Surreysmum's Reviews > Monk's Hood

Monk's Hood by Ellis Peters
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
May 23, 2010

liked it
bookshelves: 1985, mystery
Read in September, 1985

** spoiler alert ** [These notes were made in 1985:]. "A Medieval Whodunnit". Cadfael is a Welsh monk near the England/Wales border. He is also a shrewd observer, and he (as well as the people he observes) is humane if not fully human. In fact, Cadfael pretty much makes it to "human"; the suspects in the murder tend to be defined by their roles a bit. Bastard son; discontented slave; hot-tempered young rightful heir - all of them at some point are suspected of putting the poisonous balm made from Monk's-hood into the rich old man's food. The border is important, for under English law, the murderer (Meurig - the bastard son) has no reason to kill his father, but under Welsh law, he is an inheritor & therefore has reasons to feel aggrieved. Peters weaves in just enough medieval law and church politics to make all this comprehensible; it's a bit daft to compare this to Name of the Rose, which is a much more complex work, and a one-shot effort. But the two share at least some genuine evidence of their authors' erudition. I was not tremendously bowled over (Cadfael is rather more matter-of-fact than your standard detective-hero) but I was pleased by this book. I was particularly pleased by the ending in which, Father-Brown style but with more plausibility, Cadfael chooses to let the murderer go free of the outer, no' not the inner consequences of his crime

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Monk's Hood.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.