First Sentence: Teddy, you would have been proud of me.
Somewhat agoraphobic Em Moore was part of a writing team focused on the biographies of the famo...moreFirst Sentence: Teddy, you would have been proud of me.
Somewhat agoraphobic Em Moore was part of a writing team focused on the biographies of the famous. Now that her partner, Teddy, is dead from a single-person automobile crash, it is up to Em to finish the book on film director Garrett Malcolm. It takes all her resolve, but Em travels to Cape Cod and finds Malcolm is more than just a story; he’s a very appealing man, with secrets. Em tries to learn more about his late wife and about his connection to alcoholic actor Brooklyn Pierce. In the meantime, Detective Snow isn’t ready to sign off on Teddy’s death as accidental.
One of the most important elements of a story is the character. Are they interesting? Can you empathize with them. In the case of Em, the answer to the first is “yes”. However, for me, the answer to the second is “no”, which is a shame. It’s not necessary to particularly like a character, which is a good thing in this case. Although the descriptions of her panic attacks and insecurities were compelling but they weren’t enough to keep her interesting and, after a time, became quite tiring.
Perhaps it was partly due to the story being told in first person with very long passages of narrative and very little dialogue that caused the story to feel very, very slow. What’s worse is that most of what dialogue there is, is internal and directed toward the dead Teddy. Garrett was the most interesting character, exemplifying all the ego, and fickleness ascribed to that persona, correctly or not. Unfortunately, of Detective Snow, we see almost nothing.
The setting is wonderful, and there were good description and pieces of historical information. However, I suspect unless you know the area, details of driving Route 2 to Storrow Drive or around Fresh Pond Circle wouldn’t mean much to most readers unless they had a map. Descriptions should allow the reader to see, hear, feel and smell a location. There was sadly little of that.
“The Perfect Ghost” isn’t without merit. It did keep me interested enough to read through to the end without putting it aside. For me, the “surprise” ending wasn’t particularly surprising, but it was nice to have my suspicion confirmed. Ms. Barnes is a good writer, her early Michael Sprague and Carlotta Carlyle books are proof of that, and it is nice to see her back. I am very interested to see what she’ll write next.
THE PERFECT GHOST (Novel/Mys-Em Moore-Cape Cod, MA-Contemp) – Okay Barnes, Linda – Standalone Minotaur Books, 2013
First Sentence: On an early morning in mid-August, EPA Special Agents Tim Singewald and Lenox Baker left the Region 8 Environmental Protection Agency...moreFirst Sentence: On an early morning in mid-August, EPA Special Agents Tim Singewald and Lenox Baker left the Region 8 Environmental Protection Agency building at 1595 Wynkoop Street in downtown Denver in a Chevrolet Malibu SA hybrid sedan they’d checked out from the motor pool.
When Joe finds a cut fence and his neighbor, Butch, on Wilderness land, he doesn’t think too much about it. However, when the EPA and Feds come in and insist on taking over an investigation of two murdered EPA agents found on the neighbor’s land, Joe seriously questions their motives and methods. In order to keep things as controlled as possible, he agrees to lead the agents into the mountains to track Butch down.
Boy, can this man write!! The story is completely engrossing; all the more so as the premise is taken from a true story. If anything, I can’t quite understand why he is not as popular and widely read as other, similar authors. It’s certainly not for lack of storytelling. Perhaps it is because he calls out the wrong-doing of some who work for public agencies and misuse their positions. I appreciate it, as it is one way to keep such agencies in check.
Box’s characters rank among the best. Joe is a man of strong morality and integrity, but knows there are times when justice must prevail over the letter of the law. He’s also not perfect, which makes him even better. His marriage has gone through rough patches, but they’re stronger for it. His daughters are growing up and are written very realistically for their ages. I like that Nate, a favorite character of the series’ fans, makes an appearance, albeit a small one. For those who’ve not yet read the series, there is enough information to jump in and not feel lost. However, do yourselves a favor—start at the beginning and catch up. It’s well worth the reading.
There is incredible sense of place. The tension and suspense are palpable. His ability to convey emotion is tangible. You feel Joe’s anger, fear, jubilation and sorrow.
The sign of a really good book is when you had intended to turn the light out and 10 p.m., but find yourself still reading until 2 a.m. in order to finish, and the ending leaves you a bit stunned. “Breaking Point” is that good.
BREAKING POINT (Lic Invest-Joe Pickett-Wyoming-Contemp)-Ex Box, C.J. – 13th in series Putnam, 2013 (less)
First Sentence: Blood dripped from the neck of the severed head and fell in a drizzle of red raindrops, clotting into a ruby pool upon the black and w...moreFirst Sentence: Blood dripped from the neck of the severed head and fell in a drizzle of red raindrops, clotting into a ruby pool upon the black and white tiles.
Pre-teen Flavia de Luce is excited about the opening of the 500-year-old tomb of Saint Tancred and is determined to witness the event. However, the first body uncovered, is that of Mr. Collicutt, the church organist—dead, wearing a gas mask. With her skill at chemistry, detection and a little help, Flavia has yet another murder to solve.
From the beginning, it is clear that Flavia is a delightful, unusual protagonist. She is 14 and wonderfully irreverent. When discussing how to get a bat out of one of the church organ’s pipes, her suggestion is for her sister to “…play Bach’s Toccata and Fugue in D Minor? Full throttle. That out to fix the little sod.” One cannot help but love her. She is an outsider in her own family. She is brilliant, yet has her insecurities. Her sisters have told her she’s adopted so she collects samples of everyone’s blood to test for matching. Her best friends are Gladys, her bicycle which she anthropomorphizes; and Dogger, the shell-shocked soldier who was with her father during WWII and now works for the family. There is such a wonderful bond between Dogger and Flavia. She is daring, but not fearless.
It cannot be overlooked that an older man has created such a vibrant, and realistic, young character. In an interview, he talks about how children of that age are undervalued and too much overlooked yet it’s a wonderful age as they are just on the cusp of adulthood. The story is told in first person and Bradley has such a wonderful voice…”Whenever I’m a little blue I think about cyanide, whose color so perfectly reflects my mood.”
The story is very much character-driven. The series started when Flavia was 11 years old; she is now 14 and we are starting to see her mature. However, those who come into the series late needn’t worry. Bradley provides sufficient back story for each of the characters for new readers to know who they are and the relationships between. He also introduces a fascinating new character in the shape of a flora archeologist with a Rolls Royce named Nancy.
Bradley has a wonderful eye for detail and period. He provides us with a real sense of post-war England, still in the stages of uncertainty about the future. He is also able to make chemistry fascinating.
Although character drives the story, the plot doesn’t at all suffer for it. We are taken down curious and shadowy paths. We, mistakenly, think we know where we are going, and we’re wrong. We’re given a delightful dessert filled with fascinating tidbits of information, suspense, resolution and a whopping cliffhanger--but not in a bad way--iced with humor and emotion.
“Speaking form Among the Bones” lags just a touch in the middle, but finishes with a roar. It is a wonderful book and now ranks among my favorites of the series.
SPEAKING FROM AMONG THE BONES (Ama Sleuth-Flavia de Luce-England-1950s) – VG+ Bradley, Alan – 5th in series Delacorte Press, 2013
First Sentence: It was March, well past midnight, and it was cold.
Free-lance investigator Dek Elstrom is still trying to fight his local city hall to...moreFirst Sentence: It was March, well past midnight, and it was cold.
