Poll

April 2012 Science Fiction nominations by Charles

The Sirens of Titan by Kurt Vonnegut
 
  37 votes, 32.2%

The Accidental Time Machine by Joe Haldeman
 
  28 votes, 24.3%

WWW: Wake by Robert Sawyer
 
  20 votes, 17.4%

Rule 34 by Charles Stross
 
  19 votes, 16.5%

 
  11 votes, 9.6%


Poll added by: Charles



Comments (showing 1-26 of 26) (26 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Charles From my perspective, I guess I did a decent job of picking books I want to read, as I'm completely unable to decide which one I want to vote for. :-)


Eric Nice list. I voted for the one I've already bought but haven't read. It was a tossup between that and the one I'm on the waiting list for at the library. I might actually have it by then.


Kenny Chaffin I've heard good things about the WWW series so voted for it. :)


Cynthia Echterling Unfortunately, I've only read one of these.


Matt Webster Great list it just introduced 5 new books to me.


stormhawk A friend of mine recently extolled the wonders of Charles Stross, so I'd consider this an excuse to give him a try.


JSWolf Is there a list of what's won the various votes?


Eric JSWolf - if you click the Polls link near the top of the right column, you can see every poll ever run in this group.


JSWolf It would be easier if someone could make a list of what's won.


Eric I think looking through the Bookshelf link for the group will do that. Sort it by "Date Started" to see what's been read when.

Geoffrey adds books to the bookshelf after they win polls.


JSWolf Thanks.


Stephen Gibson This was difficult. Good choices. I had to chose between Titan, WWW and Wasteland. I love the original idea of "The Old Man and the Wasteland" but in the end voted for Vonnegut. In some ways, "The Old Man" made me think of A Canticle for Leibowitz in the sense that an obscure text has greater misguided meaning after an apocalypse.


Greg The only book out of place, IMHO, is Rule 34, but only because it's a sequel and I haven't read Halting State.


Geoffrey Mod
I was listing the runner up and the winner but I stopped adding the runner up sometime last year ....


message 15: by JSWolf (last edited Feb 02, 2012 07:53AM) (new)

JSWolf Geoffrey wrote: "I was listing the runner up and the winner but I stopped adding the runner up sometime last year ...."

Can you please remove the runner up as it gets confusing?


Bonnie I love Vonnegut & Haldeman equally (for different reasons), but I've read Vonnegut more recently, so... I voted for "The Accidental Time Machine." Besides, the description and member posts made me want to read it soon.


Paul Vincent Wow - I haven't even heard of any of those! Now I have five more books to investigate and possibly add to my "To read..." list. Thanks :)


Charles I'm a bit surprised (but not in a bad way) that "Sirens" is almost making a run-off unnecessary so far. I'm also pleased to see so many votes: have we gained new members recently who got e-readers for Xmas? ;-)


Charles Greg wrote: "The only book out of place, IMHO, is Rule 34, but only because it's a sequel and I haven't read Halting State."

From the sample it didn't seem to be a sequel in the sense that it depended on knowledge of Halting State, so I cheated a bit. ;-)


Phil Mathies Recently read The Forever War by Haldeman and enjoyed his style. He's clearly a science nerd kind of like Neal Stephenson, (one of my favourites) so that's where my vote went.


JSWolf Kurt Vonnegut is overrated. Joe Haldeman should win.


Greg 100 votes in a poll: this is a benchmark for the group.


Geoffrey Mod
It is. And Sirens is ahead by 9 but taking it down to where our smaller polls usually spread, thus may need a runoff ... thoughts?


JSWolf Kurt is highly overrated. Joe is so much better.


Eric The gap between #1 is twice the gap between #2 and #3. I don't know if a runoff is needed here. That seems to be a pretty significant lead for Vonnegut, despite (because of?) JSWolf's distaste.


Greg I think we should establish some ground work on how or when we do a run off. Should we always to a run off if the leading book gets less than 50% of the totals? Or should there be something like if a book has a more the X% leading or X vote count, then we do a run off? I'm fine either way. As long as we get at least 30 days advanced notice, I'm fine with automatic run offs. Also, the nominator or moderator should decide tie breakers if we even need.


back to top

Members can create polls
widget


Madeleine
Madeleine
391 books
3 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Fabio
Fabio
98 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Matt
Matt
89 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Paul
Paul
57 books
11 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Guljan
Guljan
41 books
15 friends
voted for:
The Old M...


Michelle
Michelle
248 books
25 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Terra
Terra
518 books
11 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Gus
Gus
55 books
193 friends
voted for:
WWW: Wake...


Sannie
Sannie
4193 books
359 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Sam
Sam
177 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Old M...


Monica
Monica
374 books
35 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Dennis
Dennis
98 books
8 friends
voted for:
Rule 34 b...


Lucian
Lucian
451 books
4 friends
voted for:
WWW: Wake...


J.R.
J.R.
347 books
114 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Julie
Julie
963 books
15 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Robert
Robert
235 books
31 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Michelle
Michelle
745 books
2560 friends
voted for:
WWW: Wake...


deb
deb
250 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Mallory Heart
Mallory Heart
20270 books
1070 friends
voted for:
WWW: Wake...


Tengizi
Tengizi
65 books
2 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


sjjn
sjjn
272 books
2 friends
voted for:
Rule 34 b...


salvage
salvage
383 books
1 friend
voted for:
The Siren...


Larry
Larry
99 books
7 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Kofi
Kofi
1126 books
90 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Karen
Karen
632 books
6 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Helen
Helen
889 books
20 friends
voted for:
Rule 34 b...


Sherri
Sherri
1272 books
49 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


Jeff
Jeff
345 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Accid...


Bo
Bo
1215 books
130 friends
voted for:
Rule 34 b...


Roxette
Roxette
106 books
27 friends
voted for:
The Siren...


More...