The idea of a historical setting within a historical setting is a unique one. The passion that Whitman has for both time period shows since tidbits of...moreThe idea of a historical setting within a historical setting is a unique one. The passion that Whitman has for both time period shows since tidbits of research is occasionally inserted.
The book had quite a bit of elements: fantasy, a dash of science fiction, adventure, and romance. However, I felt that some points in the story dragged on for a bit, especially parts where Addy/Matilda learns hawking. I understand Whitman loves the subject, and that the romance between the two love interests needed to be built, but there was almost nothing else driving the plot forward.
Lastly, I felt the main character, though showing tremendous growth, was a bit flat. She was rarely witty and her thoughts and dialogue only moved the plot forward instead of helping to shape her character. A big plus though was that Addy/Matilda was a very likable and relatable character.(less)
The book was a smooth and easy read and was through with it fairly quickly. Gruen is very descriptive and uses great imagery, one almost feels as if t...moreThe book was a smooth and easy read and was through with it fairly quickly. Gruen is very descriptive and uses great imagery, one almost feels as if they are right there in the circus acts.
In fact, imagery is so good that certain explicit moments, which seem to barely drive the plot, should not be read by minors.
Characterization is good and none of the characters fall flat. Even the animals have their own unique personalities.
The only downside was that the storyline did not have much going for it. The majority of the book was circus act after circus act, though the ninety year old Jacob was a nice addition/subplot. (less)
Yes, the Hunger Games was a pretty adventurous book, but I felt that the love triangle was made too dramatic and overly complicated and that Katniss w...moreYes, the Hunger Games was a pretty adventurous book, but I felt that the love triangle was made too dramatic and overly complicated and that Katniss was not as likeable a character as she could've been. The plot was also a bit simplistic.
BUT, Catching Fire, is different altogether. There were so many twists and more layers to the story and additional subplots that my entire view of the series changed for the better. Not only (warning spoilers!) is there another hunger games, but the beginnings of a revolution as well! Katniss, and Prim, and Gale and Peeta all our other favorite characters gain more depth and grow.
Overall, the second book is that rare find that actually outdoes the first instead of merely milking the first story for all it's worth.(less)
Loading...
