This is good. I know, I know, what sort of a review is that? But I've sat and tried to think of a review, I've even started three times, and I reallyThis is good. I know, I know, what sort of a review is that? But I've sat and tried to think of a review, I've even started three times, and I really don't know what else to say.
This is the first Brian Freeman book I've read and I am off to read another. I like the way he tells a story, slowly revealing each new piece of information. I'd say it was like peeling an onion but it isn't. More like eating your way through a box of chocolates without any clue what is inside the box. Each new chapter is wrapped in a tasty layer of chocolate but the filling is a surprise. Yes, I can't believe I've just used that analogy either.
Let's leave it at...I am going through a murder/mystery phase at the moment and I loved this book. My one problem (oddly) was with the detective. The story was great, him not so much. So, next Brian Freeman will not be a Cab Bolton story....more
So, I had to fly back to England, 14 hours on a plane, and maria loaded up my Kindle with books. She told me I'd like this. I knew she was wrong, butSo, I had to fly back to England, 14 hours on a plane, and maria loaded up my Kindle with books. She told me I'd like this. I knew she was wrong, but because I love her, I gave it a try...well, one of us was wrong!
I loved this.
A small town story, where very little happens, and yet I never wanted it to finish. And when it did, I was left with a tear in my eye....more
Just brilliant. I realise that this isn't much of a review, and for that I should apologise...but I won't. The simple fact is, if you have arrived he
Just brilliant. I realise that this isn't much of a review, and for that I should apologise...but I won't. The simple fact is, if you have arrived here by reading the first two books, I promise you will not feel cheated by this book. It is an excellent conclusion. I was moved to tears several times, I laughed out loud, and when I turned the last page I let out a huge sigh of disappointment. I was sad because I had to leave the characters, the world, and their story behind.
I cannot recommend this trilogy highly enough. They are excellent - and every teacher should be recommending them to young adults. In fact, stop reading this review and go get book one. Now!...more
I really want to write a review for this book, but I feel that I won't be able to do it justice. I gave it 24 hours before I started to write, becauseI really want to write a review for this book, but I feel that I won't be able to do it justice. I gave it 24 hours before I started to write, because I wanted to settle my thoughts. However, I have already started the third book in the series, and already my mind has started racing. This means that I have ended up sat here, for 30 minutes, writing and re-writing this review. I can't quite say how excited this book has made me.
The first book was a "road" book. It was an introduction to the characters, the world it is set on, and the politics. This book (the second in the trilogy) is set in one single, claustrophobic town. Todd and Viola having reached Haven, however they now become embroiled in a fight between two political ideologies: The Ask and The Answer. Remembering that these books are "Young Adult" fiction, the author brilliantly lays out the ideas/ideals of fascism and terrorism. The two protagonists are forced to choose a side (or are, at least, presented with situations that force them to choose), and thus the reader is also forced to accept that their "favourites" have made choices with which the reader may disagree.
I started to read these books because I was looking for books to recommend to my students. Sadly, I feel that these books are "too old" for my grade 6. I'd love to recommend them to some of my students, but after "The Hunger Games" recommendation, it wasn't just the whole grade 6 that read the book, but it spread through the school via siblings, and fourth graders were reading THG. I cannot recommend this book, knowing that it will end up in the fourth grade. This is a great shame because I would love to discuss these books with students.
And, at that point, I'll stop. I don't know if I've said anything useful here at all, except: read this book. If you have a teenage child, are related to a teenager, know one, read this book and then give it to them. Then a week later (it will only take a week) sit down with them and discuss their thoughts/feelings about this book. I would place this book right up there with 1984 as an eye-opener on political manipulation.
This was not what I was expecting at all. At one point, someone tells Todd that "everything he knows is a lie." As the bookI am wonderfully confused.
This was not what I was expecting at all. At one point, someone tells Todd that "everything he knows is a lie." As the book is written from Todd's point of view, and as all the information we are given is via Todd, it means that everything we know is a lie too. Which makes for a strange read. You spend half the book learning everything you can about the world that Todd lives in, to spend the rest of the book having to relearn everything all over again.
Welcome to New World, a planet that has been resettled by pilgrims, looking for their Eden. Except it isn't Eden. A war with the Spackles (the previous inhabitants) has ended with two major outcomes: all the women are dead; all the men can hear each other's thoughts. This ability to hear each other's thoughts means that the world is full of Noise. You can hear other men's thoughts, you can hear your dog's thoughts, you can hear the thoughts of all living things. This is Todd's world. A world where he is the youngest boy, in fact, the only boy. Every other person in Prentistown has already achieved manhood, an occasion that Todd is looking forward to with great anticipation.