Free-lance investigator Dek Elstrom is still trying to fight his local city hall to regain zoning rights to the tower—no castle, just a tower—in which he lives, but strange things start occurring. A large hole is dug for a new McMansion in a block of bungalows, a phone call from someone thought to be dead, and Dek’s best friend and loved ones suddenly disappearing. Dek is on the trail of answers and trying to stay alive. I have two admissions from the very start; 1) I have loved this series but, 2) this is not my favorite book of the series.
Among Frederickson’s strengths is his ability to create a vivid atmosphere from the very beginning. He has a great eye for detail and conveys it in a way that you are part of the scene. You feel the cold, you experience the turbulence of the boat ride and the driving rain; the tension becomes real and the atmosphere, threatening.
He also has an excellent ear for dialogue, whether in the narrative or between characters. It’s clear, it has the right edge to it and just enough dry humor.
The main characters are impossible to resist; Dek, who is trying hard to rebuild his life and his wonderful brilliant, completely devoid of any fashion-sense friend Leo are interesting and people about whom you want to know more. A few characters, however, feel as though they have become a bit of a joke that has gone on too long.
The weakest element, I felt, was actually the plot. It seemed we didn’t really know what was going on until nearly half-way through the story. Sometimes, this can work. In this case, it was only the appeal of Leo and an act of faith that draws you on.
“The Dead Caller From Chicago” is still a good read. If anything, I feel my frustration is in feeling that Mr. Frederickson is capable of doing so much more. I’m waiting…..
THE DEAD CALLER FROM CHICAGO (Myst-Dek Elstrom-Chicago-Contemp) – Good Frederickson, Jack – 4th in series Minotaur Books, 2013 (less)
Forensic archeologist Ruth Galloway is shocked to learn that a friend has died in a house fire. Thing ta...moreFirst Sentence: At first he isn’t even scared.
Forensic archeologist Ruth Galloway is shocked to learn that a friend has died in a house fire. Thing take on an eerie quality when she receives a letter from him, written days before he died. He talks about an historic archeological discovery but also that he’s afraid. With her daughter Katy and Druid friend Cathbad, Kate heads north to Lancashire. What she doesn’t plan on is that DCI Nelson, father to Katy, will also be there, his former hometown, with his wife and family.
If a completely compelling, albeit somewhat horrific, hook is what captures your attention; you can’t do better than here. Griffiths immediately draws you into the story and makes you want to keep reading by making each chapter more intriguing than the last. This is not a book you’ll put down.
Griffiths is very good at creating complicated relationships wherein you have sympathy for each of the characters involved. That takes real skill, and she has it. She also introduces characters very well and If you’ve read previous books, you become reacquainted; if you’re new to the series, you never feel lost wondering who they are and how they fit together. Sadly, not all authors are good at this. There are the favorites, of course; Ruth and Cathbad in particular. Children can be awkward, yet Katy is neither precocious nor annoying, but very realistic. One of the most appealing new characters is Sandy, Nelson’s friend and fellow DCI.
The atmosphere and tension created are excellent. The history related to the story is fascinating. I’ve always been a fan of Griffiths’ ear for dialogue and her occasional subtle humor.
“A Dying Fall” is a book which broad appeal as it works on so many levels. It may just be my favorite or second favorite, book in this series so far. What most pleases me is to know that there will be more books coming.
A DYING FALL (Trad. Myst-Ruth Galloway-England-Contemp) – VG+ Griffiths, Elly – 5th in series Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2013 (less)
First Sentence: It was one of those late summer days that sometimes showed up in early October after a killing front—warm, dry, and hazy; Indian summe...moreFirst Sentence: It was one of those late summer days that sometimes showed up in early October after a killing front—warm, dry, and hazy; Indian summer.
Sheriff Walt Longmire, best friend Henry Standing Bear, and undersheriff Victoria Moretti are returning from a day of fishing. A distressed call from park ranger Chuck Coon leads them to find Coon and a tourist trapped on top of a campground Porta Potty, having been driven there by a large black bear sow and her cubs. Inside, also trapped, is a special creature who may be a special Messenger for Walt.
It takes a special author whose short stories equal the quality of his full-length novels. Johnson is just such an author. All of the elements of an excellent book are here. He draws you in from the first sentence with evocative descriptions and establishes a sense of place that makes you part of the story.
Johnson has created such wonderful characters in Walt, Henry and Victoria (Vic). Even in this short-story format and had you not read a previous book, they are fully developed; you know who they are and their relationships to one another. Each character’s personality, as well as the affection between them, is very evident.
One of Johnson’s greatest strengths is dialogue. The spoken dialogue is crisp, very natural, and further establishes each character. The internal narrative places us in Walt’s head and allows us to see the story from his perspective. There is excellent balance between the narrative and the dialogue. Both also allow us to enjoy Johnson’s humor.
Learning about the beliefs of the Cheyenne is fascinating. Even more, it takes what could have been a simple and delightful story, and gives it depth and import on Walt’s life. It gives us, the reader, a bit of education, and greater respect and sense of wonder for one of nature’s glorious creatures.
“Messenger” is a wonderfully original story with humor, mysticism and friendship. While you may wish it had been longer, you’ll also appreciate that it is perfect, just as it is.
Two significant benefits of buying this e-book are that a portion of the proceeds goes to the Teton Raptor Center in Jackson, Wyoming, and that it also includes the first chapter of Johnson’s next book, “A Serpent’s Tooth”.
MESSENGER (Pol Proc-Walt Longmire-Wyoming-Contemp) – Ex Johnson, Craig – Short Story – ebook Viking, 2013
First Sentence: The year People magazine selected George Clooney as its Sexiest Man in the World, women in that part of the world known as St. Louis s...moreFirst Sentence: The year People magazine selected George Clooney as its Sexiest Man in the World, women in that part of the world known as St. Louis shook their heads.
Attorney Rachel Gold is in the midst of a case representing residents of a community in threat of losing their homes to a wealthy and powerful developer. However, a contractor, Nick Moran, who had done beautiful work on Rachel’s home has been found dead in a scene suggesting gay sex and a heroin overdose. Nick’s sister doesn’t believe any of it and asks Rachel to investigate. The further Rachel investigates the more complicated and intertwined the two cases become.
There seems to be some confusion as to the title of this book. The e-galley I received from NetGalley lists it as "Zero Sum". However, the galley itself shows it as "The Flinch Factor."
No matter the title, Mr. Kahn has made me a very happy reader by bringing back Rachel Gold and her friends. Better still is the fact that new readers, those who have no idea that this last book in this very good series came out 11 years ago, will have no problem making this their first Rachel Gold read.
The characters are wonderful, smart, interesting, and just quirky enough to completely enthrall the reader. Rachel, a widow with a son and two step-daughters, is smart and capable but has her mom there to help her. Benny, long time friend and brilliant professor of law with no fashion sense, is the friend everyone would like to have. Add to the cast Jacqui Brand, partner in Rachel’s law firm, and Detective Tomaso, and these are characters you feel you could know and about whom you would care. Even the unique, and often troublesome, Judge Howard Flinch, becomes someone you rather hope to see again.
Kahn’s voice is a pleasure to read. I hate to say that men don’t often write female protagonists well. Kahn does. His dialogue is quick, sharp, natural and often very funny. There are times you do laugh out loud. At one point, Rachel is thinking about her widowed mother and the number of suitors she could have, were she so inclined. “She has gone on record that the developer of Viagra deserves a special place in Hell. I try my best not to think about the implications of that statement.”
