I wasn’t really in the mood for folk or fairy tales, but this is the last book I must return tomorrow to the library, so I read it.
I loved the illustI wasn’t really in the mood for folk or fairy tales, but this is the last book I must return tomorrow to the library, so I read it.
I loved the illustrations, which are glorious. I loved the message that getting something without working for it isn’t satisfying, and loved how Biddy found the magic within herself.
However, I absolutely hated the end. I have little doubt that the story follows what’s considered a sensible pattern, but I was left feeling very morose. What is probably meant to be a happy ending, filled me with sadness. That’s not always a bad thing, but I guess I’m not familiar with this type of tale because I was not expecting what happened, and I wasn’t happy about it. I know that’s my fault for being clueless about this type of tale. I’m thinking I’d have had to have more knowledge and been in a different mood to fully appreciate this story’s ending.
Given how lovely the pictures are and how overall satisfying the tale is, I have to give this at least 3 ½ stars. It’s a beautifully done book....more
When I picked this up, I’d assumed it was a picture book. It’s not. It’s illustrated but it’s so heavy on text, I don’t consider it to be a picture boWhen I picked this up, I’d assumed it was a picture book. It’s not. It’s illustrated but it’s so heavy on text, I don’t consider it to be a picture book. It’s a very short (64 pages) illustrated chapter book.
I’m not that interested in Valentine’s Day so I am not the best audience for this book, but I did find parts interesting. I liked the instructions/presentation for some of the crafts that can be made. I enjoyed some of the history; I learned a few things.
In fact, the information presented is sufficiently sophisticated (and disturbing) that I think I’d recommend this book for ages (at least) 9-13, and through adulthood for readers interested in this subject matter.
But, I didn’t find the presentation that fascinating; it was interesting though.
The illustrations are all in black and white, but they’re very charming.
How St. Valentine’s Day Came to Be Valentines Cross the Atlantic True-Love Tokens Enter Cupid Valentine Love Birds Hearts and Sweethearts Roses are Red Valentine Lace Red, Pink, and White Valentine Goodies Stories and Poems for Valentine’s Day Sources Index
The back cover of this book makes it clear that this author-illustrator team have a series of holiday books. The other books listed on the back are about St. Patrick’s Day, Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas. And a book about the Fourth of July by this illustrator but another author is also listed....more
I was greatly touched by this story and I really love it. I admit when I got to the end, my cynical self said this probably wouldn’t happen, but of coI was greatly touched by this story and I really love it. I admit when I got to the end, my cynical self said this probably wouldn’t happen, but of course with some people it would. I love the depiction of the poor but loving shtetl family, especially the imaginations of the three daughters, and the moral of the story, of how important it is to be generous, with help & charity, and with friendship too.
The illustrations are wonderful, eliciting pure joy from me.
At the back of the book there is one page of text that educates about Hanukkah, and it does so in an interesting way, even for younger children.
According to the author, this story was told to her by her father, who learned it from a man whose father had lived in a shtetl; I love stories passed down orally, and appreciate when they are put to paper as this one was.
This is a perfect book for family reading during Hanukkah, and is a good story for learning about Hanukkah, for when a group or family wants to discuss selfishness and generosity, and empathy, and also it’s just a good family and sisters story.
4 ½ stars, ½ star off from this curmudgeon who thinks it might be overly optimistic...more
I LOVE chocolate. I love that the recipe at the end of the book for Mexican hot cocoa is for the traditional, “accidentally vegan” version, even thougI LOVE chocolate. I love that the recipe at the end of the book for Mexican hot cocoa is for the traditional, “accidentally vegan” version, even though this variation is not my personal favorite. Most kids who try it without the suggested variations are likely to be surprised by the flavor.
The illustrations are deliberately influenced by Mayan and Aztec art. They’re cut-paper and collage. They fit the tale well and I found them interesting, although they’re not all that aesthetically pleasing to me. I did like the colors, the people, especially their eyes & their facial expressions, and the frog, and the boldness and vividness of the illustrations and how they fill the page. The gods were kind of creepy and might scare some children if the story is not read with a lighthearted voice inflection.
According to the author’s note at the end, the book was actually inspired by a New Orleans chocolate store, Blue Frog Chocolates. The author and illustrator are from New Orleans and nearby Baton Rouge.
The story is definitely meant to be read aloud. It works well as a read aloud. I didn’t enjoy my silent reading all that much but when I went back and read it out loud, I thought it was great fun. I do love how many Spanish words and short phrases are mixed in with the mostly English language story, in such a way that their meaning is well understood.
I’m not sure why I didn’t love this one. It didn’t quite thrill me. I did enjoy it though, and I think kids who love folktales, myths and legends, and definitely chocolate, are likely to enjoy the book.
Awhile back, I read three picture books with the Pied Piper story and have another on my to-read shelf that I’ve been unable to obtain. I happened to Awhile back, I read three picture books with the Pied Piper story and have another on my to-read shelf that I’ve been unable to obtain. I happened to see this book on the featured shelf at my branch library and grabbed it, not knowing what to expect, except that the cover appealed to me. The Pied Piper fable had a huge emotional impact on me when I was a child, and I really like the story.
This is a very text heavy picture book, so I’d say it’s for independent readers or reading aloud to school aged children, and possibly not in one sitting, although if time allows, reading the story all at once is the way to go.
This version of the story is told first person from the point of view of the young lame boy. I love his first impression of the Pied Piper as “wonderfully weird.”
So, I can’t give this book less than 4 stars. The pictures are remarkably good, I think. They’re intricately detailed and colorful and beautiful. They’re really special.
The story? Well, this one is different from any other Pied Piper tale I’ve ever read. It starts off darker than most versions, but ends up happier than any other version I’ve read. (view spoiler)[ The children return home unharmed. (hide spoiler)] This telling has a definite additional moral too; it’s incredibly message heavy, even as compared to the original. Somehow, I didn’t mind that because I loved the message(s), and the characters, but its deviation from the standard bothered me somewhat, so I deducted a half star or so. As a child, I’m sure I’d have considerably preferred this version to any of the others, and definitely to the one I had read to me when I was young....more