Kat Kennedy's Reviews > Unwind

Unwind by Neal Shusterman

by
3270188
's review
Jun 08, 10

bookshelves: leaves-awesomeness-behind, kat-s-book-reviews, i-learned-something-new, contemporary-fiction
Read from June 07 to August 06, 2010

I was walking back from my playgroup with my son on Monday, I came out of an elevator to find a teenage boy waiting for me. Fear and an urge to protect my son came over me as he looked a little "rough" around the edges.

Instead of pulling a knife or picking a fight though, the teenager turned on me with big, embarrassed, doe-eyes to ask in a quivering voice, "Excuse me, can I please have fifty cents to call my mum?" I fished out fifty cents worth of coins and left as soon as I saw him head towards the telephone, not waiting around to see if he got through to her. True story.

Unwind by Neal Shusterman is a novel about a world gone mad in which children between the ages of thirteen and eighteen can be legally signed over by their parents or guardians to be put through a harvest camp so that others can take their organs, tissue and blood.

Abortion is also illegal but people can leave infants on other people's doorstep as a method of "storking" and thus legally handing over their responsibilities of the child.

A common phrase used throughout this book is, "Someone else's problem." This encompasses the spirit of the book and is said often by adults who have had children fall temporarily into their hemisphere and require dealing with. There are very few adults in this book who do more than the bare minimum of what they have to do to sit right in their conscience and there's a whole bevy of others who don't do that much.

Connor, one of the trio of main protagonists and an indisputable Christ metaphor, is a "problem" child. His parents are at a loss as to how to handle his behavioral problems and his poor grades so they consign him to being unwound. Risa, a ward of the state, is a bed that the government can free up for a child that they can't legally unwind yet and so is also handed over to the harvesting camp. Levi, the last of the trio is a religious tithe by his parents - born and raised to serve God by handing him over to be tithed as part of their duty to the community and God.

There are many other such stories in this book from a boy whose loving parents died, leaving him an inheritance that his aunt feels would be better off putting her kids through college once he's been unwound and a boy whose divorcing parents couldn't agree on any custody solution and would rather, literally, divide him.

This whole book is about the powerlessness of children in the hands of those who should be responsible for them. It is at times nerve-wracking, heartbreaking, devastating and a complete adrenaline rush.

What it is most of all, though, is sad. Sad because the truth is that children are not the problem and they shouldn't be treated like a problem. They are a symptom at worst and a blessing always. They are a gift that requires attention. They are an innocent package and in the case of 99% of them - if they are running around the street as twelve year olds being a menace to society then they have not let us down - we have let them down.

I love this book because it is well written, I love this book because it is compelling. I love this book because sometimes it is a hard and challenging read on a personal level. I love this book because it asks you to think. I love this book for the many things it has revealed about me - most of them not positive. I love this book because it is well-written with absorbing characters and a great plot.

Most of all, I love this book because next time I come across a kid of the street asking for fifty cents to call his mum, I'll let him borrow my phone and make sure she's coming to get him.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Unwind.
sign in »

Reading Progress

06/07/2010 page 69
20.6% "This book is so traumatizing..." 2 comments
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-45 of 45) (45 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Annalisa Great review, Kat. This book made me want to hug my daughter a little more. It also made me think of those kids in bad homes who are just surviving until they turn eighteen and can be on their own.


message 2: by I am Isis (new)

I am Isis That's a great review. The one reason I haven't read this book yet is the same reason I didn't like The Hunger Games: I found the basis for the entire dystopian world really implausible. I don't think we could ever be a cruel enough society to decide to harvest unwanted kids for their organs (and what divorcing parents or aunt would give up a kid to basically be killed?)

But yeah, love your review.


Penny Great review! You've made me want to read this book again. I've been meaning to, since I've been meaning to write a review for this book as well. But really, there's no point now. You've said everything I wanted to say, and then some, and in a more eloquent manner.

