Most Interesting Magic System
Fantasy books with the most original, complex, and interesting magic system.
101 Hounded (The Iron Druid Chr...
by
4.11 of 5 stars 4.11 avg rating — 33,853 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
102 Switch! The Lost Kingdoms o...
by
4.45 of 5 stars 4.45 avg rating — 306 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
103 The Wise Man's Fear (The Ki...
by
4.55 of 5 stars 4.55 avg rating — 140,762 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
104 The Silmarillion
by
3.79 of 5 stars 3.79 avg rating — 107,991 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
105 The Hobbit
by
4.2 of 5 stars 4.20 avg rating — 1,575,740 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
106 The Amber Spyglass (His Dar...
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 148,869 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
107 The Naming (The Books of Pe...
by
3.98 of 5 stars 3.98 avg rating — 15,404 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
108 Magician: Apprentice (The R...
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 40,902 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
109 The Rithmatist (Rithmatist,...
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 14,410 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
110 Summer Knight (The Dresden ...
by
4.29 of 5 stars 4.29 avg rating — 62,769 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
111 The Phantom Tollbooth
by
4.21 of 5 stars 4.21 avg rating — 134,319 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
112 Lirael (Abhorsen, #2)
by
4.3 of 5 stars 4.30 avg rating — 57,955 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
113 The Sweet Far Thing (Gemma ...
by
3.97 of 5 stars 3.97 avg rating — 43,331 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
114 Black Sun Rising (The Coldf...
by
3.93 of 5 stars 3.93 avg rating — 10,872 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
115 The Lies of Locke Lamora (G...
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 62,636 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
116 Abhorsen (Abhorsen, #3)
by
4.28 of 5 stars 4.28 avg rating — 64,442 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
117 Thirteenth Child (Frontier ...
by
3.74 of 5 stars 3.74 avg rating — 6,177 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
117 The Blade Itself (The First...
by
4.1 of 5 stars 4.10 avg rating — 53,337 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
119 The High Lord (The Black Ma...
by
4.14 of 5 stars 4.14 avg rating — 24,500 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
120 Enna Burning (The Books of ...
by
3.95 of 5 stars 3.95 avg rating — 26,126 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
121 The Earthsea Trilogy
by
4.23 of 5 stars 4.23 avg rating — 10,782 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
122 On the Edge (The Edge, #1)
by
4.02 of 5 stars 4.02 avg rating — 17,182 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
123 Fairest
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 38,729 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
124 Mary Stewart's Merlin Trilo...
by
4.34 of 5 stars 4.34 avg rating — 2,919 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
125 The Wizard Heir (The Heir C...
by
4.14 of 5 stars 4.14 avg rating — 24,765 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
126 Rebel Angels (Gemma Doyle, #2)
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 54,749 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
127 Book of Shadows (Sweep, #1)
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 13,783 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
128 Cursor's Fury (Codex Alera,...
by
4.35 of 5 stars 4.35 avg rating — 25,778 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
129 Captain's Fury (Codex Alera...
by
4.37 of 5 stars 4.37 avg rating — 27,691 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
130 The Last Wish
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 14,747 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
131 Moon Called (Mercy Thompson...
by
4.18 of 5 stars 4.18 avg rating — 91,474 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
132 A Madness of Angels (Matthe...
by
3.78 of 5 stars 3.78 avg rating — 3,943 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
133 Sunshine
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 23,320 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
134 Ptolemy's Gate (Bartimaeus,...
by
4.22 of 5 stars 4.22 avg rating — 47,244 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
135 The Enchanted Forest Chroni...
by
4.46 of 5 stars 4.46 avg rating — 6,391 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
136 The Goose Girl (The Books o...
by
4.19 of 5 stars 4.19 avg rating — 73,770 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
137 The Alloy of Law (Mistborn,...
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 35,154 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
138 Anansi Boys
by
3.97 of 5 stars 3.97 avg rating — 109,750 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
139 Princeps' Fury (Codex Alera...
by
4.34 of 5 stars 4.34 avg rating — 29,124 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
140 Hogfather (Discworld, #20)
by
4.16 of 5 stars 4.16 avg rating — 39,287 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
141 First Lord's Fury (Codex Al...
by
4.36 of 5 stars 4.36 avg rating — 28,295 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
142 Galactic Energies
by
4.39 of 5 stars 4.39 avg rating — 310 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
143 The Lost Gate (Mither Mages...
by
3.8 of 5 stars 3.80 avg rating — 12,824 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
144 A Kiss of Shadows (Merry Ge...
by
4.01 of 5 stars 4.01 avg rating — 37,262 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
145 The Emperor's Soul
by
4.31 of 5 stars 4.31 avg rating — 16,183 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
146 Daughter of the Blood (The ...
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 19,316 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
147 White Cat (Curse Workers, #1)
by
3.85 of 5 stars 3.85 avg rating — 22,747 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
148 Eon: Dragoneye Reborn (Eon,...
by
4.01 of 5 stars 4.01 avg rating — 31,607 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
149 The Princess Bride
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 454,551 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
150 Pathfinder (Pathfinder, #1)
by
3.97 of 5 stars 3.97 avg rating — 12,537 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
151 The Singer of All Songs (Th...
by
