This was a fun novel. I really enjoyed the concept of telling the novelist's life story as well as their novel. I did find myself more interested in DThis was a fun novel. I really enjoyed the concept of telling the novelist's life story as well as their novel. I did find myself more interested in Darcy's life, but Afterworlds had a fantastic beginning and ending. I also really appreciated all of the minorities, we have prominent Indian and gay characters and that's awesome.
I did have a few issues with the overall writing though. After the really fantastic beginning, Afterworlds really lagged for me. I don't think the underworld was presented in a very interesting way and as I got further into Darcy's life I found it hard to figure out if the novel was pre or post edits. It felt like it was pre edits and I found myself wishing Nan's comments were incorporated. I honestly would have liked a little less "YA hotness" and a little more death cult/serial killer. (view spoiler)[ Although I suspect this novel is way self aware of real life YA paranormal romances and I think he purposefully used tropes of the genre to influence Darcy's story. But even if his intentions were to have commentary on current YA trends, I still wanted Afterworlds to be an interesting book in it's own right, and unfortunately that wasn't always the case. (hide spoiler)]
I thought both relationships to be very insta-love (though it was worse in the novel) and that made them very unbelievable. I really had issues believing Darcy's relationship because she didn't really have any inner turmoil over it but she'd never really thought about it either. Everyone in her life was totally ok with it too, and I wish there had been just a little more introspection and discussion. And Darcy never really had any major conflict with people in her life, she just stressed about writing. I really liked the writing world stuff, especially as someone who has followed the YA publishing world very closely for 4+ years, but I would have liked more general life growth as well.
Even though I had some issues with the execution, I loved the concept of Afterworlds and I'm really hoping we will get a sequel. I personally would love to read Pyromancer and I hope that happens.["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>...more
Ehhh, not too good. It was trying to be all deep and "what would you do if the world was about to end" but there was NO character growth. The most intEhhh, not too good. It was trying to be all deep and "what would you do if the world was about to end" but there was NO character growth. The most interesting of the 3 was probably Zan, but I would have loved to have had more time with her family. Really I would have loved to see the family dynamics of all of them. Sienna was boring and Caden was just uncomfortable.
If you want an emotional look at what would happen if an asteroid/planet was about to hit the earth I recommend Lars Von Trier's Melancholia. ...more
I enjoyed Fangirl a lot. I really related to Cath, especially in the beginning. I remember calling my mom the first week of college and crying about hI enjoyed Fangirl a lot. I really related to Cath, especially in the beginning. I remember calling my mom the first week of college and crying about how I wasn't making friends and that I felt left out and lonely. And, like Cath, that alone-ness was really self inflicted. I just wasn't giving people a chance.
I had the biggest problem with the ending which felt really rushed. I felt like a lot of things were glossed over or not fully addressed. Namely what happened with Cath and her mom's relationship as well as finishing up Carry On and the fiction writing assignment. Those were three huge parts of Cath's life and they didn't get any resolution.
Overall the writing and character are adorable, but it needed some plotting work.
Oh and did anyone else find Simon Snow WAY lamer than Harry Potter? Because I did....more