I just finished rereading this (I think for the third time) for a class I'm teaching right now and it's still so good. The kids get so much out of itI just finished rereading this (I think for the third time) for a class I'm teaching right now and it's still so good. The kids get so much out of it and it's such a brilliant piece....more
This book was just okay for me. I mean it's a horrifying tale and the reality of it is just totally unimaginable, but the fact that it was nonfictionThis book was just okay for me. I mean it's a horrifying tale and the reality of it is just totally unimaginable, but the fact that it was nonfiction was probably the only thing keeping me going for the first 150 pages. (Then I admittedly skimmed the last 50 pages.) I just feel like the way Beah writes about his terrible experiences doesn't convey a totally compelling sense of storytelling. I think it's completely understandable that it comes across this way; he endured some of the worst terrors possible, so it makes sense that he might write about it with a certain sense of detachment. But at the same time, I don't think that always means the read is going to be all that great......more
**spoiler alert** The hype surrounding this book--both from friends who have read it and the major press blitz of the past few months--seriously heigh**spoiler alert** The hype surrounding this book--both from friends who have read it and the major press blitz of the past few months--seriously heightened my expectations. With every chapter though, I kept wondering, "Is it going to get better?" Sadly, it never did.
Cleave's novel focuses on the title character's escape from Nigeria to the United Kingdom, where she tracks down the white couple who saved her life while they were on holiday and attempts to gain refugee status. The early chapters constantly reference "the event" of that day on the beach when the British couple Sarah and Andrew suffered unimaginable horrors and found their lives intertwined with Little Bee's. This "event" is so built up by Sarah (who alternately narrates the novel along with Little Bee) and is supposedly the catalyst for Andrew's suicide early in the novel, that the final revelation is almost laughable, particularly since she hardly endures the worst of the abuse that takes place and isn't even present for its aftermath.
As a reader, I am totally sympathetic to Cleave's purpose and cause, yet in writing a novel about the atrocities of the world and the deplorable status of refugees, Cleave uses entirely too heavy a hand, one that constantly made me roll my eyes. Little Bee, for example, periodically relates tales of her village prior to oil-hungry rebels destroying her way of life, and at one point she tells how in her "village [the:] only Bible had all of its pages missing after the forty-sixth verse of the twenty-seventh chapter of Matthew, so that the end of [their:] religion, as far as any of [them:] knew, was My God, my god, why hast thou forsaken me?" Seriously? Later, the African characters' names through are similarly contrived (her sister's name becomes "Kindness" at one point) and in the final pages Cleave hits his reader square over the head when Little Bee tells Sarah's son what her original African name is: Peace.
Cleave's narrative is also full of uneven characterizations. Little Bee spends two years in an immigrant detention facility where she learns to speak the "Queen's English" perfectly by reading magazines and newspapers. In fact, she even learns the nuances of political satire, claiming that she learned "it was not important to have a plan for suicide under the Liberal Democrats." She then inconceivably comes out of the two years of self-education without knowing that there is any other film in existence other than Top Gun, which she saw in her village as a young girl. These inconsistencies are then matched with unbelievable plot points, like Little Bee's admission of being at the scene of a crime, a scene at which she took no pains to cover her actions and yet no authorities found evidence of her presence.
