John's Reviews > The Tudors

The Tudors by G.J. Meyer

by
290848
's review
May 27, 10

bookshelves: audiobook, history
Read in May, 2010

Historically accurate perhaps, though incredibly slanted.

Henry VIII was a bully/monster/tyrant. Period. End of Story. Most of the coverage of his reign focused on the men around him, and their roles in enforcing the break with Rome, as well as persecution of monks during the dissolution of the monasteries.
Edward VI was a fervent Protestant, but ... that was okay as he truly respected his sister Mary (in spite of their religious differences) - not a syllable to acknowledge the fact that (according to other books), he genuinely liked Elizabeth.
Mary was a well-meaning, tragic figure, in spite of all those unfortunate burnings, which, yes, were ultimately her responsibility, but weren't really so bad, especially compared to the brutality of her father and sister.
Elizabeth was Bad News - no two ways about it. So bad, that it might've been better for Jane Grey to have remained, and her heirs to follow, even if that meant sacrificing Mary in the process. Seriously! Meyer does his best to portray Mary Queen of Scots as a sensible, trustworthy counter-figure; the wrong chick got the chop (conveniently omitting that although Walsingham gave her the bait, she fell for it). We hear how the Jesuits sneaking into England were there only to minister to the oppressed minority, no threat at all. The author conveniently neglects to mention that by the 1580's, the Pope was crying for Elizabeth's head, strongly encouraging her assassination. There was indeed anti-Catholic sentiment among (at least some of) Elizabeth's advisers, but Meyer would have the reader believe that was entirely the result of xenophobia and bigotry. Regarding the St. Bartholomew's Day slaughter of French Huguenots, which influenced Elizabeth in favor of those advisers, Meyer maintains "they asked for it in displaying their wealth" (paraphrased).

As a rough parallel: Henry VIII = Reagan (bad!); Edward VI = Bush daddy (bad, but you can't help feeling a little sorry for him); Mary = Clinton (good intentions, but things didn't work out as well as they should've); and Elizabeth as Bush Jr. - just plain awful, including a sly comparison of her speech at Tilbury to the Armada troops (play acting), and her refusal to care for the returning diseased veterans.

Now you know what to expect.





Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Tudors.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Alisa (new)

Alisa Thanks. You just saved me from buying a copy of this book and then being incredibly annoyed by it!


message 2: by Brittany B. (new) - added it

Brittany B. Agreed!!!! Completely. So much bias that it is hard for me to keep reading.


message 3: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer I'm 80 pages in and this pretty much wraps up my initial impressions. I have a looong way to go...


back to top