I really like Isobel's sarcastic voice and the story has potential, but I don't think it's going to live up to it. After one day of living together sh...moreI really like Isobel's sarcastic voice and the story has potential, but I don't think it's going to live up to it. After one day of living together she's suddenly in love with her new step-brother, who's supposed to be off-limits. She keeps repeating that mantra, but she obviously doesn't mean it. And I'm not up for another round of new girl vs. the rest of the school. I thought this was supposed to be a ghost story. Putting it down at page 61. (less)
I'm a big Edgar Allen Poe fan, and The Masque of the Red Death has always captivated me, and this dystopian young adult version with a pinch of steamp...moreI'm a big Edgar Allen Poe fan, and The Masque of the Red Death has always captivated me, and this dystopian young adult version with a pinch of steampunk went on my wishlist the moment I saw it was coming out. It did not disappoint! The first theme of Poe's masterpiece is evident right away. Araby Worth lives in a city decimated by plague. A plague that still exists and kills more people every day. The remnants of society have been forced under the control of the megalomaniac Prince Prospero. The poor people eke out an existence in the rubble that remains of the city, bound in on all sides by man-eating gator-filled swamps and the sea, while the Prince and his courtiers host grand balls and lavish entertainments in his isolated castle.
But Araby is one of the lucky ones. She's wealthy, and therefore able to afford one of the masks that guarantees she won't get the plague. She lives in an affluent neighborhood, guarded against plague carriers. Her father, the scientist who invented the plague mask, is one of the most important men in Prince Prospero's kingdom, and as such is afforded bodyguards and luxuries other people can only dream of. But he's under a lot of pressure from the Prince, and spends most of his time locked away in his laboratory. Araby can't bear to be stuck at home with her mother, who wants to pretend that she didn't disappear from their lives when Araby and her father needed her most, while they were grieving the death of her brother, Finn. Araby is lonely. And borderline suicidal. She's desperate to be rid of the guilt and grief she suffers over her brother's death, yet she can't even begin to let go of it. She spends her evenings donning her mask, dressing up in corseted gowns, and gliding through the dark rooms of the Debauchery Club in a drug-induced haze.
"What do you want?" he asks in an amused voice. "Oblivion." It is what I am always looking for. "What's a pretty girl like you trying to forget?" A pretty girl like me with my clean fingernails and my unblemished bill of health. He doesn't know anything about me.
The one bright spot in her existence is Will, the quiet and serious bouncer at Debauchery, and the five-minutes she gets to spend with him each time he tests her to make sure she's plague-free before letting her into the club. When Araby wakes up one morning at Will's house after a night she can't remember, she begins a friendship that teaches her how to open her heart, and shows her the reality of life for the less fortunate, and the restlessness that's brewing in the city. Araby also meets Elliott at Debauchery. If Will is safe and solid, Elliott is all that is dangerous, and though she feels she ought to stay away from him, when he asks her to pull off a task central to his underground rebellion against his twisted uncle, Prince Prospero, Araby can't refuse. She soon finds herself caught in the middle of a war brewing between science and religion that will test her in ways she never imagined, and she finds her allegiances questioned, her family pulled apart, and her heart torn between Will and Elliott.
I thought this was a great read. Could not put it down. Very well-written, great characterizations, and a plot that kept me guessing till the very last page. The only thing that bothered me as I was reading was Araby's persistence in clinging to the guilt she carried over the death of her brother. You know, you've seen the storyline before: character has survivor's guilt and denies herself happiness, then character's love interest comes along and helps her let it go, so I was thinking Araby's story would run along the same lines, and it seemed to be headed in that direction when suddenly--Oh, snap! Wait a minute, maybe she has serious cause to feel so guilty...
Take that revelation, along with two huge game-changing plot twists that caught me completely off-guard, a terrific love triangle that had me begging for more, the originality of the story and the quality of the writing, and add it all up for one of my favorite YA reads of the year. I'm anxiously awaiting the sequel to see how Poe's story continues to play out in the eerie and startling world Ms. Griffin has created.(less)
3.5 Stars. Well-written, creepy, and wonderfully atmospheric with a great cast of intriguing characters, a mystery that kept me guessing, a couple of...more3.5 Stars. Well-written, creepy, and wonderfully atmospheric with a great cast of intriguing characters, a mystery that kept me guessing, a couple of good "WTF" moments, and a subtle yet powerful love story. I couldn't put it down. But the ending, though unpredictable and poignant, left me feeling dissatisfied and empty. Kind of tarnished what had been a really good read.(less)