I sort of want to bow down before you. Too bad you live in Australia and I don't. This will have to do----> *bows and worships Kat*

Seriously, though, how quickly did you read through this book? Were you unable to put it down like I was?


Wicked Incognito Now Wow. I've had this book on my radar for several years, but you definitely ratched it up for me.


Kristen "Kirby" Awesome review. I've seen this all the time at the bookstore, but always assumed it'd be a cheesy "kiddie" book.

Now I HAVE to read it.

pst- liked the little story introduction. Very effective at "hooking the audience". :P


Tatiana April, Kristen, you HAVE to read this book. Everybody does. I hardly met any people who were not affected by it.


Kat Kennedy Isis wrote: "That's a great review. The one reason I haven't read this book yet is the same reason I didn't like The Hunger Games: I found the basis for the entire dystopian world really implausible. I don't th..."

To be honest, with The Hunger Games I came to find that world, in its parameters, realistic.

I never quite did that with Unwind but I think that if this is the only reason that you don't read this book then you are missing out. I personally found I had to suspend my disbelief of this implausibility and that once I did - I found the novel to be brilliant.

Also, in many ways I think you'll find similar kind of ignorance in Unwind that there is in the real world. Unwinding isn't killing children. They're still alive, only in a divided state. It's okay because if they're unsettled whole, then unwinding helps them and gives them a peace. Unwinding is good for society and the children are really just being given a higher and better form of life.

April and Kristen, please, please read this book! It really is one of those books that stay with you!

Penny, you crack me up! Seriously, you're hilarious! I read this book in about five hours - I HAD to put it down a couple of times but I didn't want to, the world is very absorbing.

Tatiana - I read in your review how you were affected by the Harvesting scene - oh my goodness, I was crying so much and so angry at everyone! Somebody mentioned how it was ineffective doing it on Roland and that it should have been done to a likable character - I don't think I would have SURVIVED if I'd had to read that done to Connor of Risa!


message 8: by Jason (new)

Jason Smith Isis wrote: "That's a great review. The one reason I haven't read this book yet is the same reason I didn't like The Hunger Games: I found the basis for the entire dystopian world really implausible. I don't th..."

You obviously have not met my aunt...'shudders at what she would do if she could have (67th trimester abortion is possible).


Kat Kennedy You obviously have not met my aunt...'shudders at what she would do if she could have (67th trimester abortion is possible).

Lol! Yeah, there are some pretty scummy people in the world!

I'm just glad my grandmother never had the opportunity to get custody of me. Unwinding world would have been perfect for her!


message 10: by I am Isis (new)

I am Isis Ohhhh, see my conception of what "unwinding" is was completely off! Ok, I get it now.

Lol, my review for The Hunger Games explains why I don't find the world realistic. But I'm a big fan of 1984 and I really like science fiction in general (which has dealt with dystopian long before it was popularized lately) so I'm a hard critic for The Hunger Games. I think I'm like the only person on the planet who would categorize it as "mediocre" though :-P


Kat Kennedy Yes, I am in complete disbelief that ANYONE would find The Hunger Games mediocre! I will head over to your review though and check it out - but I LOVED that book.


message 12: by Megan (new) - rated it 2 stars

Megan Isis ~ I'm the only person who finds Unwind less than great, so maybe you should read it, then I won't be alone =) I also had a hard time buying the concept of unwinding, but the book is well written, despite the implausability of it all.

Kat ~ Actually, I felt the unwinding scene would have been more effective had it been done on a different kid than Roland. Yes, Shusterman did raise a ton of questions and gave his readers food for thought. But he was very careful to give us very good, redeemable kids. Not that anyone deserves unwinding ~ but I wish he would have made his story more complex and more in depth. Of course, then it would possibly become a very long adult series, rather than a quick YA read ;) But another reason I found Roland's story unbelieveale is because they didn't give him any sort of a sedative. Yeah ~ small point that has nothing to do with nothing :) But I am a nurse and reglarly give patients sedatives for a myriad of reasons. Despite the glory of giving back to the community in a divided state, I had a very hard time with the fact that this kid was given nothing to calm him down. I know ~ I am taking this way too seriously and Roland's awareness is what made the scene more powerful. But still... that kid needed a xanax, at the very least.