The plot has very good twists. The legal aspects of the cases are clearly explained and never overwhelm the reader. The courtroom scenes were very well done and very visual. The pacing of the story has realistic ebb and flow. I even forgive the one portent which could have been left out.
“The Flinch Factor” is a true legal mystery and a very good read.
THE FLINCH FACTOR (Leg. Mys-Rachel Gold-St. Louis, MO-Contemp)-VG Kahn, Michael A. – 9th in series Poisoned Pen Press, 2013 (less)
Investigators Sam Blackman and Nakayla Robertson head out looking for mushrooms on the site of an historic, f...moreFirst Sentence: “So, where are we going?”
Investigators Sam Blackman and Nakayla Robertson head out looking for mushrooms on the site of an historic, freed-slave commune called The Kingdom of the Happy Land. In addition to mushrooms, Sam also finds a body. Wedged inside a rotting log with a spent bullet, this was no natural death. When Marsha Montgomery asks the pair to investigate the 1967 theft of a rifle and photograph, taken on the same site, Sam becomes suspicious. His concerns are realized with Marsh’s elderly mother is arrested for the murder of Jimmy Lang, believed to be the corpse. The question is whether this is about race, or is it about greed?
De Castrique provides us with a very good, compelling first chapter that makes us want to read more. His voice is easy with natural dialogue, although the bantering and self-deprecating humor can become a bit heavy-handed.
One of his great strengths is mixing the factual with the fictional. Learning new things is always wonderful and theirs is so much to learn here, both about recent and distant historical figures, regional and American history, ballistics, and of working with vets at the VA hospital. All of this is seamlessly woven into the story giving it a richness and veracity which enhances the experience. There is even a delightful nod to author Lee Child and his Jack Reacher series of books.
Sam, Nakayla—is partner in the firm and in life—and attorney Hewitt Donaldson are very good characters. Even if this is your first experience with the series, you are provided enough background to know who they are and their relationships to one another. If anything, a bit of editing could be recommended as we are reminded way too many times of how Sam and Nakayla met. It’s a smallish criticism but it was an element of which I became very aware.
On the other hand, it’s nice when an author uses coincidence as a deliberate element of the plot structure, rather than the only way they can think to get to the next point. That’s good writing.
“A Murder in Passing” has a very good plot filled with twists, turns and an excellent surprise. I very much enjoy Mr. de Castrique’s writing, both in this series and in his Barry Clayton series.
A MURDER IN PASSING (Lic Invest-Sam Blackman/Nakayla Robertson-North Carolina-Contemp) – G+ de Castrique, Mark – 4th in series Poisoned Pen Press, 2013(less)
First Sentence: Some weird objects are handed in at Bath Police Stations.
Excellent hook. Love the characters, particularly his humor, bad puns and tha...moreFirst Sentence: Some weird objects are handed in at Bath Police Stations.
Excellent hook. Love the characters, particularly his humor, bad puns and that he sings Queen. Great dialogue..."Where did you find it.?" "At Hay-on-Wye." This was cause for a smile. "Sooner or later everything of no special distinction seems to end up there."
Excellent sense of place and fascinating information on some rather obscure history of Bath.
THE VAULT (Pol Proc-DS Peter Diamond-Bath, England-Contemp) - G+ Lovesey, Peter – 5th in series Soho, 1999 (less)
First Sentence: The last market day before Christmas in the small French town of St. Denis was unusually cold.
St. Denis police chief Bruno Courréges i...moreFirst Sentence: The last market day before Christmas in the small French town of St. Denis was unusually cold.
St. Denis police chief Bruno Courréges is multi-tasking, as usual. He’s organizing carolers, playing Father Christmas and preparing for a Christmas feast. In spite of the freezing weather, all is going well…until money raised for charity goes missing.
Lately, it hasn’t been easy finding a good Christmas story that is both enjoyable yet not too saccharine. Walker has done the trick.
Bruno is such a wonderful character. He is very much part of his village and a role model to its youth. He is strict when he needs to be, yet wise and a peacemaker when he can be.
The story is light—it is a holiday story, after all—but thoroughly enjoyable. It is also another example of an author using food to entice and delight us. I do want a Bruno cookbook.
If you’re looking for a heavy, serious police procedural; this is not it. However, if you’re in need of a delightful read and a quick visit to Provence, I highly recommend “Bruno and the Carol Singers”. If you’ve not yet read the “Bruno” series, I highly recommend that as well.
BRUNO AND THE CAROL SINGERS (Pol Proc-Bruno Courréges-France-Contemp) – VG Walker, Martin – eBook Novelette Knopf, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: Two villages, where two rivers meet.
The villages of Kushtaka and Kuskulana are the Hatfield’s and the McCoy’s of Alaska; the relations...moreFirst Sentence: Two villages, where two rivers meet.
The villages of Kushtaka and Kuskulana are the Hatfield’s and the McCoy’s of Alaska; the relationship between the two is uncomfortable, at best. The murder of a young man from Kushtaka risks more blood being shed and Alaska State Trooper Sergeant Jim Chopin isn’t having much luck getting people from either village to talk to him. A second death prompts Jim asking Kate to go undercover.
When an author is at their 20th book of a series, there is always the risk of that series becoming stale. With Dana Stabenow, there is never that worry.
The book opens with a look at the issues, and conflicts, of nature, man and wealth. The descriptions are evocative and visual, leaving you no question of the location. The characters are strong, well-written and very well defined. Kate is the woman most of us would like to be; independent, capable, self-sufficient yet still generous and caring. She could stride alone through the world, but chooses not to. I appreciated that we learn more about Jim in this book, and the horror of some of his past cases.
I always appreciate and enjoy Stabenow’s excellent dialogue and dry humor. The story started a bit slowly but, as with a dangerous rollercoaster, soon accelerated to a breathtaking ending. Although many people severely criticized the ending, even considering it a wall-banger, other than the shock of it, I wasn't bothered. I trust her as an author and, instead, it had the effect of leaving me demanding the next book--NOW!
“Bad Blood” is one of Ms. Stabenow’s best book in the series. I really can’t wait for the next.
BAD BLOOD (PI-Kate Shugak-Alaska-Contem) – VG+ Dana Stabenow – 20th in series Minotaur Books – 2013 (less)
First Sentence: The friendship between Yann Falquerho and Thierry Marchive had surprised everyone at the university.
The head of Aix University’s Theol...moreFirst Sentence: The friendship between Yann Falquerho and Thierry Marchive had surprised everyone at the university.
The head of Aix University’s Theology is expected to announce both the winner of the prestigious Dumas fellowship, and, with his retirement, the appointment of his successor—who will acquire his very luxurious apartment. Before any of this occurs, he is found having been murdered in his office. Police commissioner Bruno Paulik, his boss examining magistrate Judge Antoine Verlaque, and the judge’s lover, law professor Marine Bonnet, seek the killer
Although the author is British, her absolute love of all things French and Italian, shines through. Almost more than anything else, the book is a delight to read for its detailed descriptions of foods and wines, while art—I’d not known before of Gallés glass and ex-votos--, history—during the plague, the town fathers of Aix closed the city gates resulting in the plague passing without the loss of a single life in Aix--, literature—“What will survive of us is love.”--, and the French countryside receive their fair share of attention, as well.
Longworth more than brings the characters to life for us. We know their background—well, for most of them—their lives, their relationships and personal passions; Bruno’s love of opera and Verlaque’s cigars. She also presents one of the best descriptions I know of being in love with someone but being uncertain of their feelings in return.