Amidst all the trash though, there are certain truisms. The loss of Sarah's husband after two years of his depression prompts her to note that "there was no quick grief for Andrew because he had been so slowly lost. First from my heart, then from my mind, and only finally from my life." A colleague at one point tells Sarah, "What happened to watning, Sarah, was getting a few of the things we wanted." Then at one point Little Bee tells a white man, "In your mind you still don't think I really exist. It does not occur to you that I can be clever, like a white person. That I can be selfish, like a white person." Small phrases like this peppered throughout the guffaw-inspiring narration of the rest of the book did bump this review past the two-star mark for me, and at times the book's worst lines were even enjoyable because they made me laugh out loud. My favorite is when Sarah looks around her house, feeling her life is spinning out of control and thinks, "Sofa from Habitat. Memories from hell." In the end, this novel feels precisely like that sofa from Habitat: a pseudo-chic and stylized text with mass-market appeal....more
A gorgeously illustrated version of the traditional African folktale. I use this in class with sophomores when I teach Toni Morrison's Song of SolomonA gorgeously illustrated version of the traditional African folktale. I use this in class with sophomores when I teach Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon, but it's a great read for kids to teach them about some of the more difficult history of this country. ...more
I am such a huge fan of Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and I really wanted to love this book. I was introduced to Adichie in a multicultural literature claI am such a huge fan of Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and I really wanted to love this book. I was introduced to Adichie in a multicultural literature class when we watched her TED Talk entitled "The Danger of a Single Story." Her eloquent speech is required viewing now in my classes, and I eagerly sought out her writing. I first read her other novel, Half of a Yellow Sun, and several of her short stories that were published in The New Yorker. I found them mostly brilliant, yet they differ from Purple Hibiscus in that they are much more adult themed than this novel. Perhaps that is what this piece lacks. What I've found in Adichie's other works is a mature and subtle understanding of the layered lives we live, and she writes about them from an Nigerian perspective that provides truth to the universality of our daily struggles worldwide. Since Purple Hibiscus centers on a fifteen-year-old protagonist and her devoutly religious and abusive father, I found the story all too boring. The storyline and structure were tired and contrived in much the way an actual fifteen-year-old girl would write--maybe that was her intent? I had to force myself to finish this book, and I was immensely sad at feeling that way. I am still in love with Adichie though, and I look forward to her future work!...more
Based on my experiences reading student essays and just listening to the general literary grapevine, I was already pretty familiar with the plot of ThBased on my experiences reading student essays and just listening to the general literary grapevine, I was already pretty familiar with the plot of Things Fall Apart before I started reading the actual text. I knew the narrative to be a compelling representation of the collision between British colonialism and Nigerian nativism. Upon engaging with the text however, I was struck by the level at which Achebe succeeds in allowing both the civility and the barbarism to coexist within both societies so eloquently. Okonkwo's characterization and arc are difficult portrayals of the effects of Western greed disguised in salvation coupled with the harsh realities of a shifting native culture that cannot catch up with its destructive deliverance from primitivism. This is a book I'd like to read again in the future, especially if given the opportunity to teach it. My four-star rating is due primarily to the disconnected style in which Achebe relates the story; perhaps this is culturally stylistic or even representative of an allegorical technique, but I found it difficult to truly connect with Okonkwo in the way I expect to when reading fiction. In hindsight though, this might be due to his character's truly difficult position of being a father caught in changing times within his chosen homeland. Some of the difficult actions he takes(view spoiler)[--beating his wives, murdering his adopted child, disowning his son-- (hide spoiler)]which might be unpalatable if the reader feels too close to him....more
I was introduced to Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie during a workshop a few months ago where we watched her TED speech, "The Danger of a Single Story." The tI was introduced to Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie during a workshop a few months ago where we watched her TED speech, "The Danger of a Single Story." The talk brilliantly highlights the need to read outside one's reality in order to rid ourselves of stereotypes and myths, as well as the false belief that we understand an entire people based on a single story. I knew that the moment my reading shelf had an opening, I'd choose one of her novels.
I really wanted to love this novel, and I did. Centered on the 1960s secession of Biafra from Nigeria and the ensuing war that joined the country back together, Adichie creates a moving story of a handful of characters whose lives are drastically altered by the war. Her characters are intricately drawn and vividly realized, and her fragmented story construction and shifting points of view create a swift read. (I did not give it five stars, however, because I did feel it was a tad bit long.)
