Paul's Reviews > The War of the Words: The Political Correctness Debate
The War of the Words: The Political Correctness Debate
by Sarah Dunant
by Sarah Dunant
This book was published in 1994 and the argument rages on today.
It's a war about when we say "we" what do we mean and who are we anyway. "We" used to be white, male and middle aged as is well understood - you know, the people who drew the maps, laid down the laws and decided what you should find funny. Things were SO much simpler then.
That particular human identity has now been put on trial and found guilty of several serious perversions. The maps weren't right, the laws were despised, the jokes were not funny, they just made other people weep inside. So, Justice has been done, and that we was taken out and shot. A letter stating that it lost its life in brave service to truth and beauty has been sent to its family who shed tears over old photographs and tell each other what a beautiful person we used to be, how we were always kind to our slaves and never chastised women lightly.
So far so good. A job well done. But then the liberal, intelligent people who had dismantled this ugly superstructure either went mad or were replaced like in "The Invasion of the Body Snatchers" by some other people who looked like them but were completely insane and started barking on about chestnuts being dangerous for kids, ice cream being dangerous for kids, cholesterol and sex being dangerous for everyone, Enid Blyton was a racist, Tom and Jerry was as bad as American Psycho, you can't smoke within a mile of another human being, and everything now had to be printed in 46 different languages including this review. And also, it's compulsory to be a lesbian. It was very confusing and it still is. All those stories from the right wing press about kids being banned from singing "Baa Baa Black Sheep" - I thought they were all made up. But then Georgia (aged 6) sang "Baa Baa Woolly Sheep" to me. What??
But it always seemed to me that the people complaining about pc were just right wing shitbags who were fuming that they couldn't call black people, gay people and women the various names that they wanted to. Same people who moaned on about how the word "gay" had been traduced and co-opted and now couldn't be used properly as if a shift in lexical usage was the equivalent of the gulag archipelago.
But then in comes the human rights and health and safely people, and what was a life-affirming and successful campaign has become a hideous thousand armed beast which ties us up in mind-forged manacles every time we try to think straight. Should a guy who preaches jihad against the West be deported from Britain? Er, is he a foreign national? Yes. Well then, yes he should. Oh but his family are all in the UK plus the country he came from uses torture regularly so that would be breaking the human rights convention. Okay. What did the human rights convention say about liquidating 20,000 civilians during the Shock and Awe campaign in 2003? Not a lot really. But we can't sack a Muslim man if he refuses to guard the Israeli embassy in London because he hates Jews. One thing leads to another. I think I am becoming one of my own nightmares.
Bruce Wayne ("Batman") : It's sometime difficult to think clearly when you're strapped to a printing press.
It's a war about when we say "we" what do we mean and who are we anyway. "We" used to be white, male and middle aged as is well understood - you know, the people who drew the maps, laid down the laws and decided what you should find funny. Things were SO much simpler then.
That particular human identity has now been put on trial and found guilty of several serious perversions. The maps weren't right, the laws were despised, the jokes were not funny, they just made other people weep inside. So, Justice has been done, and that we was taken out and shot. A letter stating that it lost its life in brave service to truth and beauty has been sent to its family who shed tears over old photographs and tell each other what a beautiful person we used to be, how we were always kind to our slaves and never chastised women lightly.
So far so good. A job well done. But then the liberal, intelligent people who had dismantled this ugly superstructure either went mad or were replaced like in "The Invasion of the Body Snatchers" by some other people who looked like them but were completely insane and started barking on about chestnuts being dangerous for kids, ice cream being dangerous for kids, cholesterol and sex being dangerous for everyone, Enid Blyton was a racist, Tom and Jerry was as bad as American Psycho, you can't smoke within a mile of another human being, and everything now had to be printed in 46 different languages including this review. And also, it's compulsory to be a lesbian. It was very confusing and it still is. All those stories from the right wing press about kids being banned from singing "Baa Baa Black Sheep" - I thought they were all made up. But then Georgia (aged 6) sang "Baa Baa Woolly Sheep" to me. What??
But it always seemed to me that the people complaining about pc were just right wing shitbags who were fuming that they couldn't call black people, gay people and women the various names that they wanted to. Same people who moaned on about how the word "gay" had been traduced and co-opted and now couldn't be used properly as if a shift in lexical usage was the equivalent of the gulag archipelago.
