Esteban del Mal's Reviews > In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex

In the Heart of the Sea by Nathaniel Philbrick

by
2251009
's review
May 26, 10

bookshelves: americana, non-fiction, treadmill-to-oblivion
Read from May 11 to 26, 2010

There’s one thing you need to know about me: I’ve never listened to a song by Rush all the way through. Really. If Alvin and the Chipmunks were re-imagined as opera singers, the lead singer could be bass. I can’t take them seriously.

Okay, okay. Really there are two things you need to know about me: I distrust people who walk on the balls of their feet. You know, that little bounce? Call it instinct, but I see something morally deficient in it. It’s like Nature is giving the rest of us a heads-up.

Hold on. There are three things you need to know about me: at the age of three, I watched the movie Jaws in its entirety from the back seat of my parents Volkswagen Bug at a drive-in theater. Poor things thought I was asleep and had absolutely no intention of traumatizing their only child. To this day, I have an abnormal fear of the ocean; and yet, I am morbidly drawn to stories about the same.

No, wait. There’re four things you need to know about me: I don’t like to work. At all. I’d go so far as to assert that I am entirely abnormal in my contempt for it. A sort of cynical pragmatism colors my approach to adult life and all its attendant cares. I think of myself as seeking out a sort of hedonistic equilibrium, whereby I maximize the amount of money I earn while doing the least amount of work. And to that end, I am happy to report, I have been largely successful.

Why am I sharing all this? Because, taken in total, it shows that I would make a very poor excuse of a whaleman in this, our present age, let alone the early-19th century. Sure, it’s altogether speculative to take a modern fellow like myself and plant him in an earlier time. What if I’d been raised in a whaling family? A whaling tradition?

Bosh.

Trust me in this. I was raised in a working class family and it didn’t take me long to understand what work does to you: it takes your best years, covering them in spoonfuls of regret little by little until you realize too late all the money in the world can’t buy back what you could’ve done, what you could've been. Why do we American inheritors of the Nantucket Quaker whaling business model always prove so stressed out whenever the United Nations releases its latest sociological metrics? Because we spend all our time away from our friends and families, doing stuff we don’t like, so we can buy stuff we don’t need.

No. Leisure is the truest wealth. Me? I would’ve sought out some petty job, made merry in my off-hours and, hopefully, have been literate enough to enjoy some letter-writing and the occasional book.

Fine, you say. What’s this got to do with Nathaniel Philbrick’s book?

Well. It means all you overachieving-types would’ve been on that doomed ship, while I sat comfortably on terra firma. You should be happy about that, at least. Consider some of the aforementioned details about me -- I’m obviously prone to psychological imbalance. I surely would have cannibalized you had we found ourselves in the dire circumstances of the crew of the Essex, adrift for over three months in the South Pacific. And my probability of success would’ve been more than fair: I stand 6’4” tall, have pointy eye-teeth and a trailer park adolescence mean streak. True, I am near-sighted, but this would only be a minor inconvenience, since I would only have to track you around a 20’ long boat.

Where are all your Goodreads votes now, fancy pants?

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read In the Heart of the Sea.
sign in »

Reading Progress

05/15/2010 page 35
11.59% "...in 1979 a six-inch plaster penis...was discovered hidden in the chimney of a house in the island's historic district."
05/18/2010 page 62
20.53% "Thirty hogs in the Isle of May/Duff every other day/Butter and cheese as much as you could sway/And now you want more beef, damn you."
05/19/2010 page 110
36.42% "The creature's tail continued to work up and down, pushing the 238-ton ship backward until...water surged up over the transom."
05/26/2010 page 239
79.14% "The reading of this wondrous story upon the landless sea," Melville remembered, "and so close to the very latitude of the shipwreck had a surprising effect upon me."

Comments (showing 1-48 of 48) (48 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

karen here's mine, bitch!


message 2: by Eh?Eh! (last edited May 26, 2010 06:47pm) (new)

Eh?Eh! I share your #2 item. Since most boys seem to outgrow it (I've never seen females with the bounce-step), I always thought it was to hitch their saggy pants up. Futilely.

I would be one of the industrious eaten folk.


Esteban del Mal Thanks, karen! I'm sure that if you were garnished with some mussels and seaweed, you'd be delicious.


Esteban del Mal Oh yes, Eh! You certainly would've been eaten, too. It's painful to see those I've grown so close to become little more than items on a menu. So sad.


karen pssh - i read this book, too, and several others about cannibalism. i don't care how tall you are - i will eat you before you ever eat me.


message 6: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Well...in my industriousness, I would've noticed your lazy a** and marked you for an "accident" in case of disaster. I act pre-emptively and with finality. Esteban a la Eh!.


Esteban del Mal karen wrote: "pssh - i read this book, too, and several others about cannibalism. i don't care how tall you are - i will eat you before you ever eat me."