And then Todd discovers a hole in the Noise. A hole that is best described as Silence.
I really enjoyed this book. I laughed a lot, read bits out to my wife, screamed "NOOOOOO!!!!" several times, and wiped away tears a couple of times too. I'm off to read book two!...more
How bad is this book? Bad enough that I am tempted to go back and re-write reviews for the other books in the series. Do not read this book - esAwful!
How bad is this book? Bad enough that I am tempted to go back and re-write reviews for the other books in the series. Do not read this book - especially if you enjoyed the previous three. Stop at the end of "Specials".
Unfortunately, this book points out the *huge* plot holes in the previous books, holes that I'd been willing to skip over, but were pushed to the forefront with all the subtlety of a brick to the face. Plus, any growth done by any character in the previous books, is either ignored or changed. Familiar dynamic characters become mere cyphers, characters who were treated with respect become nothing more than caricatures. And no one learns. No one grows.
Whereas before, the author seriously took on the targets of plastic surgery, anorexia/bulimia, recycling/reuse/renew, cutting, and mind control - now we have an attack on "fame" and the end result? Well, fame *is* important. If you don't have fame then you are nothing!
Just don't read this. Enjoy "The Uglies Trilogy" and stop there....more
[24hr Update: Having thought about this for a bit, I've changed my rating. Previously I gave the book 5 stars, I realise that this was really for the[24hr Update: Having thought about this for a bit, I've changed my rating. Previously I gave the book 5 stars, I realise that this was really for the series as a whole. As an individual book I would probably rate Specials as a 4 star book.]
I'm going to treat this review as an end to the trilogy. Yes, I realise that there is a fourth book, but I like to think that the author had invented such a great protagonist in Tally Youngblood that he wanted her to have a last "hurrah".
Simply put, this series isn't really a trilogy, so much as one blummin' huge book. I first set about reading this series because i was looking for another book to recommend to my 6th grade. At first, I thought that this would be an ideal series. The thoughts/ideas raised in book one would have struck resonant chords with my students. However, as Harry Potter grew through his years at Hogwarts, so Tally grows and the situations that arise become more mature. Because of this, I am not recommending the book to my students. This is not because I feel that they couldn't deal with it, some of them could, but mainly because the sixth grade is the top grade in the school. After we read Hunger Games, fifth graders and fourth graders took up the book. I don't believe that this series is aimed at that age level. So, no recommendation to my students.
BUT, I *do* recommend this series.
The author has built a world, a world that has realised the mistakes of our world. A world has set about trying to make up for the mistakes that we have made (are making). However, to make up for those mistakes, there has to be a certain amount of mind-control in order to curb the natural excesses of humanity. This builds a dilemma into the book. Is it better to have free will if that leads to the Earth's destruction? Or is it better to "fix" people with an operation, thus saving the planet? The book is so well written, that although you dislike the "prettified" world, you can't help but see how badly we are messing up the present day, and how the people who have reversed the mind control, start to repeat our mistakes.
I think the series is brilliant! It is at moments like this that I wished I taught Year 8/9 so that I could sit down and discuss this series with my class. I can see how the book has raised questions within my own mind, and would love to know how these books would read for 14/15 year olds.
I'm off to read book 4, "Extras". I'm not sure I know what to expect. I liked the ending to the book, and felt that it left everything to the reader to "play god" and decide what was right or wrong. I don't think I'm looking forward to the author making that decision for me. Ha! As if the author of this made up world has any right to make decisions about what happens....more
Congratulations Mr. Westerfeld, you managed to impress me, amaze me, and convince me to read the third book.
When I finished "Uglies" (the first bookCongratulations Mr. Westerfeld, you managed to impress me, amaze me, and convince me to read the third book.
When I finished "Uglies" (the first book in the series), I was really impressed and looking forward to reading "Pretties". 20% into the book, I was starting to feel depressed. What I had hoped for wasn't happening. There was no strong female protagonist, there was nothing new. Well, nothing new except for a new relationship with another boy. Aaaargh! I was worried that I was going to end up with another girl unable to choose between Edward/Jacob Peta/Gale situation. And then everything changed.
I should have trusted the author a lot more. The book quickly became a page turner. Once again I was sent on a wild ride. New situations, new characters were introduced - and not just for the sake of trying to make the book seem different to its predecessor, these things occurred to drive the plot forward. They slowly revealed that the author has a much bigger plan for this story, a story that he intends to unwind slowly.