But then in comes the human rights and health and safely people, and what was a life-affirming and successful campaign has become a hideous thousand armed beast which ties us up in mind-forged manacles every time we try to think straight. Should a guy who preaches jihad against the West be deported from Britain? Er, is he a foreign national? Yes. Well then, yes he should. Oh but his family are all in the UK plus the country he came from uses torture regularly so that would be breaking the human rights convention. Okay. What did the human rights convention say about liquidating 20,000 civilians during the Shock and Awe campaign in 2003? Not a lot really. But we can't sack a Muslim man if he refuses to guard the Israeli embassy in London because he hates Jews. One thing leads to another. I think I am becoming one of my own nightmares.
Bruce Wayne ("Batman") : It's sometime difficult to think clearly when you're strapped to a printing press.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The War of the Words.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-18 of 18) (18 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Xio
(new)
Dec 26, 2007 08:57am
Phew! Terrific!
reply
|
flag
*
Some adults and children should be told, in no uncertain terms, that if they don't take their medicine and seek a steady regimen of psychotherapy, we shall be forced to put them to sleep.
Or send them to "The Island."
The Island being a euphemism for putting them to sleep.
Or send them to "The Island."
The Island being a euphemism for putting them to sleep.
I don't know Tracy, I think Brendan's is dead-on. O wait that's not a review. It's a manifesto. Ah, I like the perverse in response to the banal (the book, not Paul's review)
Paul, this is a great review. You have touched on one of my favorite current topics, and a source of great consternation. I live on the Left coast of the US... surrounded by PC... and by people who don't want to think too hard about it lest their delicate little bubble of sheltered reality be burst. I have a lot more to say about the subject... but my brain is on strike from holiday overload at the moment so I'll have to come back later and rant and rave some more. In the meanwhile, I just want to say thank you for posting this and... in the words of the Governator... I'll be back.
Thanks for vote whoring, I mean, referring me to this thread, Paul.Now that I have performed my end of the bargain and liked it, I guess the point I would like to make is that PC is just the latest manifestation of the desire of any group of people to elevate their moral views to legal status or at least some sort of semi-binding social pact.
It really gets up my goat that the Right have monopolised the term as a term of abuse, when it has been doing exactly the same thing since time immemorial.
The Right has always been about conformity to the existing moral vision, whereas the PC Left is about conformity to an alternative moral vision.
The problem for the PC Left is that they have to transform society to get to their destination, and the Right and probably most other people don't necessarily want to be transformed.
However, I don't see any other fundamental difference between the two.
Unfortunately, I gather that Nick Cohen is writing a book on PC, so we will soon have to deal with his self-righteous analysis.
Which probably makes me want to say that both brands of PC are in the realm of holier-than-thou self-righteousness.
Of course the problem is that pc is essentially something I completely support - less brutality, less contempt for the other, more r e s p e c t (find out what it meeans to me) - etc etc - and then it became another idea administered by humourless fools and their version became another stick for the Daily Mail/Sun/bloke in pub to beat the faint vestiges of anything slightly left.
That's exactly how I feel.It's a conspiracy to make people feel guilty about their desire to make things better or preserve what's better than the alternative.
I think old Cole Porter had the right idea.LIVE AND LET LIVE
(Cole Porter)
Piano & Vocal by Cole Porter
Live and let live, be and let be
Hear and let hear, see and let see
Sing and let sing, dance and let dance
You like Offenbach, I do not
So what, so what, so what
Read and let read, write and let write
Love and let love, bite and let bite
Live and let live, and remember this line
Your business is your business
And my business is mine
Live and let live, be and let be
Hear and let hear, see and let see
Drink and let drink, eat and let eat
You like bouillabaisse, I do not
So what, so what, so what
Talk and let talk, quip and let quip
Dress and let dress, strip and let strip
Live and let live, and remember this line
Your business is your business
And my business is mine
I'm liberal but to a degreeI want everybody to be free
But if you think I'm gonna let Barry goldwater
Move in next door and marry my daughter
You must think I'm crazy
I wouldn't do that for all the farms in Cuba
-Bob Dylan
Hi Velvetink - let's modify Cole a little...Live and let live, be and let be
Hear and let hear, see and let see
Sing and let sing, dance and let dance
You like people who suicide bomb in crowded London tube trains, I do not
So what, so what, so what
That might be a little more problematic!