3.89 of 5 stars 3.89 avg rating — 6,688 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
152 Lightmasters: Number 13
by
4.1 of 5 stars 4.10 avg rating — 115 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
153 Rosemary and Rue (October D...
by
3.74 of 5 stars 3.74 avg rating — 13,357 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
154 The Chronicles of Chrestoma...
by
4.2 of 5 stars 4.20 avg rating — 8,885 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
155 Shadow and Bone (The Grisha...
by
4.09 of 5 stars 4.09 avg rating — 55,111 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
156 The Wayfarer Redemption (Wa...
by
3.9 of 5 stars 3.90 avg rating — 11,194 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
157 The First Book of Swords (B...
by
3.74 of 5 stars 3.74 avg rating — 4,437 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
158 Academ's Fury (Codex Alera,...
by
4.26 of 5 stars 4.26 avg rating — 27,040 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
159 A Shadow in Summer (Long Pr...
by
3.57 of 5 stars 3.57 avg rating — 5,442 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
160 The Belgariad: Volume One
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 10,215 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
161 Libriomancer (Magic Ex Libr...
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 4,909 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
162 Dragon Wing (The Death Gate...
by
3.89 of 5 stars 3.89 avg rating — 15,149 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
163 The Hundred Thousand Kingdo...
by
3.78 of 5 stars 3.78 avg rating — 15,925 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
164 Magic Casement (A Man of Hi...
by
4.04 of 5 stars 4.04 avg rating — 1,598 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
165 The Knife of Never Letting ...
by
3.96 of 5 stars 3.96 avg rating — 66,315 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
166 Feast of Souls (The Magiste...
by
3.88 of 5 stars 3.88 avg rating — 3,467 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
167 Star Crossed (Thief Errant,...
by
3.81 of 5 stars 3.81 avg rating — 4,776 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
168 The BFG
by
4.18 of 5 stars 4.18 avg rating — 156,857 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
169 Rhapsody: Child of Blood (S...
by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94 avg rating — 12,516 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
170 Dragon Prince (Dragon Princ...
by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94 avg rating — 9,835 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
171 The Golem's Eye (Bartimaeus...
by
4.07 of 5 stars 4.07 avg rating — 58,203 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
172 Chocolat (Chocolat, #1)
by
3.91 of 5 stars 3.91 avg rating — 61,946 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
173 The Innocent Mage (Kingmake...
by
3.64 of 5 stars 3.64 avg rating — 11,254 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
174 Magic to the Bone (Allie Be...
by
3.65 of 5 stars 3.65 avg rating — 8,457 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
175 Spellsinger (Spellsinger, #1)
by
3.8 of 5 stars 3.80 avg rating — 3,639 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
176 Deryni Rising (The Chronicl...
by
3.91 of 5 stars 3.91 avg rating — 4,154 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
177 Midnight Riot (Peter Grant,...
by
3.91 of 5 stars 3.91 avg rating — 19,467 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
178 Alanna: The First Adventure...
by
4.25 of 5 stars 4.25 avg rating — 64,904 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
179 Fablehaven (Fablehaven, #1)
by
4.04 of 5 stars 4.04 avg rating — 74,169 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
180 The Darkness That Comes Bef...
by
3.74 of 5 stars 3.74 avg rating — 9,459 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
181 Dead Beat (The Dresden File...
by
4.42 of 5 stars 4.42 avg rating — 54,093 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
182 Jhereg (Vlad Taltos, #1)
by
4.15 of 5 stars 4.15 avg rating — 8,147 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
183 The Neverending Story
by
4.15 of 5 stars 4.15 avg rating — 84,891 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
184 Briar's Book (Circle of Mag...
by
4.09 of 5 stars 4.09 avg rating — 17,600 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
185 Chosen (House of Night #3)
by
3.9 of 5 stars 3.90 avg rating — 131,631 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
186 The Awakening (Darkest Powe...
by
4.16 of 5 stars 4.16 avg rating — 75,537 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
187 Grave Witch (Alex Craft, #1)
by
3.99 of 5 stars 3.99 avg rating — 16,261 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
188 The Princess and the Hound ...
by
3.43 of 5 stars 3.43 avg rating — 8,658 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
189 The Last Stormlord (Watergi...
by
3.74 of 5 stars 3.74 avg rating — 4,137 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
190 Good Omens: The Nice and Ac...
by
4.26 of 5 stars 4.26 avg rating — 205,519 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
191 Perdido Street Station (Bas...
by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94 avg rating — 31,284 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
192 Touch of Power (Healer, #1)
by
4.23 of 5 stars 4.23 avg rating — 17,643 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
193 The Magic of Finkleton (Fin...
by
3.69 of 5 stars 3.69 avg rating — 286 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
194 Stone of Tears (Sword of Tr...
by
4.09 of 5 stars 4.09 avg rating — 65,640 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
195 Cast in Chaos (Chronicles o...
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 4,273 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
196 The Dragon Reborn (Wheel of...
by
4.2 of 5 stars 4.20 avg rating — 117,711 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
197 A Discovery of Witches (All...
by
3.98 of 5 stars 3.98 avg rating — 158,760 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
198 Eldest (The Inheritance Cyc...
by
3.93 of 5 stars 3.93 avg rating — 199,556 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
199 City of Masks (Stravaganza,...
by
3.93 of 5 stars 3.93 avg rating — 8,908 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
200 The Ruins of Ambrai (Exiles...
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 6,364 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
flag this list (?)
1,432 books · 4,787 voters · list created September 28th, 2008 by Eric Gardner (votes) .
339 likes · like
Lists are re-scored approximately every 5 minutes.


