Best Historical Fiction Books that Are Actually Historical Fiction
The original "Best Historical Fiction" list is a lost cause. It's littered with books that are either not Fiction or are not historical.

So, if you're going to add a book, it has to be:
1) Fiction. What is fiction? If you don't know the answer, you shouldn't be adding books to these lists. "Angela's Ashes", for example, is a memoir.

2) Historical. This is a bit more complicated. In this context, "historical" means the story is set in the past (relative to the author and time of publication). How far in the past is a reasonable question. "Huckleberry Finn" may seem historical to modern readers, and certainly has historical significance as part of the canon of American literature. It is not, however, historical fiction. Why not? Twain was describing events of his own time (albeit with a few decades of hindsight). It is history to us, but largely contemporary to him. In no way can an author fictionalizing events of his/her own time and place be said to be writing "historical fiction". Willa Cather's pioneer novels are good examples of how blurry this distinction can be. "Song of the Lark" is set in the 1890s (Cather was born in 1873), and written 25 years after the period it describes. The wikipedia entry lists the genre for "Song of the Lark" as "novel", but for "My Antonia" (another of her prairie novels) as "historical fiction" , despite the fact that many of the events described in "Antonia" are drawn from Cather's own experiences, and the time is not far removed from that of her own life. "The Count of Monte Cristo" is another tricky example. Set during key historical events from 1815-1838, the historical setting is important (though hardly crucial to the story), but the book was published in 1844, when these events retained their relevance to the average French reader. Furthermore, no real research was required on Dumas' part to construct the setting. He knew much of it from experience, and what he did not know he could simply recreate based on the broad outlines of the facts. Thus, it seems that the "historical" component for "historical fiction" suggests two key criterion: first, a setting removed from the author's own experience; second, a recreation of that setting based on research.

A third, more stringent requirement would be that the setting have historical significance, but I disagree with this criterion. Historical fiction need not only concern great people and great events.