This book is precisely why I love fiction; it educates through an empathy that only a deep fictional narration can achieve, a penetration of multiple characters' psychologies combined with carefully structured plot devices--something that nonfiction, even memoirs, just can't match. Having read this so closely after the similarly Nigerian-themed novel Little Bee I am reminded of the importance of reading authentic voices who can write with authority. Whereas Little Bee is written by a white British male journalist, Half of a Yellow Sun is written by native Nigerian and trained fiction writer Adichie. Where Little Bee felt like the story construction and character development were second to the author's political message, Half of a Yellow Sun is precisely the opposite, a book in which the craft of storytelling quietly leads you down a path to political and moral understanding almost by surprise....more
This absolutely fantastic collection of short stories demonstrates that Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie is one of the sharpest talents around in contemporaryThis absolutely fantastic collection of short stories demonstrates that Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie is one of the sharpest talents around in contemporary fiction. The stories are each distinct, some set in the United States, others set in Nigeria, but each contains an emotional transparency that holds the reader whether Adichie spins the tale of a well-off medical student holed up with a peasant during a rebel incursion or zooming in on the life of a Nigerian immigrant forced to take a nannying job with an affluent family in the suburbs. I've read Adichie has been referred to do as the "literary daughter" of Chinua Achebe, and the final story in this collection proves the link is more than conjecture. In "The Headstrong Historian," Adichie imagines the a final chapter for Achebe's Things Fall Apart, providing a female protagonist who is a direct descendent of one of the characters in that novel exploring her family and cultural heritage.
I've also seen Adichie referred to as one of the greatest writers to come out of Africa in recent memory, and I argue that she is clearly one of the greatest writers to enter the literary scene regardless of her continent of origin. She's a fabulous African writer, she's a fabulous female writer, and she's simply a fabulous writer!...more
When I downloaded this book to my Kindle, I was bowled over by how long it looked. On the Kindle, publishers can't play with font size and spacing theWhen I downloaded this book to my Kindle, I was bowled over by how long it looked. On the Kindle, publishers can't play with font size and spacing the way they can in published books to make a book whatever length they want it to be. Undaunted, I dove in and I quickly found Abraham Verghese's style similar to that found in John Irving's lengthier books like The Cider House Rules and The World According to Garp. In fact, Verghese says in his acknowledgments that close the book that he is "grateful to John Irving for his friendship" suggesting that he has "learned so much from him both in [their:] correspondence and in his published works," so he is clearly influenced by Irving's style and plot structure, the former of which is much more sophisticated than the latter.
Following the life of Indian and British expatriate doctors and nurses living in Ethiopia during the mid-twentieth century, Cutting for Stone does provide an interesting glimpse into Eastern African history and culture, yet because the narrator is the child of an nun from India and a doctor from Great Britain, the focus still lies within the colonized world. The novel does offer insight into the historical elements of Ethiopian culture, ranging from the Italian colonization to the Eritrean violence to the corrupt rule of Emperor Haile Selassie, but the native characters are all painted in savage tones. The only developed native Ethiopians in the book suffer devastating effects of rudimentary medical understanding, opting for traditional and dangerous practices like female circumcision rather than proven medical science. Whereas Verghese's style mimics Irving's in his total immersion of the reader within the vocabulary and jargon of the world in which the characters are living. Oftentimes, this immersion comes with tongue firmly in cheek (as Irving often does), such as when the doctor narrator suggests that his father "had a theory that bedroom Amharic and bedside Amharic were really the same thing: Please lie down. Take off your shirt. Open your mouth. Take a deep breath...The language of love was the same as the language of medicine. (Irving's misogyny is here too, most evident when the narrator is reunited with his past love who has wronged him terribly, forcing himself upon her as he loses his virginity in an encounter that borders on rape.)
Verghese's story structure however suffers from histrionics at points, including such tired elements as a somewhat obligatory suicidal hanging when a native woman sees the errors of her ways. Just prior to the death, an Indian doctor screams at the Eritrean woman for her poor choice in medical practice for her daughter, asking her "My God...You stupid woman! ...Oh, God, God. Why? ...You've probably killed her...do you know that?" While this sentiment is likely the same accurate subtextual feelings that exist between the native Ethiopians and the doctors that come from more developed countries, it is a bit unsettling when considering the unique perspective this text offers on a part of the world that is nearly absent from popular literature.