The mystery is there; witnesses and suspects interviews, clues followed and investigation done. However, it does seem somewhat secondary to the abundance of characters and descriptions. Oddly, this is not a complaint.
“Murder in the Rue Dumas” is more on the cozy end of the genre, but what a delightful place it holds. I thoroughly enjoyed the book from its opening through its epilogue, which I very much appreciated. The character, their relationships and the author’s voice kept me interested and reading. I find I really do want to read the next book.
MURDER IN THE RUE DUMAS (Lic Inv-Magistrate Antoine Verlaque-Aix-en-Provence, France-Contemp) – G+ Longworth, M.L. Penguin Books, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: At 7:35 A.M. Ishigami left his apartment as he did every weekday morning.
A woman separated from her brutal husband. A neighbor devoted...moreFirst Sentence: At 7:35 A.M. Ishigami left his apartment as he did every weekday morning.
A woman separated from her brutal husband. A neighbor devoted to helping her. A policeman tasked with trying to solve a murder. A physicist asked to help his friend the policeman, and who knows the neighbor. These four elements combine into a game of cat and mouse.
My first thought was how much I wish they had included a map. My second thought was a wish for a cast of characters as I am not as familiar with Japanese names as some other cultures and, in the beginning, found it a bit difficult keeping track of who was whom. Both those thoughts quickly faded.
The story sets off with a very good beginning wherein we learn first of the characters, and then of the emotions and motives that drives them. All the characters, on both sides of the crime, draw you in. It’s fascinating as there is no real “bad” guy to the story.
That said, this is a story very much driven by the plot. And what a plot it is! There are surprises, twists and turns, and an intriguing game of cat-and-mouse. It is an intelligent plot, which even includes math and science. It is not all cerebral, as there is also some very good suspense. Most of all, there is an ending which is understandable yet emotionally raw and impactful.
“The Devotion of Suspect X” was a complete and wonderful surprise. It is a brilliantly structured story. It’s easy to see why Higashino is the most popular, best-selling mystery author in Japan. Hopefully, American readers will soon add him to their “must-read” lists as well.
THE DEVOTION OF SUSPECT X (Pol Proc-Det. Kusanagi/Dr. Yukawa-Japan-Contemp) - Ex Higashino, Keigo – Standalone Minotaur Books, 2005 (translated edition 2011) (less)
First Sentence: The past lingers all around us, a clear winter’s light, and a shroud.
Not only is academic and folklorist Fever Devlin still recovering...moreFirst Sentence: The past lingers all around us, a clear winter’s light, and a shroud.
Not only is academic and folklorist Fever Devlin still recovering for a coma after nearly dying, but his friends are concerned that he is crazy. This fear increases after Fever claims to have been visited by a woman claiming to be his wife and that he has a son. However, when there is no evidence of this woman having been there, Fever’s fiancée asks a friend, Dr. Nelson, to stay with him. No matter what they think, phantoms don’t use rifles.
From the very first chapter, DePoy draws you into the story and ensures the book won’t be closed until the last word is read. It’s always wise to set aside the time for a non-stop read with a Fever Devlin book, and this was no exception.
For those who’ve not read the previous books, DePoy provides very well-done, brief back-stories for the continuing characters. He also introduces fascinating new characters. There is a strong sense of place, excellent dialogue and delightfully wry humor. He also does surprise extremely well.
Fever is a wonderful and usual character, and I appreciate the acknowledgement that his life is far from that experienced by the average person. “Fever,” Skidmore began, “you’ve been back home for, what? Eight, nine years now? In that time you have found countless dead bodies, dozens of people have tried to kill you…. You’ve seen ghosts, witches, time travelers, racist murders, and an albino dwarf? So some wild boy shooting up your house a couple of days before Christmas? That’s just another ordinary day in your life. …” Even Fever admits “I am a deeply troubled person.” It’s that acknowledgement that makes the unbelievable, acceptable. Or, perhaps, Dr. Nelson is correct that he is a spook magnet.
I enjoyed Dr. Nelson coming up with all the psychological and para-psychological theories about Fever, and his very normal, rather irritated, frustrated dismissal of them; yet revealing an element of his own concern that she may not be wrong.
Please don’t dismiss this as a silly, paranormal mystery. What makes it, and the series work, is that the paranormal aspect is so wonderfully done. You don’t know whether events are real or not. The writing is also very intelligent. I love the inclusion of literary information, quotes and references. There are also mouth-watering references to feed which leave one hungry.
“December’s Thorn” is a wonderful read. Phillip DePoy is a treasure. May he continue this delightful, unique series for many years yet to come.
DECEMBER’S THORN (Ama Sleuth-Fever Develin-Georgia-Contemp)– VG+ DePoy, Phillip – 7th in series Minotaur Books, 2013 (less)
First Sentence: They kept it simple. They could cut off his right hand, or he could use it to learn how to fire the weapon they gave him.
PI Kate Shuga...moreFirst Sentence: They kept it simple. They could cut off his right hand, or he could use it to learn how to fire the weapon they gave him.
PI Kate Shugak is surprised to receive a call from State Trooper Liam Campbell. An even bigger surprise is being offered a job to investigate a murder; however, one of the possible suspects is Campbell’s wife. Traveling to Niniltana and working undercover doesn’t seem so bad, except someone is taking strong exception to her presence and making that clear in very physical ways. In spite of a handsome actor who is there, is soon becomes clear that the case of murder is only a small part of much bigger, uglier crimes.
As wonderful as are the characters of Kate and Mutt, it was a delight to have Liam Campbell and the cantankerous Moses, seer and master of tai-chi, back in the mix. There is no question but that Stabenow creates wonderful characters; good and bad.
Stabenow’s voice and humor bring humanity and balance to serious mysteries…”Kate marched them [the NNA board members] through old business like Alexander went through Asia…”. At the same time, this book did not, in any way, lack for suspense.
Dana Stabenow is an Alaskan who knows her state and its people. Her descriptions are powerful and create a very strong sense of place. Yet she also recognizes that life in Alaska is not for everyone…”Jim asked her [a perpetrator being extradited to another state] why she had confessed to charges that were five years old and three thousand miles away. “I’m tired of Alaskan winters.” She said.”. She also presents a very good look at the challenges, both in types of crimes and lack of manpower, policing Alaska.
One element which may bother some readers is that she addresses the issue of gun ownership and gun control. Some people might take exception to Kate’s views on guns, war, and those who fight. She does bring up as aspect of which I was unaware, yet is very disturbing.
“Restless in the Grave” is a very good book. It is well plotted. It follows both Kate and Chopper Jim’s cases, even though they are in different locations. One of Jim’s cases very much mirrors a major case currently in the news. It is suspenseful, yet with elements of humor, has great dialogue and excellent characters. For being a 19th book, Ms. Stabenow has definitely not lost her touch.
RESTLESS IN THE GRAVE (Lic Invest-Kate Shugak/Liam Campbell-Alaska-Contemp) – VG Stabenow, Dana – 19th in series Minotaur Books, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: I got a letter one day, a long letter that wasn’t signed.
Camille Warner is in publishing, pregnant, abandoned by her lover, and sortin...moreFirst Sentence: I got a letter one day, a long letter that wasn’t signed.
Camille Warner is in publishing, pregnant, abandoned by her lover, and sorting through condolences from her mother’s death. One letter, much thicker than the rest, stands out not only for its size, but its lack of either salutation or signature and seems to be part of a story. As more segments arrive, Camille is curious, thinking perhaps it’s an author looking to be published, then intrigued as the characters begin to be identified. As the story evolves, Camille realizes just how personal the story is.
