Jen's Reviews > A is for Alibi
A is for Alibi (Kinsey Millhone, #1)
by Sue Grafton
by Sue Grafton
Kinsey Millhone is a single female working as a private investigator in Santa Theresa, California. She is hired by Nikki Fife, the convicted murdered of Lawrence Fife (her husband), to find out who really killed him. Her investigation leads her into a series of other murders that seem to be connected.
I don't know if I can even justify one star on this book. I was at no point able to "connect" with Kinsey. I love a strong female character, but she does not fit that bill. She is crass which makes her seem uneducated and low-class. Attempts at presenting emotion from her were not believable; she simply came across as apathetic the entire novel. And how she could solve any crime with the amount of alcohol she consumed in this book is beyond me. Aside from the lack of dimension in her character, I am also not a fan of Grafton's writing style. This is the first book I've read of hers and from the get go, I was not impressed. At first I thought maybe I would try reading a couple of her books before I made a decision, but I don't think I could make it through another book of this caliber. The book was completely predictable. The outcome was obvious before you even hit the midpoint. Grafton tends to include pointless detail that does nothing to further the plot. And there are so many problems with the logic throughout the novel. For example, she says that Kinsey wipes down her Las Vegas hotel room to get rid of prints. Yet she paid her bill, SIGNED the bill and both owners of the hotel saw and talked to her. If she's trying to get rid of her presence in the hotel, she left an awfully bright trail...afterall, if someone were trying to establish she was there, wouldn't fingerprinting be further down the road from eyewitness accounts and paper records?
This was definitely a let-down, and I will not be pursuing any further letters of the alphabet. There are far more interesting books out there to fill my time.
I don't know if I can even justify one star on this book. I was at no point able to "connect" with Kinsey. I love a strong female character, but she does not fit that bill. She is crass which makes her seem uneducated and low-class. Attempts at presenting emotion from her were not believable; she simply came across as apathetic the entire novel. And how she could solve any crime with the amount of alcohol she consumed in this book is beyond me. Aside from the lack of dimension in her character, I am also not a fan of Grafton's writing style. This is the first book I've read of hers and from the get go, I was not impressed. At first I thought maybe I would try reading a couple of her books before I made a decision, but I don't think I could make it through another book of this caliber. The book was completely predictable. The outcome was obvious before you even hit the midpoint. Grafton tends to include pointless detail that does nothing to further the plot. And there are so many problems with the logic throughout the novel. For example, she says that Kinsey wipes down her Las Vegas hotel room to get rid of prints. Yet she paid her bill, SIGNED the bill and both owners of the hotel saw and talked to her. If she's trying to get rid of her presence in the hotel, she left an awfully bright trail...afterall, if someone were trying to establish she was there, wouldn't fingerprinting be further down the road from eyewitness accounts and paper records?
This was definitely a let-down, and I will not be pursuing any further letters of the alphabet. There are far more interesting books out there to fill my time.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A is for Alibi.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-7 of 7) (7 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Veronica
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
May 19, 2011 04:52pm
I have to agree with. I was not inspired to contine with series.
reply
|
flag
*
You raise a lot of good points. I remember thinking the same thing about wiping her prints away. I had a hard time caring about the case for much of the book.But I liked Kinsey more than you did. And the hard drinking PI is a dualisms the genre - though I didn't feel it was excessive.
On a lighter note, I kept thinking a cell phone and voicemail would have been a big help!
@Derrick you know the book was written in 1982, right? But I wondered why she wiped the prints but used a credit card for the hotel bill and didn't ask to use cash and take the registration card with her.
I got to about 48% on the kindle and called it a day..I'd been struggling with the boring and useless details for a while.
I can see where people get their points from It took me forever to get to the end bc I was procrastinating but I'm hooked and am about to start I is for Innocent