So this is a new list for great historical fiction books that are, in fact, both fiction and historical. Think before you add.
1 Gone with the Wind
by
4.25 of 5 stars 4.25 avg rating — 629,600 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
2 The Pillars of the Earth  (...
by
4.26 of 5 stars 4.26 avg rating — 324,525 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
3 The Book Thief
by
4.36 of 5 stars 4.36 avg rating — 638,254 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
4 Outlander (Outlander, #1)
by
4.14 of 5 stars 4.14 avg rating — 287,302 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
5 The Red Tent
by
4.13 of 5 stars 4.13 avg rating — 327,578 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
6 Memoirs of a Geisha
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 1,021,611 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
7 Girl With a Pearl Earring
by
3.8 of 5 stars 3.80 avg rating — 323,320 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
8 The Name of the Rose
by
4.07 of 5 stars 4.07 avg rating — 144,862 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
9 The Other Boleyn Girl (The ...
by
4.01 of 5 stars 4.01 avg rating — 313,436 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
10 I, Claudius (Claudius, #1)
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 27,866 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
11 The Clan of the Cave Bear (...
by
3.97 of 5 stars 3.97 avg rating — 144,602 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
12 World Without End (The Pill...
by
4.19 of 5 stars 4.19 avg rating — 95,144 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
13 The Guernsey Literary and P...
by
4.1 of 5 stars 4.10 avg rating — 296,355 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
14 Shōgun (Asian Saga, #3)
by
4.33 of 5 stars 4.33 avg rating — 77,236 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
15 The Sunne in Splendour
by
4.39 of 5 stars 4.39 avg rating — 12,590 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
16 The Count of Monte Cristo
by
4.15 of 5 stars 4.15 avg rating — 435,215 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
17 The Three Musketeers
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 150,143 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
18 Wolf Hall (Thomas Cromwell,...
by
3.8 of 5 stars 3.80 avg rating — 71,504 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
19 The Scarlet Letter
by
3.32 of 5 stars 3.32 avg rating — 377,199 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
20 Lonesome Dove
by
4.44 of 5 stars 4.44 avg rating — 84,498 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
21 When Christ and His Saints ...
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 7,980 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
22 Katherine
by
4.18 of 5 stars 4.18 avg rating — 16,934 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
23 A Tale of Two Cities
by
3.75 of 5 stars 3.75 avg rating — 501,242 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
24 Atonement
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 265,586 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
25 Here be Dragons (Welsh Prin...
by
4.31 of 5 stars 4.31 avg rating — 12,446 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
26 Death Valley Scotty
by
4.5 of 5 stars 4.50 avg rating — 42 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
27 Fall of Giants (The Century...
by
4.2 of 5 stars 4.20 avg rating — 98,156 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
28 Talwar
by
4.03 of 5 stars 4.03 avg rating — 37 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
29 Courage
by
4.11 of 5 stars 4.11 avg rating — 19 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
30 Snow Flower and the Secret Fan
by
4.02 of 5 stars 4.02 avg rating — 213,612 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
31 Barbarians
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 29 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
32 Armada
by
3.88 of 5 stars 3.88 avg rating — 32 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
33 The Killer Angels
by
4.26 of 5 stars 4.26 avg rating — 44,277 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
34 Possession
by
3.86 of 5 stars 3.86 avg rating — 44,615 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
35 Perfume: The Story of a Mur...
by
3.97 of 5 stars 3.97 avg rating — 132,221 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
36 Falls the Shadow  (Welsh Pr...
by
4.36 of 5 stars 4.36 avg rating — 5,196 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
37 The First Man in Rome (Mast...
by
4.04 of 5 stars 4.04 avg rating — 11,684 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
38 The Valley of Horses (Earth...
by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94 avg rating — 43,466 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
39 The Scarlet Pimpernel
by
4.05 of 5 stars 4.05 avg rating — 77,556 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
40 The Alienist
by
4.02 of 5 stars 4.02 avg rating — 72,152 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
41 The French Lieutenant's Woman
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 27,313 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
42 Year of Wonders
by
3.99 of 5 stars 3.99 avg rating — 78,438 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
43 The English Patient
by
3.86 of 5 stars 3.86 avg rating — 67,557 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
44 Master and Commander (Aubre...
by
4.08 of 5 stars 4.08 avg rating — 22,466 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
45 Sarum: The Novel of England
by
4.05 of 5 stars 4.05 avg rating — 25,109 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
46 The Birth of Venus
by
3.76 of 5 stars 3.76 avg rating — 60,028 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
47 Cold Mountain
by
3.77 of 5 stars 3.77 avg rating — 134,933 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
48 The Reckoning  (Welsh Princ...
by
4.43 of 5 stars 4.43 avg rating — 4,880 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
49 The Mammoth Hunters (Earth'...
by
3.85 of 5 stars 3.85 avg rating — 38,126 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
50 The Boleyn Inheritance (The...
by
3.8 of 5 stars 3.80 avg rating — 54,370 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
51 Dissolution (Matthew Shardl...
by