In the beginning, it’s not easy to identify which narrator is speaking when. Usually, I find this highly annoying. I don’t, however, believe the story really would not have worked any other way. I also realized that, after only a few pages, I was so immersed in the story, I didn’t mind. In the beginning, there were a few portents—always a major flaw in my view—but even those, I forgive.
The author’s/character’s voice, with the help of her translator, immediately drew me in. Her writing is punctuated with small truths that are both illuminating and disturbing…”As the curtain fluttered closed I thought of how once the last survivor of a family is dead, there is no one left to receive letters of condolence.” and “It is not other people who inflict the worse disappointments, but the shock between reality and the extravagance of our imagination.”
I shan’t tell you any more about the characters beyond my summary above. Learning who they are, reading their stories as they unfold and learning how the relationships intertwine is all integral to the plot itself. It should not be spoiled.
The story is set in two time periods; the 1975 present and the years before WWII. I appreciated learning of the milestones in history leading up to the war and seeing the European—in this case French—perspective of events. In some ways, the notions as to how women conceive and remedies for infertility were more disturbing as they were more immediate to the story.
This is a story within a story, within a story, within a story. I was drawn in immediately and kept turning the pages to the very end. Whatever you do, DO NOT cheat and read the ending, particularly the poem, until you reach it in its proper time.
“The Confidant” is a very compelling book I do highly recommend reading.
THE CONFIDANT (Novel-Camille-France-Contemp/1940s) - Ex Gremillon, Helen – Alison Anderson, Translator - Standalone Penguin Books, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: It was a pleasant evening late August, one of the busiest times of year for the village of Swann’s Lake.
Swann’s Lake nightclub owner,...moreFirst Sentence: It was a pleasant evening late August, one of the busiest times of year for the village of Swann’s Lake.
Swann’s Lake nightclub owner, and ex-con, Robbie Peterson is found in his office with a six-inch nail driven into his head, and the local police requesting the assistance of Scotland Yard’s Chief Inspector Woodend and Sergeant Rutter. It is not a simple case but one that leads to other crimes hidden below the surface. A terrible event impacts Sergeant Rutter, but also reveals information relevant to the initial murder.
The opening chapter provides a very good setup for the investigation. We’re introduced to the main suspect characters and their relationships. Unfortunately, there is a portent in the very first paragraph which is completely unnecessary considering the very dramatic and compelling hook at the chapter end.
The characters of CI Charlie Woodend and Sgt. Bob Rutter are of my favorite type and reminiscent of the best traditional British police procedurals. These are not angst-ridden, alcoholic cops, but men with wives, children or a fiancée. They are mentor and pupil, who work together and support one another. Woodend is known as “Cloginn’ it Charlie” described by Rutter as “bloody brilliant and bloody impossible—often at the same time—and is the best bobby I’ve met,” Whereas Woodend refers to Rutter as “He’s a good lad”. Woodend’s wife, Joan, is a seasoned policeman’s wife, whereas Rutter’s fiancée is part Spanish. Her participation in an anti-Franco rally provides a dramatic subplot to the story.
The dialogue is so well done, you can hear it down to the accent. I do love the dry humor, particularly in the instances where Charlie mentors Rutter by asking Socratic questions along the way.
Spencer’s descriptions and voice create a strong sense of place. “The church loomed up ahead. It had been built early in the nineteenth century, the Chief Inspector guessed, before they had got the concept of the Gothic Revival quite right. Now it stuck out like a blot on the landscape—a small church trying to pretend it was a cathedral, a structure which attempted to soar and only succeed in being a dwarf standing on tiptoes.”
“Murder at Swann’s Lake” is not a cozy—she definitely doesn’t go for the saccharine--but a solid police procedural. There is very good final suspense and excellent plot twists on the resolution. It took me awhile, but I’ve very pleased to have discovered this series.
MURDER AT SWANN’S LAKE (Pol Proc-CI Woodend/Sgt Rutter-England-Cont) – VG Spencer, Sally – 2nd in series Severn House, 1999
First Sentence: I lifted my head when I heard her knocking.
Billy Webb is a young man, recently graduated from college, joins a dictionary publishing c...moreFirst Sentence: I lifted my head when I heard her knocking.
Billy Webb is a young man, recently graduated from college, joins a dictionary publishing company and begins work as a lexicographer on their annual update. His job is to research possible words which should be added. There he meets coworker Mona who keeps coming across slips of paper with words that seem to be bits of a story. The citation for each is a book entitled “The Broken Teaglass”, which doesn’t seem to exist, but sets the two on the hunt for the book, a possible crime and, possibly, a romance.
More of a literary novel, perhaps, than a mystery the book begins with an intriguing prologue followed by a first chapter that is a complete contrast.
Billy is young; something of which I had to keep reminding myself. He is 24 years old and seems immature at times. I do credit the author for, end the end, providing us with something of an explanation as to why he is, as he is. I did find the least appealing aspect of his character was the amount of alcohol he consumed, as well as his annoying habit of plying Mona with liquor. But again, he is young. Of the two characters, Mona was the better, stronger one. Mr. Samuelson, a retiree, was one of the best characters.
The most fascinating part of the story, for me, was learning how dictionaries are created; how words are included, updated, changed, etc. A dictionary is something on which I have always depended without every considering how or by whom. …”Oh, Billy,” she [Mona] said, opening her door,” Don’t hate words. Hate the people who misuse them.” I did appreciate that we slowly learn the quite interesting backstory on the characters.
“The Broken Teaglass” was an interesting story that kept me reading, even though I wasn’t always certain why. It was literate, funny at times, a bit slow at times, but also a bit poignant. In the end, nothing was really resolved, but isn’t that true of life. I wouldn’t define it as a “must read,” but I am very glad I read it.
THE BROKEN TEAGLASS (Mys-Billy Webb/Mona Minot-Massachusetts-Cont) – G+ Arsenault, Emily – 1st book / Standalone Delacourt Press, 2009 (less)
First Sentence: By fixing his curtain to one side with a clothes-peg, Lucio could better observe the new neighbour at his leisure
Insp. Adamsburg has b...moreFirst Sentence: By fixing his curtain to one side with a clothes-peg, Lucio could better observe the new neighbour at his leisure
Insp. Adamsburg has bought a new house which, according to a neighbor, is haunted. When two men are found with their throats cut, causing him to ask a favor from pathologist Ariane Lagarde, with whom he did not have a good working relationship in the past. Upon learning an elderly nurse, whom Adamsburg imprisoned as a serial killer, has escaped he starts to think the cases are connected.
Vargas has such a wonderful voice and way of bringing her characters to life, right from the beginning. Her natural dialogue (thanks, in part, to her excellent translator, Siân Reynolds) and wry humor “…I work in the Serious Crime Squad.” “I see,” said the old man after registering a slight shock. “My specialty was the bench.” He winked. “Not the Judge’s Bench, wooden benches. I used to sell them.”…enhance the delight of the reader.
Vargas’ characters are special and unique. Adamsburg, with his individual style of investigation, Young Lt. Veyrenc has a tendency to speak in 12-sylable lines and has a childhood enmity for Adamsburg; Commandant Danglad, Adamsburg’s right hand, who can’t stand unsolved questions; Lt. Retancourt, much valued by Adamsburg, can sleep anywhere and whose kidnapping leads to one of the most interesting hunts ever written; and all the other characters, no matter how minor. She even incorporated Mathias and a mention of Marc and Vandossler, characters from her wonderful book “The Three Evangelists”, into the story.
