That was a really good end to the trilogy. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I think this exceeded my expectations. I love Alina, and I love that AlinThat was a really good end to the trilogy. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I think this exceeded my expectations. I love Alina, and I love that Alina and Mal's relationship persisted (rocky as it may have been at times), and there weren't any annoying love triangles or anything of the sort - just a friend.
It was also great to see the petty rivalries vanish and make way for friendship and loyalty. It started already in book two, but I didn't dare hope it would turn out this way, so I'm glad it did. I also loved Nadia and Tamar (and am glad that some gay people exist in this series, even if it took until book three...). I may also have cried through the last hundred pages or so, because everything hurt, but in a really good way.
I liked this one better than the first. The plot was stronger, some really interesting things are happening with Alina and some really great new charaI liked this one better than the first. The plot was stronger, some really interesting things are happening with Alina and some really great new characters have been introduced. It continues to be unpredictable in the right places....more
Every time I remember that the eight book Simon Snow series does not exist in real life, I die a little inside. I don't want this book to be over. I wEvery time I remember that the eight book Simon Snow series does not exist in real life, I die a little inside. I don't want this book to be over. I want to know everything.
This book made me laugh and cry and smile like a deranged person, and I loved every minute of it....more
Interesting, enjoyable. I've always liked the name Alina. It was unpredictable in the right places, which was very nice. The world building so far isInteresting, enjoyable. I've always liked the name Alina. It was unpredictable in the right places, which was very nice. The world building so far is really cool and the plot is engaging enough to make me want to continue.
The book could've done without the petty rivalry and backstabbing among the women.
Honestly the only reason this doesn't get five stars is because the writing isn't the most amazing I've seen. It's not bad writing, it's just...fine. It does its job but not much more than that....more
I liked it a lot and I might even like it better than the others, but I'm not sure. A few things confused meSpoilers in the review, read at own risk.
I liked it a lot and I might even like it better than the others, but I'm not sure. A few things confused me because they weren't what I expected to happen, it wasn't streamlined or what would typically happen in this kind of story - like somehow I was expecting katniss to actually make it into snow's mansion and kill him, but instead we got four pages of her being injured and drugged and then maybe ten-fifteen pages of being off her rocker. Which I do like, I mean, if nothing else everything has been super realistic, but on the other hand I feel like katniss' agency keeps being removed from her, something I mentioned in my review of Catching Fire as well. She's spent so much of the book being a pawn and when not a pawn, being in hospital. When she shot coin I'm not even sure that was an independent thought because of her conversation with snow.
I guess I have mixed feelings.
I like katniss with all her flaws and imperfections and passions and whatever, but I feel like she is ultimately just treated like a child and a pawn and rarely gets to do anything independently. She was independent before the games, when she was hunting and doing things. I feel like her final independent act was to volunteer for the games and that everything that came after was a giant construct in which she was a mechanism, like a gear in a clock or something. Not a person who decides things for themselves. She's was constantly coached and guided and made do things, then she was manipulated to do things, then she was again coached and guided and made do things while sometimes also manipulated and try as I might, I can't think of anything she did because she decided it. Maybe when she lied about the assassination mission. Not when she shot coin. Not even when she shot the arena.
Idk it feels a bit like we were supposed to have this heroine do stuff and rebel and blah blah but we didn't really.
At least I get the feeling that the movies will make her more independent because he movies don't showcase her internal monologue so when she shot the arena in the movie, she appeared to do it because she figured something out of her own and she made a decision to bring it down, but in the books she didn't know what the fuck she was doing and what the consequences were going to be. So the movies will have to cut out all the times the books describe her not knowing what's going on, being indecisive, being - frankly - slow/stupid at times, and only show her actions which come across a lot more awesome when you remove that. I kept thinking that maybe the books would've been better not in first person POV for it.