4.06 of 5 stars 4.06 avg rating — 14,880 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
52 Devil's Brood  (Henry II & ...
by
4.34 of 5 stars 4.34 avg rating — 3,809 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
53 Ivanhoe
by
3.71 of 5 stars 3.71 avg rating — 51,185 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
54 The Witch of Blackbird Pond
by
3.92 of 5 stars 3.92 avg rating — 80,006 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
55 Time and Chance (Henry II &...
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 4,488 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
56 Treasure Island
by
3.79 of 5 stars 3.79 avg rating — 202,477 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
57 Secrets of the Realm
by
4.4 of 5 stars 4.40 avg rating — 162 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
58 War and Peace
by
4.08 of 5 stars 4.08 avg rating — 115,709 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
59 The Greatest Knight (Willia...
by
4.05 of 5 stars 4.05 avg rating — 4,392 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
60 Flashman (The Flashman Pape...
by
4.09 of 5 stars 4.09 avg rating — 5,858 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
60 City of Thieves
by
4.25 of 5 stars 4.25 avg rating — 45,697 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
62 The Grass Crown (Masters of...
by
4.25 of 5 stars 4.25 avg rating — 6,423 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
63 The Scarlet Lion (William M...
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 2,907 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
64 The Agony and the Ecstasy
by
4.1 of 5 stars 4.10 avg rating — 43,067 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
65 Kristin Lavransdatter (Kris...
by
4.24 of 5 stars 4.24 avg rating — 3,635 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
66 The Sweetness at the Bottom...
by
3.79 of 5 stars 3.79 avg rating — 72,160 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
67 Claudius the God and His Wi...
by
4.23 of 5 stars 4.23 avg rating — 6,323 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
67 Beloved (Toni Morrison Tril...
by
3.7 of 5 stars 3.70 avg rating — 173,595 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
69 Madame Tussaud: A Novel of ...
by
3.95 of 5 stars 3.95 avg rating — 11,068 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
70 An Instance of the Fingerpost
by
3.91 of 5 stars 3.91 avg rating — 13,855 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
71 Memoirs of Cleopatra
by
4.15 of 5 stars 4.15 avg rating — 12,367 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
72 Unexpected Gifts
by
4.28 of 5 stars 4.28 avg rating — 95 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
73 Tai-Pan (Asian Saga, #2)
by
4.2 of 5 stars 4.20 avg rating — 24,482 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
74 The Good Earth (House of Ea...
by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94 avg rating — 141,110 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
75 The King Must Die (Theseus,...
by
3.99 of 5 stars 3.99 avg rating — 3,516 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
76 The Plains of Passage (Eart...
by
3.73 of 5 stars 3.73 avg rating — 31,685 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
77 The Confessions of Catherin...
by
3.92 of 5 stars 3.92 avg rating — 4,335 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
78 The Game of Kings (The Lymo...
by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27 avg rating — 3,909 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
79 Sovereign (Matthew Shardlak...
by
4.23 of 5 stars 4.23 avg rating — 7,129 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
80 Fingersmith
by
4.0 of 5 stars 4.00 avg rating — 30,339 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
81 The Crimson Petal and the W...
by
3.82 of 5 stars 3.82 avg rating — 20,937 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
82 Gates of Fire: An Epic Nove...
by
4.38 of 5 stars 4.38 avg rating — 13,576 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
83 The Last Queen
by
3.99 of 5 stars 3.99 avg rating — 6,276 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
84 Roots: The Saga of an Ameri...
by
4.39 of 5 stars 4.39 avg rating — 88,406 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
85 River God (Ancient Egypt, #1)
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 18,574 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
86 The Remains of the Day
by
4.09 of 5 stars 4.09 avg rating — 77,156 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
87 Orlando
by
3.83 of 5 stars 3.83 avg rating — 25,214 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
88 The Bull from the Sea (Thes...
by
4.05 of 5 stars 4.05 avg rating — 1,794 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
89 Death Comes for the Archbishop
by
3.82 of 5 stars 3.82 avg rating — 15,508 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
90 Forever Amber
by
3.98 of 5 stars 3.98 avg rating — 11,236 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
91 Lincoln
by
4.17 of 5 stars 4.17 avg rating — 5,240 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
92 Horatio Hornblower 1 - 11.
by
4.4 of 5 stars 4.40 avg rating — 1,003 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
93 The Traitor's Wife: A Novel...
by
3.71 of 5 stars 3.71 avg rating — 2,211 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
94 Johnny Tremain
by
3.56 of 5 stars 3.56 avg rating — 23,493 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
95 Follow the River
by
4.19 of 5 stars 4.19 avg rating — 9,844 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
96 A Thread of Grace
by
3.98 of 5 stars 3.98 avg rating — 7,532 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
97 Rebel Puritan: A Scandalous...
by
4.51 of 5 stars 4.51 avg rating — 74 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
97 Anna Karenina
by
3.99 of 5 stars 3.99 avg rating — 298,416 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
99 Fortune's Favorites (Master...
by
4.3 of 5 stars 4.30 avg rating — 4,054 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
100 Burr
by
4.05 of 5 stars 4.05 avg rating — 4,323 ratings
Rate this book
Clear rating
flag this list (?)
1,001 books · 1,104 voters · list created October 31st, 2010 by Andrew Hill (votes) .
131 likes · like
Lists are re-scored approximately every 5 minutes.