There are such wonderful descriptions that enhance the story and bring it, the locations and the characters to life. She delightfully anthropomorphizes the first day of Spring “…She’s touchy. If you forget her, she’s liable to go off and sulk.”…and provides a wonderful summary of the squad’s members through descriptions provided by Retancourt. There is a element of the paranormal to the story, yet ghosts are referred to in a manner that is casual and matter of fact. Yet, there is also a scene that is incredibly wonderful and moving.
Unique is such an overused word, yet it is the one that best applies to every aspect of Vargas’ writing. “This Night’s Foul Work” once again proves there is absolutely nothing ordinary or expected about a Vargas book including the excellent twists and a threads you don’t think fit but do…or don’t. There is no question that Ms. Vargas has become one of my favorite authors.
First Sentence: The woman in the condemned cell was unaware of any of the technical intricacies involved in her imminent execution.
Margaret Dobbs was...moreFirst Sentence: The woman in the condemned cell was unaware of any of the technical intricacies involved in her imminent execution.
Margaret Dobbs was tried and executed for murdering her husband. Although all the evidence pointed to her, she maintained her innocence until the end. Thirty years on, her daughter, a member of the Queen’s Council, wants her mother’s name cleared. A powerful politician, who was the original investigating officer, wants the verdict to stand. CI Charlie Woodend needs to find the truth.
The prologue, set in 1934, is a unique and compelling opening drawing you in from the very first page. It also provides the background as to the lasting impression the murder trial and execution had on young Woodend, causing him to become a policeman.
It is character that drives the story. Woodend the type of detective I really like. He follows the clues and digs into the details. It was also interesting that there was another officer for whom the case became very personal. The characters aren’t just there to propel the story; you become involved and care about them.
The main portion of the story is set in the 1950’s and really shows the classic ignorance and prejudice toward homosexuals. While that’s not a major element of the story, it does add veracity to the plot. And it is a good plot. To solve one case, they need to solve a second and there is a very good twist.
“A Death Left Hanging” is only the second Woodend book I’ve read but it shan’t be my last.
First Sentence: The moment we met is burned into my mind, and even now, I reply it over and over.
Magazine writer Richard Kilmer travels with his fianc...moreFirst Sentence: The moment we met is burned into my mind, and even now, I reply it over and over.
Magazine writer Richard Kilmer travels with his fiancée Jennifer Ryan to meet her parents. On the way, a storm causes Richard to lose control of his car, rolling it into a ditch. Although he is apparently unconscious only a brief time, Jennifer has disappeared. Not only is no sign of her found, but there’s no sign she ever existed. He does, however, meet Alison Tynes, a woman who looks identical to Jennifer and whose twin sister, Julie, is also missing.
Numerous authors have tried this premise and it is one I do find intriguing. However, I’ve never yet found an author that carries it off effectively. Certainly this one didn’t. The story became only more farfetched with every chapter and I gave up in fairly short order.
ON BORROWED TIME (Suspense-Richard Kilmer-NY State-Contemp) - DNF Rosenfelt, David Minotaur Books, 2012(less)
First Sentence: A curious world we live in,” said Franklin Merton, “where one can afford a house but not a picture of a house.”
While I loved that Rend...moreFirst Sentence: A curious world we live in,” said Franklin Merton, “where one can afford a house but not a picture of a house.”
While I loved that Rendell opened the story by providing the history of a house involved in the crime, there was one section which, had her writing been less good, would have made the book a wallbanger for me. However, I quickly moved past that feeling and felt that first chapter was a corker.
Her style struck me as a bit simplistic, in the beginning, but I quickly moved past that as well. I loved all the literary references and Wexford’s comment of how nice it would be to be an fictional detective…”I’m an amateur detective now but I haven’t got Lord Peter’s right of entry into a suspect’s home or a right to question him or her.” I enjoyed the look at his personal life; the relationship with his family at a point of crisis.
I enjoyed the mystery but did feel finding the clues relied a big heavily on coincidence, one of which even the character acknowledged, which was nice. I read a non-Wexford a long time ago and hated it. I’m happy to say, this may have changed my attitude to where I would think of reading another in this series.
First Sentence: Caterina Pelligrini closed the door behind her and leaned her back and then her head against it.
Caterina Pelligrini has a degree in ba...moreFirst Sentence: Caterina Pelligrini closed the door behind her and leaned her back and then her head against it.
Caterina Pelligrini has a degree in baroque opera and is Venetian by birth but working in Oxford, England. The offer of a job allows her to return home. Two locked trunks, centuries old and thought to belong to a mostly forgotten composer, have been discovered. Although there are no direct descendants, two cousins claim inheritance and are anxious to discover the rumored treasure thought to be contained within the trunks. With the support of Rosanna Salvi, acting director of the La Fondazione Musicale Italo-Tedesca, and Dottor Moretti, intermediary between Caterina and the cousins, she searchs for this treasure and finds a history she never expected.
This a book only a true opera lover can even begin to enjoy, and only for the opera aspect which is thin in itself. There is very little mystery. Italian phrases which are not translated and whose meaning is not always clear from their use, so you’re either left in the dark for feeling like an idiot. There are numerous characters who float in- and out- of the story but few have a real presence. There were times I enjoyed Caterina, and times she annoyed me beyond belief. There is little, to no suspense, and only a thin attraction to another character. The historical character, who is a real character, is, again, only really interesting to opera fans. The book is completely lacking Ms. Leon’s previously characteristic humor—except in the email communications with her sister--strong sense of place and wonderful descriptions of food.
“The Jewels of Paradise” really is an indulgence book; the author’s indulgence, not the readers. If you live, breathe and are somewhat of an expert on baroque opera; you might enjoy it. Unfortunately, the rest of us will have to wait, and desperately hope, for another book in Ms. Leon’s wonderful Brunetti series.
THE JEWELS OF PARADISE (Mystery-Caterina Pelligrini-Venice, Italy-Contemp) - Okay Leon, Donna Atlantic Monthly Press, 2012(less)
First Sentence: “I’m going to kill the bastard, Maggie.”
Photojournalist Maggie MacGowen is dealing with personal grief, the loss of her television job...moreFirst Sentence: “I’m going to kill the bastard, Maggie.”
Photojournalist Maggie MacGowen is dealing with personal grief, the loss of her television job and tentatively beginning a relationship with a man she met in France. In the interim, she is teaching a class at a local college. Sly Miller, a young man Maggie helped rescue from the streets, is an art student at the college and has been honored with the award of having his art piece on permanent display there. Except that the new college president, ex-Congressman Park Holloway, has declared the piece will be removed in one year. When Holloway is found hanged, questions are raised about Holloway, his past and the art with which Sly’s piece was to be replaced.
Wendy Hornsby has been a favorite author of mine for many years, even before the Maggie MacGowen series. I was, therefore, delighted to see a couple of her original characters re-appear; Kate Teague and Roger Tejeda, albeit in minor roles. Just a note: If you’ve never read “No Harm” (1987) and “Half a Mind” (1990), they are worth seeking out.
Unfortunately, what was missing from this book, was character development within this book, edge and suspense. Maggie’s character is developing across the series but I don’t know that new readers would have a sense of her strength and talent in spite of the backstory which was provided. The characters didn’t come alive; there wasn’t a strong sense of connection to them. I did, however, appreciate that the somewhat recalcitrant cop had a turnaround in attitude, but not that he started out as such a stereotype. Don’t misunderstand; it’s a good story that held my interest all the way through.