Eric
Eric
1073 books
30 friends
Charlotte
Charlotte
306 books
8 friends
Jim
Jim
490 books
2 friends
Greyweather
Greyweather
1984 books
52 friends
Mary
Mary
2766 books
16 friends
I am Bastet
I am Bastet
1884 books
150 friends
Choobie
Choobie
181 books
25 friends
Marion
Marion
13 books
0 friends

More voters…


Comments (showing 1-50 of 168) (168 new)


message 1: by Eric (last edited Jun 01, 2011 03:13AM) (new)

Eric Gardner I don't think Harry Potter belongs on this list because the magic system in that world is not rigidly defined. Basically anything can happen at any time, there's no limitations on the powers of the Characters. As long as the kid knows the spell he or she can cast it all day.

This doesn't mean I am not a fan I love Harry Potter!


message 2: by Dave (new)

Dave Moore How can any list of books dealing in any fashion with magic be considered complete without reference to Jim Butcher's "Dresden Files" series? Harry is a wizard and his employment of his magical skills (and the moral dilemmas it sometimes imposes) is core to the stories.


message 3: by Amir (last edited Nov 05, 2009 05:02AM) (new)

Amir Mishali Of course Harry Potter's magic system is the most interesting. How do you cast a spell? you wave a wand and say a single word and that's it! So intriguing! so mysterious! so complicated and original! And of course, the word you mutter must be in the correct accent! Not Leviosa, leviosa!


message 4: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Eric wrote: "I don't think Harry Potter belongs on this list because the magic system in that world is not rigidly defined. Basically anything can happen at any time there's no limitations on the powers of the..."