Andrew
Andrew
1292 books
23 friends
Jan
Jan
1671 books
67 friends
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
2426 books
467 friends
☯Bettie☯
☯Bettie☯
10759 books
145 friends
Laura
Laura
7123 books
173 friends
Lee
Lee
5265 books
250 friends
Judy
Judy
875 books
7 friends
Mishka
Mishka
276 books
20 friends

More voters…


Comments (showing 1-50 of 54) (54 new)


message 1: by Misfit (last edited Oct 31, 2010 03:30PM) (new)

Misfit I am wondering how long it will be before someone adds Twilight to this list as well. Susannah, want to draw straws? :p


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Draw straws to remove it if (when!) it shows up?


message 3: by Andrew (last edited Nov 01, 2010 01:27PM) (new)

Andrew Hill "The Odyssey" is not historical fiction. It's an epic poem that involves the active intervention of Greek Gods, for goodness sake. At what point in actual human history were Cyclops eating men and witches transforming men into pigs?

The Iliad? NOT historical fiction. The Epic of Gilgamesh? NOT historical fiction. I love epic poems, but come on.


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads You want me to remove them?


message 5: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Hill Susanna wrote: "You want me to remove them?"

Can you remove them? That would be easier than asking the librarians to do it. Thank you for offering.


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Speaking of blurred lines, though:

What about novels where a major part of the action is set in the past (not only from our, but also from the author's point of view), but the novel either ends in the author's own time or has a contemporary framework setting? E.g. Thomas Mann's "Buddenbrooks" (19th century, with a major initial focus on the earlier decades thereof, but concluding in 1877, i.e. 2 years after Mann's birth), Virginia Woolf's "Orlando" (beginning in the Tudor era, but concluding in the early 20th century) and Amy Tan's "Kitchen God's Wife" (framework setting: contemporary San Francisco, but most of the action is set in early 20th century China). I've added these books for the time being, but wil be happy to remove them again if you'd rather not have them on this list.


message 8: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Hill Themis-Athena wrote: "Speaking of blurred lines, though:

What about novels where a major part of the action is set in the past (not only from our, but also from the author's point of view), but the novel either ends i..."


If a significant portion of the novel is set in the somewhat distant past (relative to date of publication), I think you have a good case to include it. The issue with epic poems is that they're not really "historical" in the strictest sense--they are somewhat fantastic versions of real events (the siege of Troy certainly happened, for example). In my opinion, elements of the supernatural preclude books from the "historical fiction" genre.


message 9: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Hill Misfit wrote: "I am wondering how long it will be before someone adds Twilight to this list as well. Susannah, want to draw straws? :p"

Have people seriously put Twilight on historical fiction lists? Good grief.


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Andrew wrote: "Themis-Athena wrote: "Speaking of blurred lines, though:

What about novels where a major part of the action is set in the past (not only from our, but also from the author's point of view), but t..."


Thanks. I understand your points about epic poems (and certainly those mentioned). Just one more question: What about books such as Mark Twain's "Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court"?

Leaving aside that one might well want to exclude this particular work on the grounds that King Arthur's court is a mythological (as opposed to historical) setting anyway, I'm wondering how to deal with works that use features such as time travel NOT because they are focused on the feature in question per se (such as, arguably, "The Time Traveler's Wife") but because they're using this feature as a writer's tool in order to achieve the work's overall major authorial purpose (i.e., contrasting King Arthur's world with that of late 19th/early 20th century America, in the case of Twain's "Connecticut Yankee"). Assuming, in other words, Mark Twain's "Connecticut Yankee" hadn't been bolted into King Arthur's world but, say, into that of Henry VIII or the Pilgrim Fathers (and the author's chief purpose would still be to contrast the respective historic era with that in which he himself lives): Would you rather not have the book included in the list because it uses an element of the supernatural in order to transport the protagonist -- and the reader -- into the respective historic era?

And, oh yes, the "Twilight" books have a habit of infiltrating EVERY list on this site ... whether they're appropriate additions or not! :) (Which, incidentally, is one of the reasons why some of us at least try to be so careful about defining list parameters from the outset ... and your detailed definitions and explanations are certainly much appreciated in that regard!)


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Andrew wrote: "Misfit wrote: "I am wondering how long it will be before someone adds Twilight to this list as well. Susannah, want to draw straws? :p"

Have people seriously put Twilight on historical fiction lis..."


I have seen Twilight on all kinds of lists where it's not appropriate!


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Susanna wrote: "I have seen Twilight on all kinds of lists where it's not appropriate!"

Amen ...


message 13: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Hill Themis-Athena wrote: "Andrew wrote: "Themis-Athena wrote: "Speaking of blurred lines, though:

What about novels where a major part of the action is set in the past (not only from our, but also from the author's point ..."


Wow. My brain hurts. Is traveling through time a legitimate historical context? I understand that such a narrative gives an author interesting opportunities to observe the past while maintaining a modern (or alien) perspective. But it also feels somehow untrue to historical fiction as quasi-history. I don't really know the answer, but I do love Twain's "Yankee". The conjuring scene is one of the funniest I've read.

Another good question concerns alternate history. Much of it is garbage, but the really good authors build credible alternate histories on exhaustive research and great narrative development.

In both cases (i.e., time travel and alternate histories), I would say the standard should be pretty high in order to justify including the book. Again, this is just my opinion.

But hey, at least we're not debating the merits of "Twilight".


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Great -- my feelings exactly ... on ALL the above! :)


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Yeah, that's why I left Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell off, for example.


message 16: by Tania (new)

Tania Try Rebel Puritan. New author- outstanding book, and it IS HISTORICAL FICTION!


message 17: by Kristin (new)

Kristin Forgive me if someone has already posted this, but I see The Pianist on this list. Memoir?


