Alexander's review

Alexander's review

Moby-Dick: or, The Whale Moby-Dick: or, The Whale
by Herman Melville

145922 Alexander's review
rating: 5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars

I read this in a week, on a trip to Tokyo. I started it on the plane over, finished it while I was there. There was something about the way being submerged in a foriegn language while reading it made it more intense.

I found it weirdly thrilling for how it seemed to me to be this whole novel about the handsome tattooed Queequeg, and the strange beautiful relationship he and the narrator have, and then wham! The whale.

In some ways, the long aria-type chapters about whales strike me as being a way to support the ending, and at first I found them frustrating, but over time, afterwards, I understand them and find them necessary, though I do always wish there was a way the novel could have been more about Queequeg and the "bridegroom's embrace" the narrator finds himself in on that first night they meet and end up in bed together.

Like this review?   yes   (3 people liked it)  flag




comments (showing 1-7 of 7)

newest »
dateDown_arrow

message 1: by Marie
12/29/2007 06:19AM

230680 ...and that scene where they are squishing the spermaceti in that big vat and they don't know if they are holding hands or not. It was such a strange and oddly sensuous passage...

Went to New Bedford this summer to pay homage to the master, even went to the little chapel. I slipped into the backmost pew to contemplate it all...the docent said that was also Melville's favorite pew. He liked to sit in the fringes and observe as well.

Good read!
ml

flag abuse *

message 2: by Lisa
12/29/2007 08:43AM

629646 "I wish there was a way the novel could have been more about Queequeg and the 'bridegroom's embrace" ... you should explore that and see what comes of it.
L

flag abuse *

message 3: by Alexander
12/29/2007 09:06AM

145922 Lisa: I might just.

My first reaction was, Doesn't my career sort of already do that? But the answer was... no. Maybe it'll be my homage to Wide Sargasso Sea.

If I do it, I'm giving you the credit.

Marie: I used to attend a Unitarian-Universalist church in New York that had a framed note from Melville's widow, asking to be excused from the pew tax because of their extreme poverty.

flag abuse *

message 4: by Jane
01/03/2008 06:43AM

156877 This is one of my favorite American novels; reading it was perhaps *the* reading highpoint of grad school for me. I love its lavishness, how it seems as if Melville gave everything to it. If you live in Western Mass. or are visiting it, you should go tour Arrowhead, the house in Pittsfield where Melville wrote /Moby Dick/. He was contained and frustrated, mightily, by the hectic life of his extended family with whom he lived, and it's easy to wonder if he poured all that energy into the novel.

To complicate your reading of Ishmael's relationship with Queequeg, read /Rites and Passages/ by Margaret Creighton, a wonderful, short social history of 19th century whaling industry based on the diaries and letters of whalemen. If nothing else, read the parts about gender identity, romance, and sex. A student, in fact, showed this book to me about a year ago, and reading it has expanded by sense of /Moby Dick/.



flag abuse *

message 5: by Christopher (last edited 04/29/2008 12:23AM)
04/28/2008 10:55PM

666077 I started reading a bit of this at work in the last few days, and reading the last part of your review about wanting the novel to be about a romance between Queequeg and Ishmael, together with the 'rumor' that Melville felt very close to Nathaniel Hawthorne, made me want to attempt a sci-fi punk/queer hybrid of Moby Dick and The Scarlet Letter story/novel today.

flag abuse *

message 6: by Alexander
04/29/2008 04:33AM

145922 You should go for it.

flag abuse *

message 7: by Christopher
04/29/2008 03:08PM

666077 When I finish Moby-Dick, I think I will.

flag abuse *


all Alexander's books »