Agreed.


message 6: by Xenophon (new)

Xenophon Hendrix I think Harry Potter doing so well is a function of reader inexperience and the popularity of the series. To those of us who have been reading fantasy for years, Harry Potter is fun but nothing that special.


message 7: by Didit (new)

Didit bartimaeus trilogy is certainly must be added to this list! it's magic system is so interesting, like summoning things, a pact, etc..


message 8: by Xenophon (new)

Xenophon Hendrix One can add books on the right of the page.


message 9: by Matt (new)

Matt Gibson Didit wrote: "bartimaeus trilogy is certainly must be added to this list! it's magic system is so interesting, like summoning things, a pact, etc.."

I quite agree. I loved that series.


message 10: by mercury (new)

mercury This list is FAILing it's job of rating books on interesting-ness of the magic system.

It's successfully rating books on popularity with readers, by which books they've actually read and are familiar with.

Harry Potter books are great, and they're fun. Yet there is absolutely nothing interesting (nor original) about the magic system. Magic exists, and works in a way convenient to the story and the writer. The effects of the magic might be interesting, but the books shouldn't really be considered in a "Most Interesting Magical System" category.


message 11: by Nathan (last edited May 20, 2010 07:04PM) (new)

Nathan mercury wrote: "This list is FAILing it's job of rating books on interesting-ness of the magic system.

It's successfully rating books on popularity with readers, by which books they've actually read and are fami..."


I was thinking the same thing... after looking at the list, it looks like a popularity contest. I suppose some people are rather limited in the reading they have done. I can't even remember all the books I've read. I actually added some books i don't even like to the list ;) I was thinking along the lines of original, well developed, unique, well explained, and interesting systems. I am refraining from voting on books already listed that I LOVE, because I don't think they really qualify for this list. Oh well...


message 12: by Eric (new)

Eric Gardner Nate wrote: "mercury wrote: "This list is FAILing it's job of rating books on interesting-ness of the magic system.

It's successfully rating books on popularity with readers, by which books they've actually r..."


I made the list and sorry but I don't see a way to kick books off!


message 13: by Nathan (new)

Nathan I've seen comments where people have removed books, but perhaps they have removed that option... idk.


message 14: by Derya (last edited Jun 01, 2010 07:23AM) (new)

Derya Oh, I see Twilight on this list, just like all the other lists. Good God, they're way too obsessed with it. =)


message 15: by Kierenne (new)

Kierenne I agree with those above. Harry Potter doesn't really have a place on the list, nor do any of the chronicle of Narnia books, I am fans of both, though =)


message 16: by Derya (last edited Jun 02, 2010 07:44AM) (new)

Derya After reading the comments above, I’d like to share my personal thoughts: Harry Potter series have the most interesting magical system, thus I’ve voted for them.

Some claims that Harry, as the boy who survived, can do any kind of magic, simply by pronouncing the required magical words in the correct tone and accent. It’s absolutely wrong. In order to do "magic", firstly you have to possess the magical power and ability. You may learn spells by reading spell books, but in order to cast one, you have to learn how to do so, and train yourself. For example; in “The Deathly Hallows”, Hagrid desperately tries to repair his motorbike up in the air, he screams “Reparo” the magical word to repair stuff, as you might recall, in the very correct accent, yet it does not work successfully. Why not? Hagrid has magical powers, as we witness in the first book, but he is incapable of casting certain kinds of spells.

If you’re not satisfied with this particular example, here’s another one for you: The Patronus Charm! It’s not all about swinging your wand and yelling “Expecto Patronum”. After learning the basics, you have to imagine your happiest moments to form a patronus, which is not an easy task, since many students seem amazed by the fact that Harry manages to produce it.

Another intriguing fact about the magical word of Harry Potter is that there are certain rules about “creating” things. For instance; you cannot create food out of thin air, as Hermione explains to Ron in “The Deathly Hallows”. There’s in indeed a limitation.

