Emma's Reviews > Songmaster

Songmaster by Orson Scott Card

by
623773
's review
Dec 18, 07

Read in January, 1995

this is truly my favorite scifi book of all time. it's got orphaned children, gay-questioning sex, weird psychic powers, enough tragedy to make me cry, and bards. How could I not love it? well, I did when I was 14. I really should qualify my sci-fi reviews since many of these are from my teenage years and it could be that if I read them now I'd be like huh what is this crap, like when you watch a cartoon movie like The Last Unicorn as an adult and think now why does that tree have boobs? But I bet that since this is Orson Scott Card and he has so many crown masterpieces in his oeuvre that it is still good even as a jaded older person.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Songmaster.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Oh man, The Last Unicorn, what a blast from the past. I adored that movie the first time I saw it...at < 10 years old. Then I saw it in my teens and wondered if I had the wrong movie. I felt the same way about Thundercats (didn't realize there were steroids on Third Earth), The Goonies (screamed dialogue = mute button), The Last Starfighter ('80's angst), even Disney's The Little Mermaid (how do those seashells stay on?).

Heh, crown masterpiece, aye!


Emma Heh heh, The Last Starfighter, good times. I still remember the scene where he took his face off. I've seen far grosser scenes on TV since then but that one stayed with me because I was impressionable enough to be truly horrified. His face! He peeled it off! Ewwwwwwww!!

A discussion of bad childhood movies must not neglect to mention Flight of the Navigator...oh yeah!


Libbie This review is awesome. I forgot about the tree with boobs. Thanks for reminding me!


Lindsey This was a fab review, I have to say. I'm 30 and reading this for the first time ever and have fallen quite in love with the concept of everything having its own song - every person, every room, every animal, every *mood*.

As for The Last Unicorn, let's not forget that Shmendrick almost suffocated in those tree boobs! Oh the horror. Talk about your tree huggers. Haha! Oh, can you even imagine the obituary...

The piece of my pop culture history I can't live down is the utter fascination I had with the Smurfs. I even remember back in the day, before they cut the show down to fit the half hour time slot, when the show was 99 minutes long. One minute of air time per Smurf! ...Madness.

When I grew up and found them again on cartoon network I was all kinds of delighted! Until I watched a couple of episodes. Man being a writer for that cartoon must have been such a gravy job. All adjectives and verbs could be replaced with 'smurfy' or 'smurf!' I found it all far from smurftastic and I wanted to smurf myself in the smurfy little smurf for being such an easily entertained kid. It smurfs me right off.




back to top