In the end, I did enjoy the book. Verghese provides a satisfying narrative in the totality of his scope, which is something I always loved about Irving's books. So long as the reader is aware of the inherent dangers in reading a single story based on a foreign culture, there is enough good here to enjoy!...more
I loved reading this book with my daughter. It is precisely the type of book that more kids should read in order to show young learners the many diffeI loved reading this book with my daughter. It is precisely the type of book that more kids should read in order to show young learners the many different types of people there are in this world. Each chapter begins with the same refrain: "Anna Hibiscus lives in Africa. Amazing Africa" (7). The repetition sets the stage for the amusing focus in each chapter but also reminds us that we are in fact somewhere other than the United States. I mostly enjoyed the ways in which the story focused on different ways of life in Africa, not merely on the privileged. Anna's experiences are universal yet specific to her African homeland, providing for a great experience for children!...more
This is a terrific installment in the Anna Hibiscus series. As with the first installment, each chapter starts with the mantra "Anna Hibiscus lives inThis is a terrific installment in the Anna Hibiscus series. As with the first installment, each chapter starts with the mantra "Anna Hibiscus lives in Africa. Amazing Africa" (7), providing a great perspective on an unrepresented locale in American children's fiction. The chapters in this edition cover stage fright, Anna's coarse and beautiful hair, the abundant power outages in Africa, and poverty. Even the weightier subjects are covered with a point of view that even my three-year-old son could understand (not to mention my five-year-old daughter) and the book gave us the foundation for some terrific conversations. I recommend this book to every parent. It's an important way to broaden your children's horizons or to reinforce their sense of self!...more
I like how the books in this series all build upon one another; each book references chapters from the other books and there's a continuous storylineI like how the books in this series all build upon one another; each book references chapters from the other books and there's a continuous storyline in the first three of Anna heading off to Canada to visit her maternal grandmother and see snow for the first time. Based on the cover of the fourth book, it culminates in her actually reaching that snowy landscape! My kids are very excited for Anna to actually reach Canada and play in the snow, so they enjoyed the scenes of Anna trying to buy cold-weather clothes, which is not the easiest thing to do in Africa! Each chapter does stand on its own though, which makes these great bedtime reading, especially when we can't get to them each and every night. The chapters are a tad long for my kids' age group, but I really like how there are some great lessons about self-esteem on a personal level and global awareness on a societal level interwoven throughout each story. These are great books!...more
I’m fast becoming a huge fan of Chimamanda Ngozi Adiche. Her adult fiction is intelligent and important, and Americanah is no exception. Here she detaI’m fast becoming a huge fan of Chimamanda Ngozi Adiche. Her adult fiction is intelligent and important, and Americanah is no exception. Here she details the seemingly doomed relationship between two Nigerians: Ifemelu and Obinze. Their affair begins in Africa and seems destined to fail once Ifemelu moves to America, but through a fragmented storyline that opens in the present and fills in the holes via flashbacks and shifting narrative perspective, Adiche provides a refreshing and unique point of view on how race truly is a social construct that mutates between cultures and continents.
Early on, Ifemelu quips “How easy It was to lie to strangers, to create with strangers the versions of our lives that we have imagined” (17). Upon her move to America, she suffers that traditional immigrant experience of feeling a part of two worlds and failing to feel at home in either. However, as an African immigrant in a country where blackness defines social standing, she provides a new frame of reference. Ifemelu finds a type of fame in the United States as an anonymous blogger on race, but her authority on the matter is rather suspect according to American standards. She is hired to give speeches on race only to be told that her ideology is flawed and anonymous posters regularly start flame wars on her website. The sister of her African American activist Ivy League professor boyfriend summarizes the issue when she somewhat spitefully suggests that the reason “Ifemelu can write that blog [is] because she’s African. She’s writing from the outside. She doesn’t really feel all the stuff she’s writing about. It’s all quaint and curious to her. So she can write it and get all these accolades and get invited to give talks. If she were African American, she’d just be labeled angry and shunned” (336). In reality, she has to learn the hard way that there is immense truth in what her aunt tells her upon her arrival to America: “You are in a country that is not your own. You do what you have to do if you want to succeed” (119). Ifemelu suffers considerably in a number of ways, and she fails to come to terms with the reality of her success until late in the novel, particularly her reliance on a white family that find her friendship an important collectible tchotchke for their mantle of liberalism.