Kat Kennedy I understand what you're saying, Megan. I can only guess that they didn't give him something like Xanax because they seemed very specific and careful about what drugs were in the body while performing the procedure - and without blood, would it still have been carried through and as affective?

I think, over all, their "ethics" would not have allowed them to drug someone out of respect for their right to be aware and know what's happening to their bodies. The nurse said something about him having a right to know what was happening. *Barfs*

I'm also glad that it was Roland for a different reason then just because it would have been too hard if it were Connor and Risa. I'm glad it was Roland because he WAS redeemable. He wasn't a killer - he was a product. Was he a great person? No. But in the end you got to see EXACTLY what he was which was a scared and powerless child. He suffered EXACTLY his worst nightmare (for someone who NEEDS power and control he was stripped of every ounce of it at his most vulnerable time) and I think for me, it brought out my empathy. I couldn't hate him or despise him. The worst child in the book was unwound and instead of feeling like it was a justified end for him - I was still sickened. If the worst child in the book shouldn't be unwound - then none of them should. That was the way I saw it at least.


message 14: by Megan (new) - rated it 2 stars

Megan Yes, I agree that kids were not doped up due to some messed up "ethics" ~ and the nurse was horrible when she told Roland he had a right to be aware. Ugh!

I also agree with you that, "If the worst child in the book shouldn't be unwound - then none of them should."
Still don't know that I see Roland as someone who is guaranteed to be redeemable. Yes, he was a scared and powerless child, but then what bully isn't? We see him making the wrong decision over and over again and while that doesn't justify his unwinding... I think there is a good chance that he would have gone on to be a jerk in his adult life, as well.


Kat Kennedy Yeah, I agree Megan - I don't think there was a high chance that he would have redeemed himself any time soon or maybe even ever.

Maybe to me though, that's not the point. These people thought they knew him too. They had studied his file to within an inch of his life, knew him intimately. Commented on his circumstances and still coolly and efficiently took his life.

Who were they to judge his worth as a human being? Who are we? Who are we to decide that he would never do any good in this world and therefor is better off not in it?

This is the thing I love about this book - it does generate opinions and conversation! I love it.


message 16: by Megan (last edited 09. Juni, 03:20 Uhr) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Megan I haven't read anything else by Shusterman ~ wonder if all of his books are so thought provoking, or just this one? I'm guessing just this one because it is so close to the abortion debate... but I also love that Unwind generates so many conversations. Just what a book is supposed to do, right? =)


Cherrelle Great review. I read this novel not too long ago and it blew my mind. The part that really hit home for me was the scene in the book were the character Roland is being unwind. I still can't get that scene out of my head.
This was a great novel.


message 18: by new_user (new)

new_user What a wonderful review! Why haven't I come across this novel before! Going to add!


message 19: by Nishtha (new)

Nishtha Is this book like the island?? The movie!! It has scarlet jo---- sorry can't spel the last name???


Wicked Incognito Now Sort of. In The Island, the people were clones that were grown specifically for body parts, like this book:The House of the Scorpion and they don't know what is actually going to happen to them.

In Unwind, the kids are not clones. They are just kids whose parents decide they are too much trouble and opt to have them used for body parts. They sign them over for unwinding at some point in their childhood, and then they're carted off to be hacked apart.


Lyn (The Heartless) This book made me sick to my stomach, and I loved it for that.


message 22: by Maye (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maye Great review (whoever you are.) I will definitely add this onto my to-read shelf. Loved your little true story. :)


Angie Bishop I absolutely LOVE your review! And because of your stellar review, I will buy this book. I will buy this book and just go nuts with it. THANK YOU! <3


The Cover Contessa Great review.


message 25: by Zanahoria (Taly) (last edited 08. Mai, 03:02 Uhr) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zanahoria (Taly) Megan wrote: "I haven't read anything else by Shusterman ~ wonder if all of his books are so thought provoking, or just this one? I'm guessing just this one because it is so close to the abortion debate... but I..."

