I remember starting this in high school, when I'd gone through all of Jane Austen's novels one after the other, but I came up to Letter 4 and just cou...moreI remember starting this in high school, when I'd gone through all of Jane Austen's novels one after the other, but I came up to Letter 4 and just couldn't get into it.
Now I wonder at my stupidity in quitting. I gave Lady Susan another go and got so much into it I had to force myself to put it down and go to sleep because I had classes early the next day. I've kind of succumbed to a cold and curling up with hot tea, a blanket and Jane Austen was like chocolate and homecoming for the soul, all rolled up into one snuggly package.
The story pulled at me, made me indignant and involved in the fate of Frederica and Reginald and all the others. Lady Susan is a creation I know not how to describe and I wonder at the abilities of a woman so young and so limited by the times as Jane Austen was to have created her; even more - to have represented her so well through a sequence of letters, and not straight storytelling.
As always, this story stands as proof of how much the world lost by being early deprived of such a wonderful mind as that of Jane Austen.(less)
I believed the story. It read as a good biography might. I believed the characters. The voice. The notions. I didn't think 'fiction'...more I believed it.
I believed the story. It read as a good biography might. I believed the characters. The voice. The notions. I didn't think 'fiction' once. I was pulled in and submerged.
All this sounds pompous. Yep, to me, too. But John Green has written an honest story. He works out mortality depths through the 'simple' life of a sick sixteen-year-old girl. He creates love and relationships that are unbelievably non-fictional.
It is a simple YA story that's not simple at all.
I don't think I could write anything that would live up to what I feel reading this book. It made me feel. Made me think. And it made me aware of every breath I took. It makes the reader notice the universe, both on the inside and out.
This reads so much like one of those cheezy, blown-out wall posts Hazel and I both hate, but it's what I truly believe. And while I revel in reading a plot that just makes me live an interesting life, and mostly rate books on how much I'd enjoyed and believed them, I seem to have focused on the meaning behind the plot this time round. On Hazel and Gus and Isaac's thoughts and revelations about life. And I loved that even more.
So I'd say read this book eleven years in the making - however briefly, it will touch you.(less)
This... was supposed to be devoured, enjoyed, savoured and cherished into re-read territory. What the Hell went wrong?!
I bought Defiance over a year a...moreThis... was supposed to be devoured, enjoyed, savoured and cherished into re-read territory. What the Hell went wrong?!
I bought Defiance over a year ago and I remember being thrilled to have it on paper. I mean, look at that cover. And the description... I just KNEW I'd love it.
A friend of mine told me there are lots of reviews out there saying it's a letdown. I got fearful, and as always when I have the feeling something would disappoint - I procrastinated. And then, one night, I had time, it was raining and I was cuddled in my bed craving the good old paper read and so I reached for this.
I swear, for the first 50 or so pages I must've looked just like that. I kept... waiting for something to REALLY happen. Not that there wasn't any plot development - quite the opposite, I think it was supposed to be a sudden and shocking intro into a story, the catalyst event that would set it all off having taken place before the first words even... But I just didn't feel it.
Then, when we picked up speed, danger and action and death was everywhere, and I was supposed to be on the edge of my seat and all.
Instead, I set the book aside. Months passed, and I literally had to have five hours on a train with it to delve back into the story. Before that, I'd come home each night, see it through the layer of dust sitting lonely on my nightstand, the cover mocking me and chiding me.
Then I knew - despite every hope I had, despite it possessing the recipe for a great read, Defiance had turned into one of those books - you know, the ones that get stuck on your Currently-Reading shelf for months even as dozens of others go up to join them and move to Read. I was so pissed off by this that finally, several days ago I set my foot down and decided I was finishing it.
I'm being harsh, and it's time I justify my opinion. Why did a dystopian fantasy, a book that had both the well-loved and fresh element in it, that had a kick-ass heroine and an amazingly sweet, amazingly smart hero, that had both a black villain and a grey one, a dragon-like monster and mysterious devices - why did it not catch me up? Why wasn't all the fighting, inventing, travelling, and standing up for the right and wrong reasons not enough? It was supposed to be...
But I found Rachel - our 'tough-as-nails' heroine, more annoying than anything. "Get on with it", I'd think more often than not. She was supposed to be a warrior with a hardened but true heart. I found her petty, often implausibly rash considering her supposed 'toughness', and thinking and doing stupid things. Then there was Logan, and he wasn't as annoying, but he had his moments, too, especially in the beginning. There were things that he should have easily figured out later on, and instead he made what I call 'a great show' of stumbling through the logic to the obvious answer. Nice, smart guy. Though the changing POVs between the two was a good idea, often half the chapter would stress the same thing, the two characters wondering 'why, oh, why' or thinking 'I'm not worthy' on and on. I agree, inner conflict is the spice all great leads need, but not spanning half the story and having the substance of a broken-into-repeat record. Add to that the predictability of some of the supposedly unpredictable twists in the plot, and I say 'You're done'.
There were countless other things that subtly played on my patience and destroyed my enjoyment of what surely is a great, fresh twist of dystopian and fantasy. And while the plot stared me in the face with its action and romance and intrigue, and asked me 'Why?! Why don't you love me?' I could only sigh and shrug.
I have to give credit where it's due, too. What I did like about the story were some of the details - author C.J. Redwine has done her research on fighting techniques, survival and orientation, on tech construction and bombs. There was plenty of action which was very well executed. Also, she created Melkin - a grey villain, who did the wrong things for the right reasons, and then even didn't commit his ultimate task, did not turn into a killer and kept true to his purpose. I very much believed in the city-state's inner lifestyle - the Claiming, the social hierarchy, and so on. It was so medieval, and that's what answered to the promise on the back cover summary.
I feel as if this book shouldn't be placed with my other three-stars, but I can't do anything else, considering how much time it took me to pick it up, to read it, and how I didn't fall even in like with it, which is such a pity.
Maybe Defiance is just not my cup of tea. Maybe it will enamour most other readers - it has potential for that. I just felt no chemistry going on between the two of us. So, despite my lengthy, non-typical-for-me ranting, I'd say give it a go - it might be the adventure you'd love and want to read.
This being the thirteenth book of an amazing series, I'm having trouble thinking up new ways to praise every next one, no matter how very different th...moreThis being the thirteenth book of an amazing series, I'm having trouble thinking up new ways to praise every next one, no matter how very different they are all from one another. (I can't imagine writing a review when I reach book 30-something)
This one is sort of a lucky read for me, because I was gone for two weeks and out of the several books from the series I saw in one bookstore, this was one. Being the one I've reached I couldn't believe my luck and bought the paperback.
And it was an engrossing read, as always. I loved the concepts of the crime and was really driven to shuddering at the murderer's reasoning. This is not the most psyche case Eve's gone through, but it was a ton of shattered innocence without reason.
McNab and Peabody fans will enjoy this, as will those who liked Doctor Louise. And Roarke&Eve-shippers will love it. Featured in this one is also Eve catching a cold, Whitney going in the field and Trina doing a once-over on an unwilling undercover cop XD