As for edge and suspense, there were a couple incidents, but they lacked strong build-up. There wasn’t a sense of impending danger. Even when they happened, it was something of a non-event.
Perhaps I’m seeing Ms. Hornsby’s previous books, from “Telling Lies” through “In the Guise of Mercy” through a fan’s rosy glasses, but those seemed much stronger, more emotionally impactful books to me.
Let me say, however, one shouldn’t at all dismiss this book. It’s a good story. It’s well told and included themes I found fascinating. I very much appreciate the way the story moved from one supposition to something much greater and far reaching. That was very well done. I do like the character of Maggie and her growth in the series. That is very well done. I was certainly never tempted to put the book down. That is always a very good thing.
“Hanging” is definitely a good book. Wendy Hornsby is an author whose work I shall keep reading as long as she keeps writing.
THE HANGING (Unl. Invest-Maggie MacGowen-So. California-Contemp) – Good Hornsby, Wendy Perseverance Press, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: - None; this is a collection of short stores
John Harvey is a poet, dramatist, broadcaster, and very funny man in person although you c...moreFirst Sentence: - None; this is a collection of short stores
John Harvey is a poet, dramatist, broadcaster, and very funny man in person although you certainly would not have known that by this collection. He is also the author of countless book. There two series in particular police procedurals I have enjoyed: The police procedurals with Detective Inspector Charlie Resnick; lover of jazz, owned by cats; and Frank Elder, who tried to retire from the force and failed. I was delighted to see both of them appear in this collection, along with ex-cop/PI Jack Kiley and a few stories with other characters as well.
I freely admit to not being a fan of short stores. By the time I become involved, the story is done. However, Harvey pulled me a bit past my usual bias, and that’s saying something.
These are dark, gritty stories; not noir, but certainly hard-boiled detective fiction. They are about people you hope not to know and lives you’d rather not have touch yours. If anything, the darkness felt grim and unrelenting; almost too much so. A little relief would have been greatly appreciated. The stories are compact, tightly written and complete. Each stands well on its own merit, and the quality of Harvey’s writing is very apparent.
I would not recommend “A Darker Shade of Blue” to new Harvey readers. However, I would definitely recommend it to those who are fans of his writing, particularly those who are fans of short stories, as well.
A DARKER SHADE OF BLUE (Short Story Collection-Various characters-England-Contemp) - VG Harvey, John Pegasus Crime, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: Sometimes the water was glassy and still, and the boat sat on it like a piece of paper on a flat table.
Grace MacBride, partner in Monk...moreFirst Sentence: Sometimes the water was glassy and still, and the boat sat on it like a piece of paper on a flat table.
Grace MacBride, partner in Monkeewrench, finally takes a break, sheds her protective clothing and goes sailing with the friend only to end up saving him from having his throat slit by killing the two assassins instead. Grace’s friends, homicide detectives Leo Magozzi and Gino Rolseth are faced with a string of execution murders. Their investigation leads them to uncover a chain of such murders in cities around the country. The motive puts the Monkeywrench gang directly in the target and fighting to stay alive.
The first pages of a book are so important to a reader and Tracy’s descriptive opening provides a perfect introduction to the books characters, even those not present in the opening scene. We are even introduced to a metamorphosed Grace with an understanding as to how such a change transpired.
Between the police and the Monkeywrench gang, Tracy has established a wonderfully eclectic group of characters that work well together and balance each others strengths and weaknesses, including some of the most basic phobias. Tracy’s dialogue takes you from suspense to humor, providing a well-needed balance.
Tracy’s wonderfully evocative descriptions give a real strength to the story. They are the type of descriptions you don’t just read, you savor. Some you allow to build and form in your mind’s eye for their lyricism and inclusion of mysticism.
There are flaws, however. The character of plot’s villains were too easily set up to be the villains and too stereotypical. There was an unfortunate phrase which kept being used and should have been eliminated. The story had excellent suspense that ratcheted up with each chapter but the ending fell off the cliff. For a group of seemingly brilliant individuals, there was a major too-stupid-to-live event that was nearly unforgivable. The final climatic scene seemed abrupt, almost as though they weren’t certain how to write the dramatic action scene and suddenly, there we are; all done. Even though the epilogue was a good confirmation, it really wasn’t a necessary one, which is too bad. Rather than being a didn’t-see-that-coming revelation, it was I-knew-that confirmation.
“Off The Grid” is a good read. It certainly kept me turning the pages. Its strengths are definitely the characters, dialogue and descriptions. And although there were problems, I was entertained and would put it at the level of a good Sunday or airplane read.
OFF THE GRID (Police Proc/Unl Invest-The Monkeywrench Gang/Det.s Magozzi and Rolseth-Florida/Minnesota-Contemporary – Good Tracy, P.J. – 6th in series Putnam, 2012
First Sentence: In the earth nineteenth century, the Catholic Church realized it had a problem.
The cloistered monks of Quebec’s self-contained Saint-G...moreFirst Sentence: In the earth nineteenth century, the Catholic Church realized it had a problem.
The cloistered monks of Quebec’s self-contained Saint-Gilbert-Entre-les-Loups monastery focus their lives on prayer and the simplicity of Gregorian Chants. The murder of their prior and choirmaster, Frère Mathieu, has forced open their doors to Inspector Gamache and Jean-Guy Beauvoir of the Sûreté du Québec
Penny’s writing is simply superb. Her prose is more than mere words telling a story, her phrases are stories in themselves.
“Gamache couldn’t yet see the blows that led up to the final, catastrophic crushing of this man’s skull. But he’d find them. This sort of thing never came out of the blue. There’d be a trail of small wounds, bruises, hurt feelings, insults and exclusions.”
Penny wonderfully and accurately describes the way in which music can transport the soul. Her analogies are highly evocative.
“The monk examined Gamache. “… We don’t just sing, we are the song.” Gamache could see he believed it. The Chief has a vision of the halls of the monastery filled not with monks in black robes, but with musical notes. Black notes bobbing through the halls. Waiting to come together in sacred song.”
The inclusion of humor adds levity, yet there is anger and pain as well. Her words are thoughtful and thought-provoking. There are contrasts such as describing one particularly dour monk as “The Eeyore of the monastery.”, while having a doctor describe how “People die in bits and pieces.” Her writing causes you to stop and consider the concepts behind the words and can compel one to share passages with others. I’ve been known to call friends at odd hours insisting that they “Listen to this.”
Penny’s descriptions bring places and people to life, placing you at the scene and causing you to see, hear and know the things and people around you. Among Penny’s many strengths is her ability to create characters about whom you want to know more.
This is finally, I feel, the first time we see Gamache truly at his strength in his role. At the same time, we are made painfully aware that although he has a very close relationship, both to its credit and detriment, with his second, Jean-Guy, there are others who would do anything to discredit him. There is a wonderful segment where we learn of the same information but from two separate perspectives. Rather than being redundant, it truly exposes the differences in the personalities of Gamache and Jean-Guy. We also learn the details of the enmity between Gamache and his superior in whom she has created a distinct type of evil; a character who truly excels at manipulation and cruelty.
The story is very well constructed with plots and sub-plots each as interesting as the next. Lest you think this is a cozy, it is not. It is a traditional police procedural solved by investigating and following the clues. It is also a story of relationships and strong emotions, and there is nothing cozy about them.
Staying up most of the night reading is not something one would normally recommend. Staying up most of the night with a new book by Louise Penny is almost unavoidable.