Meanwhile, Obinze is shut out of her life after her move, and he must find his own path to success. He struggles with immigration abroad in his own way, only to find a path to economic success and a traditional family back home. The only problem is that “he was no longer sure, he had in fact never been sure, whether he liked his life because he really did or whether liked it because he was supposed to” (21). Upon Ifemelu’s return to Lagos late in the chronology of the story—a plotline that is revealed rather early in the novel however—he questions whether or not he can stay in the life he has created now that his past has returned to him. When he contemplates leaving his life behind in order to create a new future with Ifemelu, he is told by a friend “many of us didn’t marry the woman we truly loved. We married the woman that was around when we were ready to marry. So forget this thing. You can keep seeing her, but no need for this kind of white-people behavior. You can keep seeing her, but no need for this kind of white-people behavior. If your wife has a child for somebody else or if you beat her, that is a reason for divorce. But to get up and say you have no problem with your wife but you are leaving her for another woman? Haba. We don’t behave like that, please” (472).
This “white-people behavior” is the soul of the Americanah—the native Nigerian who returns after having lived abroad in a Western culture that unintentionally marginalizes traditional African life. Ifemelu joins an Americanah Club upon her return and realizes that “It’s as if we are looking at an adult Nigeria that we didn’t know about” (429); her new outlook on her homeland is mature, but the conflict of embracing Western culture and her native way of life is a difficult one to overcome. Such is the crux of this post-colonial tale: how does a country with such promise move beyond the devastating effects of colonialism without embracing the power that exists in the Western world? When Ifemelu tells her American ex-boyfriend that “race doesn’t really work here. I feel like I got off the plane in Lagos and stopped being black” (476), there is both truth and falsehood wrapped up in that statement. Blackness is a construct in America born of a oppressive legacy that many refuse to face, and having lived so long within that culture, how can Ifemelu possibly shed the trappings of that identity even upon her return to a country without the same social constraints? ...more
I loved almost everything about this book. The chapters set in Zimbabwe are powerful and real, and the protagonist's move to America provides anotherI loved almost everything about this book. The chapters set in Zimbabwe are powerful and real, and the protagonist's move to America provides another great glimpse into immigrant life in modern America. Every chapter is focused and poetic in its narration, and the horrific aspects are balanced with the humorous....more
While on the surface much of this book sounds like it should be trite and contrived, it simply works. The titular Burgess boys are Jim and Bob, escapeWhile on the surface much of this book sounds like it should be trite and contrived, it simply works. The titular Burgess boys are Jim and Bob, escapees from Maine living the high life as lawyers in New York; the former in insanely wealth, helping the rich stay rich, and the latter is a Legal Aid attorney, helping the poor and downtrodden. Initially, they seem to have left behind Bob's twin sister Susan and the shadows of guilt over their father's death when they were all children, but when Susan's son Zach makes an incredibly stupid decision, one that disrupts the delicate balance between hearty Mainers and the newly relocated Somali refugees, the boys are pulled back home and the reality of their ties to their hometown and each other are revealed to be both strong and strained.
Strout explores various narrative perspectives, seemingly inconsistently, yet each contributes to the central themes of her novel. Her characters are flawed and imperfect, and she simultaneously makes them endearing and horrifying. The book read incredibly quickly, and I admit loving every minute of it....more