Sath's Reviews > We

We by Yevgeny Zamyatin

by
2056399
's review
Apr 14, 12

bookshelves: classics, utopia-dystopia, science-fiction, sfx-100-writers, 2011-must-read, reviewed
Recommended to Sath by: Aredhel
Read from February 11 to 13, 2011

This is one of those books that I knew I'd put off reviewing. When a book is classic, or popular, or iconic.. you just know you'll never find anything original to say that hasn't already been said, or that'll do the book justice.

We is set in a future utopian paradise, The One State, ruled by their glorious Benefactor. Everyone is a number, not a person, the emphasis is on cohesion, not individuality. Happiness has been reduced to an equation, but as such it it is solved, plug in the numbers and all citizens can live happy, well regulated lives. All wake at the same time each day in their transparent houses, dress the same, chew their food 50 times, go to their assigned work, and on their assigned day they get to draw the shades for 1 hour exactly for conjugal relations with their registered partner (sexual requirments calculated for each number based on their hormonal readings of course).

D-503 is the 'author' of the novel. He is the architect of the Integral, the space ship which was commissioned to take the expansion of their One State into space. All numbers have been called upon to write poetry and prose to extol the virtues of the One State to any alien species. D-503 is no poet, but a mathemetician, so he chooses to write a sort of diary, a collection of his daily thoughts on the one state, explanations of things which he believes uncivilised readers may not have the benefit of... and then as it progresses and he meets the inexplicably fascinating and frustrating I-330, who is not like other numbers.. She angers D, but he obsesses over her. She takes him beyond the Green Wall to the ancient house, where artifacts exist from the uncivilised time before the One State, and things begin to change for D.. well. I'll try for no spoilers here :)

D-503 is a very interesting narrator to have. He begins so innocently content with everything, and despite being no poet, the way he writes certain things when he is truly exstatic is almost psychadelic in it's poetry. At times he is frustratingly unaware for a protagonist, never quite being in the right place at the right time, and always one step behind the plot, reading through his thoughts I felt just as confounded as he was by I-330, by the secrets at the ancient house, by the disease of having a soul.

I can see clearly how this was the inspiration for 1984, there are many parallels between the two. The utopian communist style government. Their insular society, that is unaware of anything of interest outside of their walls. Then there is the Great Benefactor, who for the most part of the book is never seen, but comes across like a mysterious G-d (but of course he has to be a real person, but we never really know anything about him).

The book left various things unexplained and open. I wanted to know more about what was beyond the wall, about how the One State came to be, about who the benefactor was, and most of all how we come to read D-330's diary after what unfolds in the book. But the open-ness sort of leaves room for hope and it's good to imagine the various options for myself, it's not so much disappointing as it is frustrating.

But it's definately a brilliant novel, definately worth 5 stars, possibly worth a favourite. If you love dystopian fiction, and love to have the fear of tyrannical governments struck into you, then read it!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read We.
sign in »

Quotes Sath Liked

Yevgeny Zamyatin
“The only means of ridding man of crime is ridding him of freedom.”
Yevgeny Zamyatin, We


Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Aredhel (last edited Jan 21, 2011 06:56am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Aredhel It was my first dystopian novel *sighs* - and it was a long time ago :))I sincerely hope you like it!
And maybe it's a bit out of subject but I have to say your taste in music is just awesome! Love all the bands you listen to ;)))


Sath Thanks!
And I don't mind that its out of subject. I'm glad you like my taste in music. What are you favourite bands? YOu don't have a last.fm account do you?


Aredhel I had it once, but as I didn't have much use of it I deleted all the information and just forgot about it..
And regarding bands..There are so many of them! But I think my most favorite are Placebo, Breaking Benjamin, Poets of the Fall, Within Temptation, Skillet, Coldplay, Muse and..and..almost every band that is mentioned on your profile on last.fm! Can't live without music! Especially without rock and alt rock. And I have a soft spot for britpop :))
Though I don't have a last.fm account I have a LJ one :))Hope you won't mind my asking to become your LJ friend?)))


Sath Yay great taste in music then! :) For some reason I hadn't suspected you were a rock fan! but then strangely enough it usually goes along with a fondness for fantasy and sci fi, wonder why that is? I couldn't live without Rock either.

Yes you can friend me on LJ, but I warn I don't post much, and lately I am only using it to keep a record of my excercising regime, haha, boring huh.
But my name on there is Sath.


Aredhel Sath wrote: "For some reason I hadn't suspected you were a rock fan!"

ahaha)) I guess I just don't look like a rock fan :) But then again I think no one knows how they should really look like :))))

Sath wrote: "but then strangely enough it usually goes along with a fondness for fantasy and sci fi"

You are right! I have my theory that it's somehow connected with that feeling of "epicness" that good fantasy and sci fi books always have about them, and usually rock music has that feeling about it, too - can't say this about pop culture..Sounds rather obscure, but I think this idea has its right to exist ;)


Sath No, you are right! Fantasy and Rock are both EPIC :D
Plus it's about being transported to another world, and imagination, and things like that.
Where as pop just goes with chick lit, cos its just about money and clothes and makeup... blehhhhh nasty!


Aredhel I'm so glad you liked it! Well, I pretty much hoped you would like it. :) for me it's one of the best dystopian novels and one of the best examples of the Ru literature in general.


Sath Of course I liked it, I loved it! :) I read it in english, but it seemed like a very good translation, of course I have no way of knowing how it compares to original russion :)

I've been putting off writing the review for it tho because it's so daunting. It's really hard to review a classic, so much has already been said before, and how can I do it justice!


Aredhel I know what you mean :) Classic books are..well..they are classic books. They have been already appreciated by the millions of readers. It's hard to tell anything new about them.
But I still hope to read your review soon :)) because I'd really like to know your opinion on this one :))


back to top