Devin's Reviews > Red: The Heroic Rescue

Red by Ted Dekker

by
3638874
's review
May 14, 10

bookshelves: fiction, christian
Read from May 12 to 15, 2010

** spoiler alert ** In Black, I was introduced to an exciting story littered with allusions to Ted Dekker's Pentecostal theology. In Red, Dekker presents a very clear redemptive analogy in the more fantastic of the two worlds in this book. Dekker emphasizes Arminian, free-will salvation at every turn. Dekker goes so far as to have the "Jesus" character tell his followers that they are "cured" (ultimately) because they choose to obey him. Also, Dekker's view on the bridegroom-bride relationship between Jesus and the church is rather simple and almost shallow. Dekker only meets theology on a level that positively engages the emotions, going no further.

However, this book is quite an emotional ride, and this is largely why I have enjoyed The Circle Series so far. Dekker is a brilliant writer. I just wish he could be considered, in some measure, a theologian.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Red.
sign in »

Reading Progress

05/12/2010 page 1
0.26% "Here we go..."
05/12/2010 page 97
25.46% "Really, Dekker? You're gonna go all egalitarian on me, now?"
05/12/2010 page 109
28.61% "Soon, I'll find out what Dekker thinks about heretics. Right now, they look like good guys."
05/14/2010 page 166
43.57% "Dekker owns!"
05/14/2010 page 318
83.46% "Chapter 28 shows me how bad Dekker's theology is. This is hard to endure."
show 2 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Joshua (last edited May 17, 2010 09:09am) (new)

Joshua Schneider It is good to see a review of a fiction book which values both what the story proclaims as truth as well as the emotional effects that it has. Emotions should not be teaching theology. Reminds me of what has been going on with that book The Shack.


message 2: by Devin (last edited May 17, 2010 09:44am) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Devin Joshua wrote: "It is good to see a review of a fiction book which values both what the story proclaims as truth as well as the emotional effects that it has. Emotions should not be teaching theology. Reminds me o..."

At the time, I didn't really notice the theological underpinnings of The Shack, but after some solid theological education in college, I now understand the dangers of such novels. Thanks for appreciating my review. Often, I find that people are offended when you critique a heartwarming story's underlying theological or philosophical framework.


Bethany Haha... you ARE a tough critic Devin [if I remember right, most of your books you've rated 3 stars and "ok".... I was like "does he even ENJOY any of the books he's reading?":], but that's good because it pushes people like me to think harder and encourages me not to not "approve" something just to be nice.


back to top