I read the Skinjacker Trilogy, and yeah, it seems so. He likes to pose itchy questions, and stretch them to their most grand, logical, horrific ends. I loved them.

This was a great review Kat. I loved how you framed it with personal experience. It is a book to take personally.


The Cover Contessa Zanahoria (Taly) wrote: "Megan wrote: "I haven't read anything else by Shusterman ~ wonder if all of his books are so thought provoking, or just this one? I'm guessing just this one because it is so close to the abortion d..."
I didn't know he had another series. I will have to look into that. I really enjoyed the book. Made you think.


Zanahoria (Taly) Oh yeah. And question some beliefs. And left me a bit catatonic. And my cheeks all salty.


message 28: by Hollie (new)

Hollie I don't think I could read this- I really want to but judging by how everyone talks about it, it would leave me scarred for life. I just don't think I could stomach the thought of a world like that. I would probably cry and throw up at the same time.Maybe one day I'll work up the courage :)


Kat Kennedy You should. You should always test yourself to imagine a world that is worse or you will fall into the trap of thinking the world is good.


message 30: by Roxy (new) - added it

Roxy I just started this and had to put it down to sleep. I've been thinking about it all day while doing my everyday tasks. I'm not even halfway and its changed the way I view some things. It's a sad book but I'm hoping the end result is what I'm hoping for.


message 31: by Urwah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Urwah This review makes the book sound more gripping.


message 32: by Lindsey (new) - added it

Lindsey What a moving & fabulous review! You make me want to run out and get this book right now.


message 33: by K8 (new) - rated it 2 stars

K8 I'm 33 pages in, and not moved by the writing at all. It feels ho-hum to me, devoid of good action words or descriptors. I feel nothing for these characters, despite knowing I should. A good writer would make me feel Risa's terror at the news or Connor's disappointment with Ariana. But I'm getting none of that. Am I alone in these feelings?

Good writing can bring life to a crappy story, but mediocre writing cancels out a good story. Should I stick with it? Does the writing improve?


Zanahoria (Taly) Stick with it a bit more. Same thing happened to me. Things start so fast you don't get enough time to care for the characters from go, but once that comes it takes your heart for the ride.


message 35: by K8 (new) - rated it 2 stars

K8 Zanahoria (Taly) wrote: "Stick with it a bit more. Same thing happened to me. Things start so fast you don't get enough time to care for the characters from go, but once that comes it takes your heart for the ride."

Thanks!


message 36: by Wei (new) - added it

Wei Cho I think your last paragraph was particularly heart-warming. Your review was eloquently written too, enough to make me mark this book as to-read.


message 37: by Dominika (new) - added it

Dominika Beautiful review!


Nadiraalisha help! what does bill of life means?


Kat Kennedy What are you asking on here for?


message 40: by Miriam (new)

Miriam Isn't the Bill of Life is the imaginary Constitutional amendment in the book?

http://unwind.wikia.com/wiki/The_Bill...


message 41: by H99 (new) - rated it 5 stars

H99 Miriam wrote: "Isn't the Bill of Life is the imaginary Constitutional amendment in the book?

http://unwind.wikia.com/wiki/The_Bill..."


Yes, I think it is. It is, after all, a Bill.


message 42: by Gordon (new) - added it

Gordon Shumway Beautiful review.


Safura0307 agree !!


message 44: by Nicki (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nicki Great review. Those are words coming from a mom, that's for sure. I can't imagine not doing everything possible to protect my son and daughter, and so far I'm disturbed by the willingness of the parents in this book to hand over their child. I'm only a little ways in too, I imagine I'll be in tears later on


message 45: by Mary (new) - added it

Mary Beth I was surprised how good this book was!! I never read anything like it and am looking forward to reading unwholly which is the sequel!


back to top