Morgan F's Reviews > Willow

Willow by Julia Hoban

by
2941288
's review
Jul 25, 10

bookshelves: own, 2000s, young-adult, ive-got-issues, read-2010, its-a-girl, characters-i-wanna-shoot, medium-sized, realistic
Read from July 23 to 24, 2010 — I own a copy

Everything changed on that rainy March night seven months ago. Willow's parents were tipsy and asked her to drive home, a decision that would cost them their lives. Ever since then, Willow has felt disconnected from the world. Her only reprieve is in mutilating her own body, one cut at a time. But everything changes when she meets Guy, the only one with whom she can possibly share her secret.

I did not like Willow. Not the book, the character. She was a whiny little biotch. I understand that I probably should pity her, her being responsible for her parents deaths and all, but she makes it so damn hard. It's not the cutting that makes her so unlikable. Even though I am not a cutter myself, I understand the concept and have friends who indulge in it. It's just her view of the world. She expected the whole damn universe to revolve around her. She whined about people being inconsiderate around her and about how no one "got her". But Willow was always wrong about others. She judged them before they could judge her. I didn't understand her logic most of the time. And I hate how she would always go "well, I killed my parents." You're not the only who has ever lost anyone, Willow. You are not the only person in the world who is grieving. I just wanted her to get over herself. Though admittedly, I did like her considerably more by the novel's end.

Based on the character of Willow alone, this book would have gotten two stars. Thankfully, the intense writing and topic made me really like it. The writing flowed really well, and its interesting how this book was in third person instead of the expected first person. Of course, cutting is an always disturbing, intriguing topic, as much as you wish that it wasn't.

And Guy might have been too perfect, but he was sweet and sensitive without being gay (glances at her copy of Shiver). But I felt sorry for the poor guy (hehe, pun). He was stuck with Willow. And I also liked David and all the literary references.

One more thing that didn't quite fly with me was the end. A spoiler is coming up, so AVERT YOUR EYES. Okay, so teenage sex. It happens a lot. A lot a lot. So why encourage it? "Guy, we need to sleep together because I'm sad." "Okay then." *they do it* "Okay, I'm all better." "Okay, then." Just a little bit of WTF.

Overall, parts of this book and others parts I didn't like at all (aka Willow). But it is a good book, no doubt about that. It has a powerful, intense theme that I'm sure teenagers (especially cutters looking to relate) will eat up.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Willow.
sign in »

Reading Progress

07/23/2010 page 273
83.0% "Willow is such a brat." 3 comments

Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Arlene It sounds like for the most part you liked the book. I was most bothered by the razors that were thrown into the ocean at the end of the book. Not good for the environment. Bad! Bad! But I did really like the book. Great review!!


Morgan F Those poor little cut up fishies :(


message 3: by Nic (new)

Nic Great review. I have being meaning to get this, will have to soon. So it sounds like Willow is going on your annoying character shelf with Claire :D


message 4: by ~Tina~ (new)

~Tina~ I still have this on my shelf. I think I'll have to pull it out soon, great review.


Thomas Reading the last few paragraphs of this review made me smile... great review.


message 6: by Kim (new) - rated it 2 stars

Kim I agree, but I didn't want to give it that much stars.


Morgan F Thanks guys.

And Kim, logically I know I shouldn't have given it that many stars, but that's just what that book feels like for me.


Alexa I couldn't seem to like Willow. I didn't even feel sorry for her. :\

Your comment about the sex was hilarious! XD


message 9: by NJ (new) - rated it 2 stars

NJ I'm not liking Willow so far too. I think proclaiming herself a killer works the first few times she's said it. But she goes on and on about it throughout that I wanna slap her so hard.


Morgan F Yeah, she is really annoying. I liked the book overall though.


message 11: by amberj (new)

amberj haha i love your review = ) it made me laugh (in a good way) thats how i felt about vampire diaries! i couldnt get through the first page without being mad at the main character...anyway i prob wont read the book based on your review so thank you = ) i hate it when the book sucks and your like half way through...so major time saver = D


message 12: by Amber (new) - rated it 1 star

Amber omg I hated Willow too


back to top