I am off to read book three - and this time I intend to be more patient while reading the first third! ...more
I'm a sixth grade teacher, and in a desperate search for books that will capture my students' imaginationWow! I really was not expecting that ending.
I'm a sixth grade teacher, and in a desperate search for books that will capture my students' imagination (especially my female students), I decided to give "Uglies" a go. I was a bit sceptical at first, did I really want to recommend a book based on children's looks to my students. Sometimes I can have enough trouble with name calling, without opening up a can of worms about the difference between "pretties" and "Uglies". However, as I read, I was pleasantly surprised.
The book deals with the difficulties of growing up, and the changes that children go through, in a very open and very clear way. It points out the pain of surgery but also points out the benefits. However, it very cleverly starts to point out the lack of personalities of the "Pretties". I'm probably not explaining this very well.The easiest thing to say is that I would very quickly recommend this book, and will happily stand by that recommendation.
The book isn't just about the surgery, it is also set in a future world. A world that remembers how we (the Rusties) attempted to destroy it - with our love of cars, cutting down trees, and non-recycling.
And, at the heart of the book, is a betrayal. A betrayal that I thought would become "glossed over". However, the final third of the book deals with that betrayal head on.
I feel that this book is excellent and will be recommending to my class. It deals with themes and problems that they will face (are facing), and allows the characters of the book to make hard decisions. If I was 12/13 I would be giving this a five star rating. As it is, I am giving it a four star rating but am opening book two as soon as I publish this review....more
Ok, first things first, I know the author. In fact, I would probably describe myself as a friend of the author. Which means that anything I say next iOk, first things first, I know the author. In fact, I would probably describe myself as a friend of the author. Which means that anything I say next is going to be coloured with that brush. I did, however, pay cold hard cash for my copy of the book - a whole 99c (USD) - which is probably also necessary knowledge before you read my review. And, finally, I don't normally read police procedural books, but I picked this up because a friend had written it and it only cost 99c, so I couldn't see the harm. Assuming that is all the information you need - here's my review.
I liked it. It should really be read in one sitting (which is entirely possible because it is more of a novella than a novel) to get the full enjoyment of the story. This is not a "who-dunnit" as the book isn't over padded with red-herrings, wild-goose chases, and other animal-themed asides. No, this starts with a murder, moves on to another murder, and continues until....well, until the end (HA! You're not getting any spoilers out of me.). Along the way a blogger gets involved, and helps the police out with their enquiries (in a positive way).
All in all it is a quick and easy read, with a satisfying conclusion. I'm looking forward to the follow up, which will hopefully flesh out the characters fully. The problem with a novella is that there isn't enough to fully form the characters, and I want to know more about Wil and Chief Inspector Price.
Well, that was different. I really disliked book 2, Catching Fire, but having read my way through two books, I decided to give book three a go. And, IWell, that was different. I really disliked book 2, Catching Fire, but having read my way through two books, I decided to give book three a go. And, I'm glad I did. It is a totally different book. Oh, it never achieves the heights of book one, but it does have its moments.
These moments are mostly caused because of Ms. Collins changing the whole premise of the book, changing the thought patterns of the characters, changing the whole way that time passes, changing her mind about what sort of book she is writing. From the very first chapter, where we suddenly learn that "everything you knew before was wrong", to the second last chapter, where we suddenly learn that "everything that you thought you now knew is in fact as wrong as the other bit you knew", the book becomes very schizophrenic - it really doesn't know what it wants to be. Oh, we still have the odd moments of Katniss pretending to be Bella from Twilight, and we have a lot more moments of her pretending to be Ripley in Aliens, but instead of the book being all about "me, me, me" somehow she becomes more of a viewer to other people's problems. She does actually grow a little in this book. Not much, it is still up to too many other people to do all the hard work for her. But occasionally she does have glimpses of empathy - which is nice.
It is a strange beast this book, because by the end of it, there are very few likeable characters left. Katniss (in case you haven't guessed) I never particularly liked, even though I was desperate for her to be likeable. However, as the book progresses, everyone you learn to like (or have liked), either dies or becomes unlikeable.
The best news about this book is that it ends. There cannot be any more...unless the author - no, she wouldn't. Anyway, even if she did, I won't be on for the ride.
If you've read book 2, read this. Even if it is just to get the taste of book 2 out of your mouth. It'll give you proper closure, and in the second third of the book, remind you why you enjoyed The Hunger Games so much. I'm fairly sure that the film is going to be great though. So, on the whole, I'd give the whole three books a miss and just watch the film instead! [And that is probably the first time I have ever said that.]...more