Mary Regan's Reviews > Here on Earth

Here on Earth by Alice Hoffman

by
Nophoto-f-50x66
's review
Sep 18, 12

bookshelves: fiction
Read from July 08 to 11, 2010

I am listening to this book, unabridged, on audio and I can barely stand it. And it is such a rip-off of Wuthering Heights- but a poor imitation. I cannot picture Lawrence Olivier in the role of Hollis, who is a complete numbskull as far as I can tell.

Everything about the story is so predictable and trite, including the endless metaphors. I nearly tossed my i-phone in the trash at Grand Central tonight. But I just want to find out a few things:

1. if the two first cousins (children, who no one seems to pay any attention to. Am I too old to be reading this book?) run off together and produce another equally selfish and ridiculous offspring;
2. if the two absurd adults are half-brother/sister
3. if he kills her and then shoots himself (that would be a nice twist)
4. if the "coward" in the marsh (I mean, really - could it be more of a W.H. rip-off?) saves his niece from drowning the next time she decides to give him a gift ( a compass?
4. if anyone is ever going to feed that poor little dog or if March (what a silly name) is arrested for animal cruelty
4. if Luke and Laura come back

Too harsh? Happy to listen to any defense of this book.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Here on Earth.
sign in »

No comments have been added yet.