My daughters both love to be read to and in the past year we have really started to incorporate some good read aloud stories. Of course we read aloudMy daughters both love to be read to and in the past year we have really started to incorporate some good read aloud stories. Of course we read aloud picture books and the like, but I'm taking about real chapter books with and without sparse pictures and illustrations. Enough that we can sit together and read and enjoy listening, but also where they can lie in bed and listen to me read to them from the rocking chair. I have a crazy list of books to read, both some I already have and others I'm trying to find. I have a few Grosset & Dunlap Junior Illustrated Library Classics and books that mimic that classic feel are my favorite for us as opposed to just random paperback copies. I want things that will last. Thus, when unexpected The Wonderful Wizard of Oz illustrated in full color by Michael Sieben appeared for review I was ecstatic! We have spent the last few months filling the moments before bedtime snuggling and reading about Dorothy's adventure with her friends. While reading I had several updates and thoughts including the fact that this is really full color, "complete" and unabridged. Crazy THICK paper!
Crazy THICK paper! This is the first time I have read this classic and I'm sharing the experience with my preschooler. This particular edition from HarperDesign is very heavy with thick photo type paper but feels good and solid in my hands. I'm unsure what I think about the art, especially the eyes. However the text to art ratio is perfect for us now in attention to longer text storybook reads. I'm really excited.
Enjoying the story and the ratio of text to illustration. These are just bizarre illustrations.
Heavy book for my 3.5 to carry. Really enjoying the story. Might finish before @DisneyOzMovie comes out. (Well that didn't happen, but we did get to watch the movie and she knew a little bit about Oz from Dorothy's story. I think it will spark an interest in going back to read Oz's story and others...)
The Green Lady version of Oz is the first illustration I have actually liked. I'm still with mixed feelings.
Now back to current me. I did enjoy the image of the Green Lady and that of the good witch Glinda. But mostly I thought they were a bit bizarre, but then I'm a calm traditional artist viewer. I love the impressionists, but I cannot stand Picasso. So this falls a bit in between. I love that it is extravagant. I love the it is bizarre and creative for my young daughter to see and really experience someone's interpretation. Actually it was a few days before this one arrived that we had ordered the Sterling Illustrated Classic Robert Ingpen illustrated edition. This one is big and wide, like a lap story book. It is neat to compare the more traditional illustrations to the quirky ones of Michael Sieben. I like this book, this specific book. I'm glad we have. While I might not have picked it up at first I'm glad that we did get through it and stop to look at all the pictures. This is a normal trade size book that will fit well on the shelf with any other classics and chapter books. The illustrations are full color and vibrant on schemes of green, red, yellow and orange. There are more than fifty full color illustrations and they really lend to the imagination.
This would make a really good contemporary gift. As I read in the press release, "Folk Art Meets Punk Rock in this Beautiful Edition of a Classic Tale" and that is definitely the truth!
'The Wind in the Willows' was a big part of my childhood. In my mind I always thought 'Frog and the Toad' and 'The Wind in the Willows' was the same s'The Wind in the Willows' was a big part of my childhood. In my mind I always thought 'Frog and the Toad' and 'The Wind in the Willows' was the same story or series. It is only now as a mother to a kindergartener entering on reading on her with early readers such as the 'Frog and the Toad' series and read alouds for all the children in such titles as 'The Wind in the Willows' that I've discovered they are quite different, NOT the same Mr. Toad! Part of my childhood experience and memories of 'The Wind in the Willows' (which I also always thought was The Wind AND the Willows, wrong again I suppose) was the animated storybook we have recorded off TV on a VHS tape. My children watch that sometimes as well, maybe one day we'll find the good digital version. But what I'm getting at is that to my mind, the characters have a specific look in my imagination due to that influence which resembles more Robert Ingpen or E.H. Shepard illustrations, so this new version illustrated by David Roberts is quite different for me.
David Roberts' illustrations are quite contemporary and new to me, but they are fun and vibrant and entertaining for the child's eye. What I love, is his words and proof on the page of no fear to experiment. What a great example and influence for children! David Roberts edition of 'The Wind in the Willows' is decidedly modern and will open up the classic story to a world of a readers that might not have been interested in the vintage classic story previously before.
In our family, as an art experiment we are enjoying spending time comparing how the same story is told from two different artists perspectives.
I received this product free for the purpose of reviewing it. I received no other compensation for this review. The opinions expressed in this review are my personal, honest opinions. Your experience may vary. Please read my full disclosure policy for more details.
I was on a movie based on the book kick the other day when I was filling my netflix que and this was one that I was able to watch the other day. I wasI was on a movie based on the book kick the other day when I was filling my netflix que and this was one that I was able to watch the other day. I was surprised, all I knew going in was that it was a book. I had not looked at the actors in it nor anything about the book. I was pleasantly surprised because I like those actors and experiencing such a story on hard times and the life in a carnival was very neat. Watching the film I'm not sure if I would like the book or not, because I think it might have lost my interest. However, it was very interesting and challenging in parts to watch. I would watch it again. ...more