A reader begins every book with the hope of finding something wonderful. “The Beautiful Mystery” is the realization of that hope. It is an excellent, beautifully written book that stays with you long after closing the cover yet leaves you wanting to demand the next book immediately. It is also only the latest in excellent series I recommend reading in order from the beginning.
THE BEAUTIFUL MYSTERY (Pol Proc-Chief Inspector Gamache-Canada-Contemporary – Ex Penny, Louise – 8th in series Minotaur Books, 2012 (less)
First Sentence: The coffin is definitely a health and safety hazard.
Professor and forensic archeologist Ruth Galloway arrives at a family-owned museum...moreFirst Sentence: The coffin is definitely a health and safety hazard.
Professor and forensic archeologist Ruth Galloway arrives at a family-owned museum to supervise the opening of the family’s ancestor, a medieval bishop. Instead, she finds the body of the museum curator dead of an apparent heart attack. His death is followed by that of the Museum owner and owner of a horse-training stable, who had received threatening letters regarding the repatriation of Aboriginal skulls to an Australian representative. Do the skulls carry a curse, or is there an equally evil but more human motivation going on?
Ms. Griffiths has a very good ear for dialogue and for wry humor. The characters emotions, doubts and insecurities are handled in a way that we can be empathic to them, having perhaps experienced some of them ourselves. However, there are times that the protagonist’s inner dialogue is often stronger and more natural than the verbal exchanges between characters. This is offset by the very evocative descriptions; not only of places, but of feelings and concerns.
The characters are dimensional and although some may feel there is too much back-story given, I very much appreciate an author who does not assume everyone has read the previous books in the series. A weakness comes when the characters’ stories’ overwhelms the mystery and the person for whom you may feel the most sympathy is one of the more secondary characters. Yet there is such realism and near rawness of emotion, it shouldn’t be changed.
The story gives a very interesting presentation of the two sides of the argument regarding the repatriation of art and artifacts. While there are other authors who do include mysticism in their plots, Griffiths combines both the mysticism of the Celtic and Aboriginal beliefs in a very effective way yet also providing a scientific explanation as well.
“A Room Full of Bones” contains several different threads to the story. Some threads are intertwined, some less so, yet they combine to result in a book that may not be Ms. Griffith’s best, but it is still a very good read.
ROOM FULL OF BONES (Unl. Invest-Ruth Galloway-England-Contemporary) – VG Griffiths, Elly – 4th in series Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2012
First Sentence: They tell me it was an IED hidden I the truck full of goats going to market, pulled off to the side of the road with an apparent flat...moreFirst Sentence: They tell me it was an IED hidden I the truck full of goats going to market, pulled off to the side of the road with an apparent flat tire.
Journalist Hannah Storm is recovering of head injuries resulting from and IED attack in Afghanistan. She is staying in the old home of her sister and her family whose neighbors are housing Hila, an Afghani woman also severely injured by the war with whom she develops a quiet friendship. Visits to the farm’s root cellar have Hannah discovering more than vegetables; blackouts results in visions of a woman living during the American Revolution. When Hila is discovered murdered, Hannah must deal with her own recovery while trying to uncover the link between the death and the visions.
Ms. Delaney’s book begins with an excellent opening chapter that captures your attention and compels you to read more. She provides evocative descriptions of places and gives you an insight into the background of the protagonist. She also establishes a wonderful sense of the creepy fairly early in the story which, unfortunately, becomes a bit lost along the way.
There are basically three threads to the story; Hannah’s recovery, the possible haunting and the murder. While each is interesting, the weaving of them isn’t necessarily as tight as one might like to the point where I found sections a little dull. I did appreciate the perspective of seeing the life of a Loyalist wife during the Revolutionary War. However, although having an understanding of her life was critical to the story’s climax, it didn’t enhance the suspense of the story. The same could also be said of Hila’s character. She provided a means by which we had a small view into the life of an Afghani woman and a perspective of Afghanistan and the involvement of the West, but I never had a sense of her as a person.
Hannah is a well-drawn, fully dimensional character and reading about her dealing her injuries was one of the most interesting elements of the story. I truly showed the issues of those dealing with unseen injuries or ailments and the lack of understanding and resentments it can incite in others. Unfortunately, the men didn’t fare as well. They felt to be stereotypes, one of which felt completely superfluous to the plot. I identified one of the villains way too early while others seemed rather over-the-top; not so much due to their actions but more due to the dialogue which seemed forced.
In spite of the issues I may have had, “More Than Sorrow” was a good read. It kept me interested all the way through and I did enjoy it.
MORE THAN SORROW (Para Myst-Hannah Manning-Canada-Contemporary/18th Cent) – Good Delany, Vicki – Standalone Poisoned Pen Press, 2012
First Sentence: Chief Inspector Chen Cao of the Shanghai Police Bureau found himself standing in front of the gate to the Wuxi Cadre Recreation Center...moreFirst Sentence: Chief Inspector Chen Cao of the Shanghai Police Bureau found himself standing in front of the gate to the Wuxi Cadre Recreation Center.
Chief Inspector Chen Cao is surprised, pleased and a bit suspicious when he is given an unexpected vacation at a resort reserved for only those of high cadre; influence and/or power. The exclusive resort is located on the once very beautiful and pristine Tai Lake but chemical dumping and greed for wealth are changing that. One of the executives is murdered and a young woman Chen has come to know is being blamed. It is up to Chen to find the truth before she, or her friend, are taken off to prison.
With a tranquil beginning, we are immediately brought into a different world where we learn the importance of rank. Qui excels establishing a strong sense of place. From him we see, hear, smell and taste China. There are wonderful descriptions of the food, which are enhanced by stories of the history behind some of the dishes reminding us just how old is the culture of China.
Chen is fascinating and wonderful character. He’s a policeman who had no desire to be a policeman. He’s a poet and translator of books, particularly mysteries, from English into Chinese. But he is also dedicated to do his job the best he can, realizing its importance. It’s enjoyable to see the local policeman, Sergeant Haung, admiration of Chen and his comparisons of Chen to Sherlock Holmes. Chen is a man of integrity. Although he is attracted to a female character, he knows he must not violate his responsibility as a cop. Poetry and quotation have a significant place in the story. Even the love scene is lyrically described.
We learn details of its history and customs; from the “hair” salons to environmental issues of today. In particular, it is about the changing China, economics and what a company, if permitted, will do to increase its value to increase wealth for its executives. [Chen]”Why are people capable of doing anything just for the sake of money? A partial answer might be the collapse of the ethical system…” It’s prophetic in we see the result of a non-regulated industry, yet it never becomes preach-y.
It is also interesting to see the way in which now having some freedom of religion impacts the people of today’s China. We forget that religion was banned under strict communism so when two of the supporting characters attend a church service it is a new experience for them. However, there is still the strong importance of “saving face”.
There is a redundancy in the constant reminder that the complex is only for those of high cadre of a certain rank and that Chen is only there because of his connection to such a person. However, this also supports Chen’s personality that he would be very much aware of that fact.
“Don’t Cry, Tai Lake” concludes with a wonderful, touching ending. The final revelation as to the solution of the case is summed up best by Officer Huang “The clues are all there, but it takes a master to connect them,”. However, even with the murder solved, the story shows the insular nature of China against the West. I’ve enjoyed the entire series but feel this is one of Qui’s best books.
DON’T CRY, TAI LAKE (Pol Proc-CI Chen Cao-Shanghai, China-Contemporary) - VG Xiaolong, Qiu – 7th in series Minotaur Books, 2012 (less)
Loading...
