Nian's Reviews > Eragon
Eragon (Inheritance, #1)
by Christopher Paolini
by Christopher Paolini
Eragon has got to be one of the most tedious books I have ever read. I normally love fantasy (my love for Harry Potter is an indication of this) but Eragon, I could not get through. It was excruciatingly long for such a simple journey. He chances upon all things magical and makes such a big commotion of things. Everything is supposedly mysterious. But it is actually more annoying than mysterious. I love adventure, but his journey was slow paced and took f o r e v e r to get through.
The writing was terrible. There were so many details and not enough substance, and often times, I found myself cringing at some of the sentences, wondering what the heck did any of it meant. Most descriptive language and details were completely random. Why do I care for the pots and other utensils that lay in the house? How does that drive the story that is being told? Why do I care about that spot of dust (and much more, random stuff) in the stupid dungeon?!
Now, I'm green with envy that Paolini wrote this at such a young age, and published it pretty early too, but jealously and admiration are two different things. And I don't admire his work. Especially since he basically copied his ideas from previous fantasy books. He couldn't bring anything new to the table? And he received critical acclaim from this? Maybe I'll go copy Harry Potter and Twilight, too, and turn it into story about a bunch of teens going to Hogforks (a mix of Hogwarts and Forks) to train to become the best vampires so that they can kill this evil vampire beast called Goldemort, and I'll get critical acclaim and win all these awards too! Yay? Nay.
The writing was terrible. There were so many details and not enough substance, and often times, I found myself cringing at some of the sentences, wondering what the heck did any of it meant. Most descriptive language and details were completely random. Why do I care for the pots and other utensils that lay in the house? How does that drive the story that is being told? Why do I care about that spot of dust (and much more, random stuff) in the stupid dungeon?!
Now, I'm green with envy that Paolini wrote this at such a young age, and published it pretty early too, but jealously and admiration are two different things. And I don't admire his work. Especially since he basically copied his ideas from previous fantasy books. He couldn't bring anything new to the table? And he received critical acclaim from this? Maybe I'll go copy Harry Potter and Twilight, too, and turn it into story about a bunch of teens going to Hogforks (a mix of Hogwarts and Forks) to train to become the best vampires so that they can kill this evil vampire beast called Goldemort, and I'll get critical acclaim and win all these awards too! Yay? Nay.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Eragon.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Stuart
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
24 nov. 15:07
sorry, but he wrote the book before harry potter, and twilight. :P
reply
|
flag
*
that was not the point. He/she was saying he plagiarized from other books (like lotr i guess). The hp and twilight thing was just an ironic example of what is bad to do xD
I don't know if I am in a different world or what. How in the wold do you not love this book. I believe that the story concept is totally amazing.
I see that you are a jealous fool who believes that they could do better. The world is full of them. I can find similarities between this book and another I read rather recently "Blood Red Road". The scars, the wording, and more similarities I can't think of at the moment. Now I'm not saying that this book was the best thing ever, but I don't think it was horrendous. I actually applaud Christpoher for making a wonderful fantasy book that I liked. By the way, all of these opinions don't mean a bloody thing to me because my opinion counts more to me and I'm not gonna change it because of some jealous kids that loath the fact that they can't even IMAGINE to write a book as good as Christopher Paolini.
Awwwww, such lovely people you are, trying to tell me your opinion is better than my opinion! Don't worry folks, I totally got it :D
Eragon was published before Twilight or Harry Potter and besides Eragon has like NOTHING to do with the two
I love Harry Potter as well. I agree it did take me ages to read Eragon but I think it was worth reading. For some scenes