If you examine the books -quite carefully for once- you as well, will definitely come up with other facts, that may serve to prove the point.


message 17: by Nathan (last edited Jun 02, 2010 08:55AM) (new)

Nathan Try reading some other books before you make such statements, Blut. It's like claiming Avatar is the most original storyline ever when you haven't seen Dances With Wolves or Ferngully or the 75 other movies it's ripped off from. Sure it looks great, but its far from original or interesting. It's actually quite derivative and completely unoriginal. That doesn't mean it's bad, but it should be recognized for what it is.


message 18: by Derya (last edited Jun 02, 2010 09:17AM) (new)

Derya This is the most foolish statement I've ever read. Remember that you're bla bla bla-ing about a perfect stranger online. You have no idea about me at all. Of course I've read novels and short stories, with plots, evolving around magical worlds.

The question is have you ever read Harry Potter? When it comes to that, you're randomly guessing without reasoning.


message 19: by Nathan (new)

Nathan Wow, you've read stories with plots... amazing. The Potter books are mediocre, but fun. I really don't have much else to say. I would rarely even want to admit to reading them. They are books for people who don't really read at all, barely any real substance and perfect for the unthinking masses.


message 20: by Derya (new)

Derya You've read only two plays, which are “the most popular” ones, by Shakespeare, and now you think you know it all, eh? How ridiculously sweet!

I understand that you don't have "anything" to say about HP world, you obviously have a very limited knowledge -probably based on the “popular” film adaptations- and you're not capable of criticizing my comment on the magical system of HP, therefore I have already successfully pointed out that you're randomly guessing.


message 21: by Nathan (new)

Nathan Shakespeare is not very good, I wouldn't ever read more than I absolutely had to and I've read quite a few plays, actually. I've barely touched on rating the books I've read here. You are the only one "randomly guessing". I wish you the best of luck in your future failed attempts at insulting others. Good day.


message 22: by Derya (new)

Derya One must have the capacity and a higher taste in art, in order to appreciate it. We cannot expect an illiterate man to realize the beauty of The Mona Lisa.

You're the one, who clearly insulted each and every one, who like the pure escapist HP series, by claiming that they're for "unthinking masses". Actually, generalisation is for "unthinking" and lazy beings. Hope you remember it, the next time.


message 23: by Selena (new)

Selena Blutiful wrote: "Oh, I see Twilight on this list, just like all the other lists. Good God, they're way too obsessed with it. =)"

Agreed. How's Twilight even on this list? There is no magic in that book. Just weird vampire powers (still not magic).


message 24: by Ben (new)

Ben I usually vote for the most original.The Golden Compass doesn't use too much magic and the world uses it in conjunction with primal technology. I also voted for A Wizard of Earthsea and Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell because of the difficulty and gravity of their "magic".


message 25: by Christopher (new)

Christopher Harry Potter, The Chronicles of Narnia, Twilight, and many of the other books here, while excellent reads, do not have a structured magic system. In many of the worlds listed, the magic is free and without clear rules, serving whatever purpose the author desires. Of the books that I have read, only Eragon has an actual, defined, system of magic with rules that can never be broken.


message 26: by Eric (new)

Eric Gardner I made this list, I became a goodreads librarian to edit the books on the list and I still can't edit the books on the list! ouch!


message 27: by Adinata (new)

Adinata Crazedgenius wrote: "Harry Potter, The Chronicles of Narnia, Twilight, and many of the other books here, while excellent reads, do not have a structured magic system. In many of the worlds listed, the magic is free an..."

Agreed. Have you ever read "Black Magician Trilogy" by Trudi Canavan? I believe the magic system in that story is as complex as Eragon. Not everyone can do magic. But everyone has magic. And the magic it self like a knowledge that needs to explored first. Just like a scienstist trying to find new thing.


message 28: by Christopher (new)

Christopher I have not. But I'll make sure to read those if I ever get the chance.


message 29: by Xenophon (last edited Dec 06, 2010 11:25AM) (new)

Xenophon Hendrix Librarians aren't supposed to kick books off a list unless they clearly don't belong. Harry Potter has magic, and persons who have not read much fantasy might believe it has some interesting ideas about magic, so it doesn't clearly not belong. Or, you know, maybe they have read a lot of fantasy and genuinely believe the Harry Potter books have some creative ideas about magic. There is room for disagreement.


message 30: by Eric (new)

Eric Gardner Xenophon wrote: "Librarians aren't supposed to kick books off a list unless they clearly don't belong. Harry Potter has magic, and persons who have not read much fantasy might believe it has some interesting ideas..."