Pffft. Whatever. You'd just be another drumstick in my cannibal's feast. I've made it this far in life out of pure spite -- put me in a little boat in the middle of the ocean with a small prospect of rescue, no food and no authorities to curb the natural evolution of passive-aggression and it'd be GAME OVER.


karen your confidence will taste delicious.


Esteban del Mal Eh! wrote: "Well...in my industriousness, I would've noticed your lazy a** and marked you for an "accident" in case of disaster. I act pre-emptively and with finality. Esteban a la Eh!."

No, no. You would've needed me, because I already would've eaten a few of the weaker ones among the crew. I'm pretty big and need a lot of calories. Hard tack wouldn't have been enough even when we were on the ship. I woulda been pre-emptively cannibalizing.


Esteban del Mal karen wrote: "your confidence will taste delicious."

You'd be too busy reading and writing to ever see it coming. Probably be melting some wax and making an impression with your signet ring on some lavender-scented stationary as I cudgeled you to death. If it's any consolation, I'd see to it that your final letter was delivered (that is, if I didn't eat it first).


message 11: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Hold up there, Este-brisket. In solidarity I'd have karen's back and would garrotte you before the cudgel was lifted to clobbering height. A swift suffocating death would preserve your muscle from icky adrenaline.


karen i am scrappy with the hearing of a wolf.

sensing you behind me, i would spin around and jam my writing utensil into your jugular. then i would wrap you in a blanket and tuck you under my bunk, and tell everyone you jumped overboard in despair over a lost love back dockside.


message 13: by Miriam (new)

Miriam Wait, how did Esteban get on the whaling ship? I thought we had established that he would be in port working at the pub or some such. Esteban, I don't know you from Ahab but your review has me picturing you as one of those bartenders who reads a book while filling pints in an unhurried manner.


message 14: by Ceridwen (new)

Ceridwen I vote because I fear you. Like, in a nice way.


message 15: by Buck (new)

Buck I voted because it's zanily brilliant, despite the continuity problems.


Esteban del Mal karen wrote: "i am scrappy with the hearing of a wolf.

sensing you behind me, i would spin around and jam my writing utensil into your jugular. then i would wrap you in a blanket and tuck you under my bunk, and..."


Well played, my cagey opponent. Too bad for you, it is an acknowledged fact that we del Mals do not have lost loves. Ever.


Esteban del Mal Eh! wrote: "Hold up there, Este-brisket. In solidarity I'd have karen's back and would garrotte you before the cudgel was lifted to clobbering height. A swift suffocating death would preserve your muscle fro..."

Eh! It's the open ocean! Where do you get the garrote? Dried fish intestine? Poo. I'd be sucking the marrow from your dried bones before you finished one of your cute little engineering thoughts in said Hobbesian hellscape.


Esteban del Mal @Miriam -- It's not necessary to know me. Not a bartender, but my wife was. Work in one of those technical jobs where I get paid not for what I do, but what I know (and I've managed to convince someone I know something). Now get in my belly.

@Ceridwen -- See? Zombies did jump the shark! It's all about cannibals!

@Buck -- It has continuity problems because I'm hungry.


message 19: by Ceridwen (new)

Ceridwen See? Zombies did jump the shark! It's all about cannibals!

Oh, same dif.


Esteban del Mal Ceridwen wrote: "See? Zombies did jump the shark! It's all about cannibals!

Oh, same dif."


Hardly. I'm CONSCIOUS in the eating of my fellows.


message 21: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Esteban wrote: "Eh! It's the open ocean! Where do you get the garrote?."

I carry one with me at all times. It tucks away nicely in the hair. Part of that industriousness that would have me hauling nets aboard that whaleship and surviving on your carcass.


Zombies didn't jump the shark! Cannibals jumped the shark with the movie Alive.


Esteban del Mal Eh! wrote: "Esteban wrote: "Eh! It's the open ocean! Where do you get the garrote?."

I carry one with me at all times. It tucks away nicely in the hair. Part of that industriousness that would have me hauli..."


Mmmmmm! That garrote would make for some good fiber, after all that vitamin-rich Eh! meat.

Cannibals vs. Zombies!


message 23: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow I vote for the word "fancypants," which is a personal fave.

I hate to rain on all y'all's parade, but you have to draw straws with cannibalism. Many an honest sailor has wound up with a life sentence for preying on the weakest element. You could take your chances with the law if you want, though. If you don't eat me, I'll represent you at trial . . . in hell.


Aerin Are there still laws on the books for this type of situation?


message 25: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow It's common law, so not on the books, but it's the way judges decide stuff traditionally. I don't think it comes up a lot, so they would probably consider the tradition. That's the gist of cannibal law anyway.


