This review pertains to the audio version however, I have read the print version as well. Both receive 5 stars!
I first read Graceling in March 2009 aThis review pertains to the audio version however, I have read the print version as well. Both receive 5 stars!
I first read Graceling in March 2009 and I loved it. I read it around the same time I read The Hunger Games, which I also loved, and felt that both these books portrayed strong, young adult protagonists.After reading a review of the audio version of Graceling and because June is Audiobook Month I thought I would give it a go.
The audio version is produced by Full Cast Audio and each character is representd by a differnt actor. This was a different experience for me. The only other audiobooks I've ever listened to were the Harry Potter books read by Jim Dale (who is AMAZINg and won all kinds of awards for his narration). He does all the voices for all the different characters, so to hear a book with a full cast was quite different.
The audio version of this book gave me quite a different experience than reading the text. One of the things I noticed was how much more attention I paid to the little details. Because the text is being "read" aloud or acted out, there is no temptation of skimming or glossing over any of the text. You hear everything well, unless your mind happens to wander!
I was concerned that perhaps the actors voices they chose to portray certain characters would not match my idea of what the characters should sound like. However, all the main characters had great voices that I found appropriate for each character. Especially Po's voice. Sigh.
The only thing I would comment on as far as the story goes, that I hadn't noticed when I read the printed text, was how anti-climatic the encounter with the villain of the story was. I didn't notice it when reading the story but when listening to it, our protagonists when through sooooo much to evade the villian and when they do encounter him the resolution seemed so rushed like....that's it? Really? I don't know why it stood out to me so much more on the audio than it did with the text.
That being said, the audio version really brings to life, literally, the amazing world and characters that Kristen Cashore has created. I enjoyed this audio book immensely and I intend to check out other Full Cast Audio productions.
I thought I should mention that AudioFile Magazine gave this audio book their Earphone Award which is given to: " truly exceptional presentations that excel in all the following criteria:Narrative voice and style, Vocal characterizations, Appropriateness for the audio format, and Enhancement of the text"...more
A good start to a promising new series. The chemistry between Lucy and Sean is sizzling. The secondary characters are interesting especially Lucy's twA good start to a promising new series. The chemistry between Lucy and Sean is sizzling. The secondary characters are interesting especially Lucy's two best friends. I'm looking forward to seeing how things pan out for Lucy and Sean. As well as wether Em and the detective get together. I'll be eagerly awaiting the second book Deeply, Desperately.
I received this ARC from Goodreads First Reads giveaway. ...more
**spoiler alert** I really enjoyed this book. I thought Meg and John had great chemistry. The only thing that bothered me about this book was that Joh**spoiler alert** I really enjoyed this book. I thought Meg and John had great chemistry. The only thing that bothered me about this book was that John was all about following rules and not doing anything illegal, yet he is 19 and Meg is 17 and they have sex. Technically....that's statuatroy rape. Even though it says in the book they're only a year and a half a part, John makes such a big deal that 19 is WAY different than 17. So it really irked me that after him making a Big Deal about being NINETEEN and being Mr. Law Abiding Citizen, that he would be sleeping with Meg before she was 18. That was the only thing that bothered me. It just didn't seem to jive with everything we know about John. Overall, I really enjoyed this book. I picked it up and didn't put it down until I'd finished it.
Edit: As a librarian I should have done some research. The consensual sex age laws in Alabama (where the book is set) are 16 and she's 17 so it's legit. ...more