By this logic eventually every book with the word magic in it somewhere will be clogging up the list eliminating any value it may have...


message 31: by Xenophon (new)

Xenophon Hendrix Not necessarily, those books that readers think well of should still bubble up high on the list. I've found that Listopia retains its utility if one simply ignores Harry Potter, Twilight, and other books that have become fads. That which is left near the top is often worth consideration.


message 32: by Matthew (new)

Matthew Ulmer Although there is some argument over Harrt Potter, I think we can all agree that Twilight does not, in any way shape or form, belong on this list.


message 33: by Aimee (new)

Aimee Eric wrote: "I don't think Harry Potter belongs on this list because the magic system in that world is not rigidly defined. Basically anything can happen at any time there's no limitations on the powers of the..."

I completely agree with you! I am also a Harry Potter fan but I do not understand the magic system at all.


message 34: by David (new)

David Harry Potter's magic system is the most interesting?! Those Potter fans really ought to read more fantasy books. How is waving a wand and saying some words "interesting"? It's the most basic, most traditional, and most typical way of performing magic, like Merlin.


message 35: by Patrick (new)

Patrick David wrote: "Harry Potter's magic system is the most interesting?! Those Potter fans really ought to read more fantasy books. How is waving a wand and saying some words "interesting"? It's the most basic, most ..."

I totally agree! I'd prefer to have A Wizard of Earthsea beat HP's position! I'd comment on the other books, but I haven't gotten to reading them yet. I will eventually!


message 36: by Minglis (new)

Minglis seriously HP has one of the most dull magic systems in fantasy.


message 37: by Melanie (last edited Jul 27, 2011 07:05PM) (new)

Melanie Matthew wrote: "Although there is some argument over Harrt Potter, I think we can all agree that Twilight does not, in any way shape or form, belong on this list."
Totally agree
I was thinking WTH is that doing in here! not only that but its almost in the top 50!
I swear twilight comes up on every list!
It was in a steampunk list at one point!
what is with the twilight fans ?


message 38: by Melanie (new)

Melanie I also agree about harry potter has much as I love thoese books the only interesting magic is the horcruxs and even then that are not the most imaginative.


message 39: by Cindy (new)

Cindy To me, what makes HP interesting is the way it turns some traditions around. Elves are not otherworldly, beautiful eerie creatures. They are short, helpful critters who do housework. And so on.

Maybe if the terms were more clearly and explicitly defined at the top of the page, people would be more discriminating about what books they add.


message 40: by David (new)

David Elves are only as they are now because of Tolkien primarily. Before that, there was a period where they were diminutive fairy-like creatures.

I suppose you're right about the description. Depending on one's experience with the fantasy genre, one may not understand what a magic "system" is, as opposed to a world or a setting.


message 41: by Kerri (new)

Kerri Harry Potter is one of my favorite series but really, its magic system isn't unique at all. It takes overdone and stereotypical magic (as in wands and incantations, witches on broomsticks, potions in cauldrons, pointy hats) and has fun with it. But it's all been seen before.


message 42: by Bobby (new)

Bobby Luke Yeah - harry potter fanchildren - stop giving it credit it doesn't deserve. THEY USE WANDS! How on earth is that the most "unique" ?

Another thing, whoever the heck is voting for Twilight, stop it!! They don't use magic - they are werewolves and vampires. And if that is magic, it's not new - books about werewolves and vampires are not "unique."

