Kaethe's Reviews > You

You by Charles Benoit

by
1072582
's review
Jul 01, 11

bookshelves: age-ya, fiction, friendship, contemporary
Read in April, 2011

You are a strawman, a character created in order to demonstrate how one bad choice in middle school can send your whole life spiraling out of control. But don't blame yourself. The author really stacked the deck against you. The thing that you supposedly love to do best is something we never get to see you do, or even express an opinion on. If video games are your great joy, why don't we ever get any insight into that? Likewise, the girl that matters so much to you, that you'd really like to get to know? Well, the author doesn't even let you listen to a single word she says when she does talk to you. So it turns out that there is no joy in your life at all, you're bright and bored because the author has sent you to loser high school where the teachers are slack and bored themselves and less knowledgeable than you are. Unlike the famous Holden Caulfield, who was also pretty disgusted with his life, antidepressants could help you, but no one appears to ever consider it, including the therapist you're forced to go to for your anger issues.

So your set up is grim from the very beginning, and then, as if that wasn't enough, the author of your cautionary tale sets you up against a SPOILER that has uncanny power to destroy. You are totally screwed, dude. I wouldn't bother to show up.

Library copy

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read You.
sign in »

Reading Progress

04/22/2011 page 17
8.0%
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Will (new)

Will Byrnes Bummer, man.


Kaethe A serious downer, that everyone else seems to really like.


message 3: by Will (new)

Will Byrnes Don't you hate it when you are so completely spot on and those around you just don't get it?


Kaethe Yes


message 5: by John (new)

John Egbert Ouch. Well, this is why I don't read those kinds of books.


Kaethe Thankfully most writers publishing YA aren't patronizing to their audience, and don't feel the need to beat them about the head and shoulders with an important moral.


message 7: by John (new)

John Egbert Thankfully indeed. I mean, I like a good moral and all, but geez -- no need to beat the moral moose.


Kaethe By "moral moose" I assume you mean the upstanding, albeit clueless, Bullwinkle?


message 9: by John (new)

John Egbert Yes, yes I do.


Kaethe Ha!


Chihuahua Zero I just published a blog post on why Kyle Chase fails as a protagonist, and you say a few of my thoughts.

The cards might be stacked against him from the beginning, but Kyle doesn't try to do anything to salvage his situation, or be interesting.


Kaethe That's a fair summation, I think.


back to top