Picked this up used after reading a paris review interview with him, even though I didn't much like his personality. I also kind of confused him in myPicked this up used after reading a paris review interview with him, even though I didn't much like his personality. I also kind of confused him in my mind with barry hannah.
Have never seen the movie despite it being a pop culture touch stone....more
As usual with Eco the history and the details are there. It is however very tiresome to read in many ways just because of the repetition of the libelsAs usual with Eco the history and the details are there. It is however very tiresome to read in many ways just because of the repetition of the libels. It's hard stuff to listen to over and over again. But there is a real fascination with the history presented particularly because Eco seems trustworthy in that way. The action is also in some parts sketchy and perfunctory, though at other times particularly the Italian adventures comes closer to a real novel....more
I liked this a lot. Of course the characters all have issues and problems. Some people claim they are unlikeable but for me it was quite easy to likeI liked this a lot. Of course the characters all have issues and problems. Some people claim they are unlikeable but for me it was quite easy to like them. That's one of the nice things about the novel is that they are a bit complicated as people. I liked the story too. I read it quickly though there were one or two tough spots if i remember. (Emotionally rough not intellectually.) plenty of interesting things to think about. I liked the way the narrative bounced around but still seemed easy to follow. I liked that small things would come up and connect back through the novel simetimes just in small ways sometimes in bigger ways.
What didn't I like. This was a bit tough for me to put my finger on. I guess what I would say is that there is a bit of cartoonishness about the characters. To a large extent I thought they were realistic complicated characters, and that they did hang together as a family. There is just some quality about them that was a bit silly. I think this was intentional on his part. It kind of relates to Chip's realization while walking to Poland. Farce not tragedy. So i am not saying he should have changed it. I see why it was like that I think. Maybe I just have a preference for the tragic
I felt I noticed some similarities with Foster Wallace's stuff, particularly in some of the topics and themes, but I seem to have a preference for Franzen
I think this book will bear some thinking about. I kind of imagine though if I revise my opinion it will be up rather than down....more
Erdrich "Fleur": I think this is the third story by Erdrich I've read and I've liked them all, although I thought this one wasn't quite as good as theErdrich "Fleur": I think this is the third story by Erdrich I've read and I've liked them all, although I thought this one wasn't quite as good as the story in the 2002 volume of this series.
Johnson "The Children's Wing": A nice enough story and decently written. I didn't really like the last few lines of the story.
Boswell "The Darkness of Love": Interesting story. Well written. One interesting point though was that the story was about a black family, and the main character is a black cop. Something I can't really put my finger on made me question whether the author was black or white. (He's white. So am I for the record.) I liked the story and would definitely like to read more by this author, but I wonder if that feeling I had doesn't say something about some point of feel. It's interesting to me to wonder whether a white author could get away with writing about black characters in the current intellectual and political climate or whether they would be rejected out of hand as not having the necessary experience for it or even worse accused of somehow trying to "appropriate" or "colonize" black culture or lives. Those aren't arguments I would make, but it's something to think about the changing climate around these issues.
Adams "Tide Pools": I liked this story. It was simple but presented what I thought was an interesting situation. It has a kind of happy ending. It will never be a contestant in any heavy weight competition but it was a nice read and the writing was fine. On the other hand, I don't really see myself seeking out any more of this author's work.
Dybek "Blight": I liked this story. The characters are pretty much the whole thing. The city itself does play a part. I felt the ending was a little limp, due probably to the fact that there's no plot really. I'm would definitely consider reading more of this author's work, particularly because I lived in Chicago for a short while and am interested in the city.
Lott "The Janeites": I really thought this story was horrible dreck. The emotional content was cheap and poorly done. And the "intellectual content" of the story was ridiculous. Basically this dude gets to feel superior because some evil academic defends a nasty character in a Jane Austen novel for all the wrong reasons. My God what is the world coming to! There was also a stereotyped and questionable scene with black boys and a boom box on the bus. Tellingly, I have looked up a number of the authors in this book on the internet and I can find no traces of Mr. James Lott, though admittedly I didn't search very hard.
Barthelme "Basil from Her Garden": I saw the name Barthelme on the table of contents. It rang a bell but I didn't know anything about him so I looked him up and found a website that has several of his stories on it. Usually this kind of thing is not really my taste, I usually prefer realistic stories. (That being said I do like Borges.) Whether because I've gotten more open minded lately, or whether there was just some connection I did like some of the Barthelme stories I read. On the other hand,I didn't like this one in the collection that much. It didn't have the zap that some of the shorter ones of his did. I definitely see myself trying to get a hold of some more of this guy.