Furthermore, why don't we just vote on series, not series and the individual volumes? I mean, the magic in Mistborn doesn't change from book to book. The uniqueness of the system is the same in each book - so how is one more unique than the other? I mean, really.


message 43: by Ian (new)

Ian (first person omniscient) It is exceedingly difficult for me to pick any one magical system as the most unique. The best magical systems are those that are integrated fluidly, consistently and, as ridiculous as it might sound considering the topic, logically. The magic system in Harry Potter, for example, is the best magic system possible for THOSE stories. The charm and appeal for me was the integration of a traditional incantation and wand based magical world with the mundane reality of adolescence and our own world. In that sense it all but demanded the presence of things like wands, broomsticks and cauldrons. So no, the books would not have worked half as well if Mrs. Rowling had went with a system of magic like say the one in Mistborn. What she did with the traditional fantasy tropes was certainly unique but the magical system she used was not. I personally feel like it is a diservice to the books to condemn what she did as dull but I don't think they would have been nearly as popular if they actually deserved the top spot on this list. (Oh and someone mentioned the horcruxes as an example, I think, but even there the first thing it reminded me of was a phylactery.)

Speaking of Mistborn, Brandon Sanderson ALWAYS goes above and beyond when it comes to the creation and defining of magical systems. The systems always have clear limitations and, what to me at least, the best part about all of them is that none of them function in the absence of... well, something. Be it metal, color, trapped light or 'breath'/souls, each of his magic systems have an internal logic they must play by; in a sense each system has its own law of conservation of energy.

Garth Nix did the same thing in the Old Kingdom stories, when he brought a rather elegant system of magic to necromancy through the use of sound and the various gates of death. The aspects of charter magic and words are more traditional but since that was the magic of the common people inhabiting his world, it served as a nice counterpoint to the abilities of the abhorsen.

One of the most thought provoking systems of magic I have encountered was in A Shadow of Summer by Daniel Abraham. The golemesque 'andat' and the poets that bind them with unique 'names' and whose very own sense of self worth can infect those 'names' and allow weaknesses for the andat to exploit was wonderfully used and rich with philosophical potential that wouldn't have been found in the traditional summoner and summoning pact basis from which it springs.

I am going to stop before I go on and on about why I picked each book to vote for but I guess the main reason I stopped to write a reply to this list is simply because it is my favorite one to think about hands down.

Oh and Robin Hobb got two books in my list from the same series (or at least the same world) because the magic system diverges in very unique ways... and honestly, it does again in the third trilogy. I won't say more since most of it is closely tied to the plot.


message 44: by Bobby (new)

Bobby Luke I totally agree - the harry potter system was the correct and best system for the series - and most definitely worked better than anything else would have. However, although it may be the best application in that series - it is in no way a unique magical system. A great system yes, a unique system no. That's all I am saying.


message 45: by Miriam (new)

Miriam I agree. It worked for the story, but based on the description of this list (at the top of the page) I wouldn't include it here.


message 46: by Aubrey (new)

Aubrey Didit wrote: "bartimaeus trilogy is certainly must be added to this list! it's magic system is so interesting, like summoning things, a pact, etc.."

I know! Where's Bartimaeus on this list? How can The Host be on while they aren't?!


message 47: by Bobby (last edited Nov 21, 2011 11:10PM) (new)

Bobby Luke Aubrey wrote: "Didit wrote: "bartimaeus trilogy is certainly must be added to this list! it's magic system is so interesting, like summoning things, a pact, etc.."

I know! Where's Bartimaeus on this list? How c..."


VERY good point. The magic in that book was very unique, and very cool.

As it stands, however, Bartimaeus IS on the list. Number 65.


message 48: by [deleted user] (new)

The Ballad of Young Tam Lin. You can debate the "original," since it's somewhat based on Scottish folklore, but for a totally engaging fantasy romance, you won't find better than this. Preview 3 chapters on Amazon Kindle ("Look Inside").


message 49: by Bobby (new)

Bobby Luke What does everyone think of The Dark Tower series? The magic, albeit not used in the traditional sense like a harry potter or mistborn, is certainly present and is DEFINITELY unique. At least in my opinion.


message 50: by [deleted user] (new)

Going back a bit (well, a BIG bit), there's the Amber series by Zelazny. Not nearly as well-written as The Ballad of Young Tam Lin (above), but the plotting in the early books is engaging, and the idea of a reality "more real" than our own is compelling.


« previous 1 3 4
back to top



Anyone can add books to this list.