enjoyable overall; in particular, the period details are fascinating. unfortunately something left me cold about this novel. perhaps it was the lack of old-fashioned adventure in what was a tale of, well, a very bloody and very lengthy siege. perhaps it was the constantly ironic and semi-comic portraits of the characters, both english and indian. although a rather unique way to approach an historical adventure steeped in commentary on the nature of humanity, rationalism, religion, etc...it seemed faintly condescending and in a novel with so much death and despair, at times i longed for deeper emotions and higher qualities to surface. the ironic, comedic detachment became somewhat oppressive at times.

still, a very well-written novel and a worthy experience.