Will Byrnes's Reviews > The Passage

The Passage by Justin Cronin

by
1526851
's review
Aug 07, 10

Read in July, 2010

The hype machine was working. With some terrific reviews, this was immediately one of THE BOOKS TO READ for summer 2010, a vampire tale not written by Stephanie Meyer, and not even promoted very much as vampiric. Maybe our capacity for reading vampire novels has clotted somewhat?

The world in question begins in 2022. Gas is $13 a gallon. Iranian jihadists have killed hundreds at the Mall of America. Jenna Bush is Texas guv (this is a horror story, after all). New Orleans, battered by another monster storm, is now an uninhabitable industrial park. An expedition to a remote corner of South America, sponsored by the US Army, is searching for a promising and dangerous virus. What could possibly go wrong? The Passage is nothing if not very, very derivative. Although there are a few nifty new notions within its 766 pages, (I will not spoil them by telling) there will be little here that is not almost immediately familiar. Government projects gone wrong, post-apocalyptic struggles for survival, battles between good and evil, strong people, weak people, and lots and lots of vampires.

That said, I felt that there were almost two complete, independent books within the whole. The first tells of the beginning of the unpleasantness, lasts for 246 pages and is gripping. I hated to put the book down. Even with the been-there-read-that aspect of the book, there was something about the writing of that 246 pages that kept me turning the pages, thirsty for more. As for the remaining 520, not so much. We move forward almost a century and enter the too-familiar landscape of post-apocalyptic survival. Although there were elements here that were interesting, some characters that held promise, I found it a very, very long yawn. I also felt that the author cheated a few times too many in leading us to believe that certain events had taken place when they had not. He even jokes about it in the writing, having one character say out loud what any reader might wonder about how a particular event transpired.

If The Passage had kept up the frantic and so-engaging pace of its long opening, it would indeed have been one of THE BOOKS TO READ this summer. Instead of reading The Passage, though, I would look for an alternate route.

I gave it two stars instead of one because the beginning was so good. Otherwise, I resented the time it took to read this waaaaaay too long book.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Passage.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-23 of 23) (23 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ellen (new) - rated it 2 stars

Ellen Absolutely agree; the first section was very good (for this genre), and then it flat-lined. Nice review!


message 2: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Thanks. What was Salon thinking? the NY Times as well.


message 3: by Lou (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lou Exactly what I was just writing in my review after 250 so the new locations and people and writing just like another author.


message 4: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes It appears that we are not alone in sharing this view.

I have not read any other material by this writer, so have no basis for comparing this, the first (good) section, or the endless rest, with his other work. Maybe one part or the other is consistent with his other work, a comfort zone, and the other is new territory for him. No idea. Have you read anything by Cronin before?


message 5: by Maria (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maria Your review is spot on! I really wish that I could have been Cronin's editor and forced him to continue what he started in the first 246 pages. The second book of this trilogy should really be what started on page 247.


message 6: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Thanks Maria. We are in good company, as there are many who also found the book overhyped and disappointing.


message 7: by Nancy (new) - rated it 1 star

Nancy Totally agree!!!! Wonder where all the hype came from?


message 8: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Nancy wrote: "Totally agree!!!! Wonder where all the hype came from?"

Janet Maslin of the NY Times was a fan, as was Salon.com. Ditto Entertainment Weekly. It could not have hurt to have had a supportive quote from Stephen King.


message 9: by Rose (new) - rated it 2 stars

Rose I'm so in agreement. I REALLY resented having invested time in this book after the first part ended. I kept waiting for it to get better but it never did. You're right about screenplay-setup and sequel. What a horrible non-ending. I'm tired of books that can't conclude and must leave you hanging so BUY the next one, especially when they do it poorly with no evidence of an editor anywhere.


message 10: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Rose wrote: "I'm so in agreement. I REALLY resented having invested time in this book after the first part ended. I kept waiting for it to get better but it never did. You're right about screenplay-setup and se..."

