, he proposes. it was a great scene. Fantastic, and this whole book was above and beyond my expectations.
Beth, however, decides Ian can't possibly be serious, and goes off to Paris. Well Lord Ian follows. But not before having a few scandalous episodes that Beth spots in the London Post society section. Lord Ian harbors a couple big secrets, really big ones, and not only is the Inspector way off in his deluded case of "justice," but so is everyone else's opinions. One secret (and not a "spoiler" secret)is that his father killed his mother in front of him in a fit of rage, and at 12, he had Ian committed. Ian was never mad, but he was different. And he was so worked up that at the sanity hearing (mind you he was 12 and had just watched his father shake his mother to death!) he could only rock and repeat the same phrase from a poem over and over to calm himself. So of course, he is committed. Luckily his brother gets him out after their father dies, but Ian had been locked up for something like 10 years or so (I forget the actual number). The electro shock therapy, the cold ice baths, the beatings, all of it, had taken it's toll, and yet Ian remained a remarkable man. He has rages, like when he sees the vengeance-driven Inspector Fellows talking to Beth, but he really is afraid he'll rage against Beth.
The romance between the two is fabulous, as is the passion. I like how Beth's husband (her first husband) was a good man, and she was able to still love him, but be passionately in love with Ian as well. I loved the Mackenzie clan. even Isabella, Mac's estranged wife. We see her when Beth goes to Paris. And just as we think Ian is in front of Beth, it turns out to be one of his brothers, Mac Mackenzie. Mac is keeping tabs on his wife. Their story is next, and also fabulous!!
The only thing I didn't like about this book was Inspector Fellows. The surprise twist at the end was good, and well played, but I couldn't muster enough emotion for Fellows after the way he had harangued Ian and Beth.
(I meant this review to be short...ha!)
I loved how Beth was able to hold her own with Hart...he was such a jerk to her, and yet she was able to make Ian laugh...that was a miracle in and of itself since he usually didn't understand humor. At the end, Ian still couldn't understand a lot of jokes, or follow a conversation with more than one or two people, but he'd gotten better at making eye contact, and he fell in love with Beth...there is a side story of a murder from 5 years before (hence Inspector Fellows' obsession with bringing Ian down) and then a similar murder right after Ian and Beth met. But anyways, I tell you this so you understand when I say that Beth is injured in her quest to clear Ian, and Ian finally understands that without Beth he has nothing, and feels nothing. It was simply amazing to watch his transformation and his and Beth's romance. When he tells her he loves her, and it becomes "Iloveyou.loveyou.loveyou.loveyou." It was beautiful.
I. LOVED. THIS. BOOK.
http://www.demonloversbooksandmore.co...
Lord Ian Mackenzie is the youngest of 4 brothers and he has a slight disability. He doesn't understand emotion. For example, he can play a piano piece perfectly after only having heard it once, but he can't feel the emotion behind it. Or he knows that one applauds after a show, or at the opera, but he doesn't get why. Lord Ian is intelligent, highly so..a genius with numbers and odds, so an acquaintance of his asks his opinion on his bride-to-be. Lord Ian has her investigated, and he feels Beth is too good for the likes of Mather. so not only does he tell her, he proposes. it was a great scene. Fantastic, and this whole book was above and beyond my expectations.
Beth, however, decides Ian can't possibly be serious, and goes off to Paris. Well Lord Ian follows. But not before having a few scandalous episodes that Beth spots in the London Post society section. Lord Ian harbors a couple big secrets, really big ones, and not only is the Inspector way off in his deluded case of "justice," but so is everyone else's opinions. One secret (and not a "spoiler" secret)is that his father killed his mother in front of him in a fit of rage, and at 12, he had Ian committed. Ian was never mad, but he was different. And he was so worked up that at the sanity hearing (mind you he was 12 and had just watched his father shake his mother to death!) he could only rock and repeat the same phrase from a poem over and over to calm himself. So of course, he is committed. Luckily his brother gets him out after their father dies, but Ian had been locked up for something like 10 years or so (I forget the actual number). The electro shock therapy, the cold ice baths, the beatings, all of it, had taken it's toll, and yet Ian remained a remarkable man. He has rages, like when he sees the vengeance-driven Inspector Fellows talking to Beth, but he really is afraid he'll rage against Beth.
The romance between the two is fabulous, as is the passion. I like how Beth's husband (her first husband) was a good man, and she was able to still love him, but be passionately in love with Ian as well. I loved the Mackenzie clan. even Isabella, Mac's estranged wife. We see her when Beth goes to Paris. And just as we think Ian is in front of Beth, it turns out to be one of his brothers, Mac Mackenzie. Mac is keeping tabs on his wife. Their story is next, and also fabulous!!
The only thing I didn't like about this book was Inspector Fellows. The surprise twist at the end was good, and well played, but I couldn't muster enough emotion for Fellows after the way he had harangued Ian and Beth.