Aerin Good to know. You never know when that kind of info might be useful!


message 27: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow No kidding. I hope it's in survival guides and whatnot.


karen i am only nomming in self-defense.


Esteban del Mal Meredith wrote: "I vote for the word "fancypants," which is a personal fave.

I hate to rain on all y'all's parade, but you have to draw straws with cannibalism. Many an honest sailor has wound up with a life sent..."


No, no, no. Lawyerly-types go first. Everyone knows that you people don't spoil.


message 30: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow Dang! No one was supposed to know!


message 31: by Ademption (new)

Ademption Esteban wrote: "Lawyerly-types go first. Everyone knows that you people don't spoil.

Exactly, which is why lawyers so go near the end. The sweet stuff, the stuff that WILL spoil should be eaten first. The hardy, gristly, keep-well types should compose the final emergency rations.

Plus, having a notary onhand to sign an affidavit attesting that the cannibalism was decided by lots, whether it actually was or not, does more for one's case were it ever to go to trial. So I read somewhere. I think in a Meredith review.


message 33: by D. (new)

D. Pow I like Rush. A lot. Most of my friends consider this the biggest chink in my armor of good taste. I'm okay with it. Never walked on the balls of my feet, though. That bugs.


Esteban del Mal Evan wrote: "Esteban wrote: "Lawyerly-types go first. Everyone knows that you people don't spoil.

Exactly, which is why lawyers so go near the end. The sweet stuff, the stuff that WILL spoil should be eaten ..."


No way! Meredith will keep -- you slaughter her and tuck her away in some of her books like jerky. Just make like you're studying up on something, say, like affidavits, when in reality you're snapping into a Slim Jim. You play dumb about her whereabouts while the rest of the herd roams around the boat a la free range. When you get to a hankering for something fresh, BANG!


Esteban del Mal D. wrote: "I like Rush. A lot. Most of my friends consider this the biggest chink in my armor of good taste. I'm okay with it. Never walked on the balls of my feet, though. That bugs."

Dear God, D. I'm going to have to re-think you.


message 36: by Ademption (last edited May 27, 2010 11:41am) (new)

Ademption @Esteban

Curing human slim jims on a sea voyage?!

This is executive thinking. I think you should start studying for the LSAT or GMAT.


message 37: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow Whatever I can do for the greater good, ya know? Just as long as you don't say I didn't warn you when you all get life sentences for improper cannibalism.

Note to self: avoid sea voyages.


Esteban del Mal Evan wrote: "@Esteban

Curing human slim jims on a sea voyage?!

This is executive thinking. I think you should start studying for the LSAT or GMAT."


Well, I don't wanna toot my own horn, but I did take a few accounting classes as an undergrad.


Esteban del Mal Meredith wrote: "Whatever I can do for the greater good, ya know? Just as long as you don't say I didn't warn you when you all get life sentences for improper cannibalism.

Note to self: avoid sea voyages."


Only one life sentence, Meredith. Only one.


message 40: by Ademption (last edited May 27, 2010 11:53am) (new)

Ademption Cannibalism is kind of a career topper. There really isn't anything that can be done after. It is ne plus ultra of criminal behavior.

The Japanese cannibal, Issei Sagawa, wrote restaurant reviews later in life. That's quite a steeply descending curve in aspirational trajectory.


message 41: by Sparrow (new)

Sparrow Esteban wrote: "Only one life sentence, Meredith. Only one."

Wow. You've really got a long stay planned, huh? This thread's getting a little Hannibal Lecter for me. Excuse me while I go hide in the Virginia Woolf club.


Esteban del Mal @Evan -- *snort* I'll have to look him up. I'm a no frills kinda guy, salt and pepper would suit me fine.

@Meredith -- Given enough time, Woolf woulda become a cannibal. No question.


Esteban del Mal Okay, okay...just wiki'd Sagawa. Lost my milk and cookies. I'm all talk.


message 44: by Ademption (last edited May 27, 2010 12:30pm) (new)

Ademption Yeah, whenever you think crime couldn't get any more messed up, you can find a Japanese precedent that defies all of what you thought made sense.

Because there were no French laws about foreigners eating a Dutch girl, Sagawa was extradited to Japan, where he just lives as a bizarre curio.

His situation is beyond weird. Imagine Hannibal Lecter isn't a supersane mastermind escaping from secure mental wards, but a guy who aspires to write liner notes and bums smokes outside train stations, and thinks of his past "indiscretion" as something of a one-night stand that can be milked for his freelance writing gigs.


message 46: by Deb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deb Driscoll You guys are pretty funny but guess what? Draw the short straw and I'll be eating your liver with some fava beans and a nice chianti.


Jennifer I walk on the balls of my feet because I have unusually high arches and they strain easily. But then I am resonably morally deficient so it's swings and roundabouts really.


back to top