I can't wait to pass on reading volume #2.


message 11: by Glenn (last edited 16 nov. 10:22) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Glenn Great review Will. I fully concur with your comments - the first third of the book was the best and then it strayed off course. It almost felt like two books and I felt much more invested in the characters introduced early in the book (Amy, her mother, Wolgast, Carter and Lacey).


message 12: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Thanks, Glenn. It seems that there are many who share our feeling about the book.


message 13: by Beth (new) - rated it 2 stars

Beth Reynolds All of these review pretty follow the same theme and the same thoughts I had while I was reading. So many high expectations were built from all the hype. I started it and was impressed and excited to see where Cronin was going to take it...only to be be so disappointed. Of all the directions I could see this story going....the result was one of the worst case scenarios in my opinion


message 14: by Anita (new) - rated it 3 stars

Anita Baião I profoundly agree with your review and the impression that I have is that the characters from the "second part of the book" were not really defined. The feeling I had was that Cronin was making too many tries regarding the characters personality and psychological profiles. Instead complex, we end up with schizophrenic "heroes", with no depth at all and I felt really confuse about some decisions they made. The author spends so many pages describing lines of thoughts and they end up make decisions that are not exactly explained.


message 15: by Caroline (new) - rated it 3 stars

Caroline Clifford Yes....you put it so clearly...."i resented the time it took to read this book..." lost a lotta time there


message 16: by S.L. (new) - rated it 3 stars

S.L. if u want a decent vampire series read Anne Rice's version of vampires much better. no sparkle mind u i enjoyed twilight minus the sparkle and no fangs. Or you cud read my series. As for this book i am having a real hard time getting into it. This is twice now i have picked it up and read to page 200 and i am like when is this going to get interesting? I want to put it down and skip it altogether but much like movies that suck i need to see it to the end. so i am in for 766 pages of suffering just so i kow what happens. However the sequel may not be added to my reading list. just sayin'.


message 17: by Will (last edited 01 déc. 22:20) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes S.L., I have had the pleasure of several of Anne Rice's books, much better than this one. You're right.

I am a bit surprised that you are finding it a no-go that early. Many of us who do not care for the book found the first third rather engaging. It is the latter two thirds that seemed, well, bloodless.


message 18: by Dana (new) - rated it 2 stars

Dana Severson Wish I had read your review before delving into this book. I too agree. Loved the beginning and have kept reading in hopes it would regain the same energy. Now I know I can set the book down and not worry about missing something.


message 19: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Just think how much time you might save by reading the other seven hundred or so. :-)


message 20: by S.L. (new) - rated it 3 stars

S.L. Will;
I have to say that I am not the biggest fan of stories that jump around from character to character. Its hard to visual when the story jumps to a different person each chapter. u just start to know the character and like them or not and then next chapter pops in and a whole new scene. and sometimes u read thru more than one chapter before u get back to the one person u were really starting to get into. I wouldn't say I wouldn't read another book like that because one of my fave authors is Stephen King and some of his books are like that, but one thing is for sure I didn't end up finishing it. I was very excited about reading it the cover grabbed me immediatly well both covers I have come across enticed me to buy it and I have read books just as long so the amount of pages was nothing. it just wasnt time for me to read it. maybe during my vacation i will try to continue on and get to the end of it. LOL
( by the way I am a huge horror, slasher, vampire supernatural fan so that wasn't it either.)
Cheers...


message 21: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes Many folks liked the book, S.L.. Maybe you will ultimately be among them.


message 22: by Jeffrey (new)

Jeffrey Keeten I was the 50th LIKE WOOHOO!!! Where are the balloons and the girls in short skirts jumping and yelling.

Oh well.

Since Cronin's new book is coming out I thought I would look to see how my GR friends liked the first one. I read maybe 100 pages and stalled. I set it aside for a short hiatus that turned into years. I was just chastising myself for neglecting this book when I read your review. You have lifted a burden from my shoulders friend. I officially moved the book to long hiatus.


message 23: by Will (new) - rated it 2 stars

Will Byrnes The girls with balloons are still here, and I wish they would knock it off. I need to get to sleep.


back to top