(I meant this review to be short...ha!)
I loved how Beth was able to hold her own with Hart...he was such a jerk to her, and yet she was able to make Ian laugh...that was a miracle in and of itself since he usually didn't understand humor. At the end, Ian still couldn't understand a lot of jokes, or follow a conversation with more than one or two people, but he'd gotten better at making eye contact, and he fell in love with Beth...there is a side story of a murder from 5 years before (hence Inspector Fellows' obsession with bringing Ian down) and then a similar murder right after Ian and Beth met. But anyways, I tell you this so you understand when I say that Beth is injured in her quest to clear Ian, and Ian finally understands that without Beth he has nothing, and feels nothing. It was simply amazing to watch his transformation and his and Beth's romance. When he tells her he loves her, and it becomes "Iloveyou.loveyou.loveyou.loveyou." It was beautiful.
I. LOVED. THIS. BOOK.
http://www.demonloversbooksandmore.co...
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Madness of Lord Ian Mackenzie.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 07/25/2010 | page 6 |
|
2.0% | "I've got high expectations from everyone else's reviews" |
| 07/25/2010 | page 23 |
|
7.0% | "I'm not even 25 pages in and I'm absolutely in love with Lord Ian. He makes me want to hold him and never let go." 5 comments |
| 07/27/2010 | page 23 |
|
7.0% | "review to come, but absolutely loved Lord Ian!!!!" |
Comments (showing 1-32 of 32) (32 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Catherine
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 25, 2010 03:50pm
This is your first time reading this? If you like it half as much as I did you'll be in for a treat!
reply
|
flag
*
Great review, Laurie! I'm relieved & happy to know you liked it! I've been getting quite a few rec's to try this novel & your review puts my worries at ease. Sounds like a really good one!
I have never been a fan of the beta male, or having an invalid or handicapped hero (I'm shallow in my fantasy-land) Ian has his Alpha moments that I adored, and I never saw his "madness" as a negative aspect. He reminded me of a boy I nannied for who was autistic, but it was very mild, and he had a sensory disorder-the sensory disorder is what Ian reminded me of. I am NOT saying Ian is Autistic, or that is what his "madness" is, (for anyone else reading this!) but that's just what some of his behaviors reminded me of. The not meeting eyes, the not following certain conversations, not understanding emotions well. My point is just that even with all that, I just loved Ian. I could just hold him forever. :)
I read somewhere, can't remember where (so believe this at your own discretion), that the author had clarified that Ian had a milder case of Asperger Syndrome. I remember because I had to google it to learn what it was.I agree, Beth standing up to Hart was excellent. He needs someone to shut him up once in a while. I'm very curious how the author will write his story. I wonder if she'll stick to the gritty way we know he likes sex or if she'll back off that and make his sex vanilla.
Thanks for clarifying that Catherine :) I think it'll be interesting to see what type of woman will be able to satisfy his appetites as well.
I admit that this isn't the kind of book I would normally read but I've heard nothing but praise about it. I think I might have to give it a go :)
YAY, this is so good to know because I need a good historical & I have this one on my nook! Great review, love ♥
no prob babe! I just read the one that will come out in August, and I don't think you can go wrong with any of these Mackenzie brothers
How is she compared to Beth and Isabella?I heard from somewhere I she got married to a total A-hole, too. Poor woman. Good thing she met Cam.
I can't wait for this book >_<
Panichaya wrote: "How is she compared to Beth and Isabella?I heard from somewhere I she got married to a total A-hole, too. Poor woman. Good thing she met Cam.
I can't wait for this book >_<"
She's very different from Beth and Isabella. But I like her alot. She was married to a very old man, but Cam more than makes up for that
An old man!? Was she forced to? Poor poor woman.And Laurie, I finally figured out what makes me so into Cam more than Hart, who is usually my type of hero. It's how Ian describes him almost at the end of The Madness of Lord Ian Mackenzie, it's that 'Cam can be more intimidating than Hart if he wants to' line that got me hooked. LOL
Wow, I thought you'd already read this! Glad you liked it though. I loved this one, but I really liked the next book better for some reason. There was something sweet about a rekindling marriage and all. :)
I can't decide who I like more, Ian, Mac, Cam, or Hart. If possible, I want to fuse all of them together in one whole person and BAM!!! I'll kidnap him to Mars so he will not have any other choice but to ask my hands in marriage because all other females are Martians.And Laurie, I just got The Many Sins of Lord Cameron today at Borders and I'm already hooked!!! Love, Love the interactions between Cam and Ainsley!!! And Ian with his honey (but hr would have to give credit to Cam, since he thought of it first LOL)
Panichaya wrote: "I can't decide who I like more, Ian, Mac, Cam, or Hart. If possible, I want to fuse all of them together in one whole person and BAM!!! I'll kidnap him to Mars so he will not have any other choice ..."LOL! :)