Anyway. I liked the series a lot and the only real beef I have with it is katniss' lack of agency. And everybody dying. Everyone always dies. <.<...more
I feel like this one delivers on the promise of the first one. It is a little more slow going it feels like, but it's brilliantly done. I find it inteI feel like this one delivers on the promise of the first one. It is a little more slow going it feels like, but it's brilliantly done. I find it interesting that katniss isn't made out to be an either/or heroine - either rebellion or playing snow's fiddle - she does both. Her priority is to stay alive and keep her family alive, but she also wants to incite hope in the other districts, spark a rebellion. Not at first, mind. Katniss shows great character development from someone independent on people doing most of the thinking for her, to being someone who does a lot of their own thinking. My one issue is that I can't shake the distaste of katniss being used as piece in a game, literally by both the system and by the rebellion, so she comes across as having a lot less agency than she initially seems to have. Here's to hoping that in the next book she'll really come into her own instead of being the pawn of adult men around her. I'm looking at you, Haymitch.
A great read, one i enjoyed a lot. I only wish I hadn't seen the movie first, as it killed some of the suspense I'd otherwise have felt about some things. ...more
Not a great piece of literature and the prose is fairly plain. It's entertaining enough, however and Collins manages to build up a believable dystopiaNot a great piece of literature and the prose is fairly plain. It's entertaining enough, however and Collins manages to build up a believable dystopian world and interesting characters. I'm particularly fond of the role reversal of the heroine being the saviour and the guy being the damsel in distress; it's very refreshing. I do have a few minor nitpicking issues with the novel, which may in part be brought on by the fact I saw the movie first. I thought the movie was somewhat stale, whereas the book feels like the extended edition directors cut version of events, and I'd venture to say that the book on the whole is a lot darker and grittier in contrast to the movie which seems awfully polished in comparison. (This is where I'd make a comment about the movie actually serving as some kind of piece of meta reflecting back on the universe in the novel; surely the media coverage of the movie and the proposed love triangle in the movie (which doesn't exist in the book) is right in line with the Capitol's treatment of the actual Hunger Games. Morbid and fascinating. I'll stop here, though, as I'm simply too tired to expand upon that thought.)
Tl;dr: I enjoyed the book a lot and I'd recommend it for anyone looking for dystopian YA which is actually dark and gritty and also for people who aren't looking for romance per se. This is the kind of book I'd want my younger sisters to read, because really, I'm Katniss and I'd do anything to protect my sisters and they'd recognise that. How fortunate that I don't actually have to sign up for slaughter in order to do so....more
i want to give this four and a half stars, but because goodreads doesn't do half stars, it'll get away with five. this is a thoroughly enjoyable booki want to give this four and a half stars, but because goodreads doesn't do half stars, it'll get away with five. this is a thoroughly enjoyable book with well-cut characters and an intriguing world and storyline. i'm much too tired now to actually go into details of why i loved it so much, but towards the end i had to keep taking breaks just to prevent the story from being over. the reason why i want to take half a star away is that i have some issues with how the names, for people, cities, countries, etc., have been constructed. i realise we aren't all tolkien, but having clear references and influences from vastly different languages in the real world to show something of the same cut was a bit confusing, and one has to wonder whether the writers were just counting on no-one noticing the irregularity in their system. nevertheless i enjoyed playing 'spot the language' whenever something new popped up, so it wasn't all bad. another, also language related, reason why i want to take away half a star is because some words just seemed very out of place, such as 'gasoline' and 'cappucino' which seem to me to be very modern words and don't really fit into a semi-medieval fantasy world. minor details, though, and i'm sure there are explanations for them.
i don't want to end this review on a critical note, but it's often easier to pinpoint one's problems with something than the likes, so have a bulletpoint list of awesome to sleep on: - rook with his braids and blue streaks and foul mouth - relatedly, havemercy with her dry wit and equally as foul mouth - thremedon, for being probably one of the most confusing cities i've yet met in fiction, but simultaneously the most charming and beautiful - the strong bonds the characters form between themselves and the different ways in which they manifest - the fact my heart got torn out on several occasions - and just as many times, whooped of joy - the clever and vivid descriptions of both people, places and actions - there are more books in the series and i'm going to buy them all instantly so that i can stay in this universe with this characters for a little while longer...more