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Kristin wrote: "Forgive me if someone has already posted this, but I see The Pianist on this list. Memoir?"

Ouch -- good catch. I removed it.


message 19: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Young What do people think about East of Eden by John Steinbeck? The story stretches from the 1860s to WWI, and so it overlaps with the first 10 years or so of Steinbeck's life. It wasn't published until 1952. Does it qualify?


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Victoria wrote: "What do people think about East of Eden by John Steinbeck? The story stretches from the 1860s to WWI, and so it overlaps with the first 10 years or so of Steinbeck's life. It wasn't published until 1952. Does it qualify? "

I wasn't sure about including it myself, either, but based on Andrew's response in message 8 above you might have a case. (Andrew?)


message 21: by Stacy (new)

Stacy FOrgive me if any of these are already on the list (I might have overlooked them). I don't want to add anything to this list without the creator first accepting them as true Historical Fiction.

The Crown Rose by Fiona Avery
The Lady Elizabeth by Alison Wier
The Dress Lodger by Sheri Holman


message 22: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Hill Victoria wrote: "What do people think about East of Eden by John Steinbeck? The story stretches from the 1860s to WWI, and so it overlaps with the first 10 years or so of Steinbeck's life. It wasn't published until..."

Seems reasonable, but of course I defer to your judgement. Sorry for the delayed response. I have been recovering from a move and starting a new job, so life's been hectic. Looks like the list is in good shape. Relatively few misfires.


message 23: by Ann (new)

Ann Clements Just finished Donati's "Wilderness" series. Thought they were great - up there with Gabaldon. Shouldn't these books be on this list? I may have overlooked them, but like others, am hesitant to add without the list creator's blessing.


message 24: by Cadiva (new)

Cadiva What about Bernard Cornwell's Sharpe series of books? Perhaps not all of them but I would certainly say the original series would stand up to being very good historical fiction?


message 25: by Lucy (new)

Lucy Paquette I'm new to Goodreads, an author, and I submit for the list creator's approval my book, The Hammock: A novel based on the true story of French painter James Tissot. It takes place in London and Paris during the 1870s, and I have relied on my training in art history to recreate the lives of Tissot and his friends Edgar Degas, James Whistler, Edouard Manet, Berthe Morisot, Lawrence Alma-Tadema, J.E. and Effie Millais, and others. I have attempted to present all the many characters accurately on each date they are depicted, showing where they were and interweaving their career progression and personal life with Tissot’s.

As much as possible, dialogue and situations are drawn from the individual’s own words, in their letters or autobiographies, or from those of a contemporary. My aim was to let the characters speak for themselves and to blend imagined dialogue for a seamless recreation of these fascinating individuals playing off each other as they might have in life. Tissot's story has never been told, and he had a fascinating life -- war, glamour, love, scandal and tragedy.

It's not Twilight! And of all the lists on Goodreads, it belongs in this category of Historical Fiction Books that are actually Historical Fiction, but I defer to your opinion.


message 26: by Peter (last edited Nov 13, 2012 04:25AM) (new)

Peter I believe War and Peace is missing from this list.


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Peter wrote: "I believe War and Peace is missing from this list."

Everybody can add books to this list, Peter -- there's a tab up top next to "all votes."


message 28: by Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) (last edited Nov 13, 2012 06:24AM) (new)

Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Deleted, for not being historical fiction within the description given above:
Table 21
Mid Ocean
All Quiet on the Western Front
(not "historical" fiction but set during their respective authors' own lives and informed by their own experience)
The Pianist
(redeleted -- memoir, not fiction)
Undeadly
(supernatural, not historical fiction).


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads 38 votes while 8 people say they've read it? That's impressive.


message 30: by Pat (last edited Jan 15, 2013 10:23PM) (new)

Pat I thought so too. His books have popped up on several lists all of a sudden.


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Another case for the "authors behaving badly" list ...


message 32: by Lance (new)

Lance I'm new to Goodreads too. I think the Mary Renault's stuff starting with the Bull From the Sea works. Cornwell's Sharpe series is good. And Colleen McCullough's series beginning with the First Man in Rome qualifies. I have to laugh. I may have screwed up a time or two. Some books evoke a period, but don't really rely on history or a story about which we can only guess at the details. But, I'm clear that dragons and vampires do not exist. This is great.


message 33: by Jain (new)

Jain Removed for not being historical fiction relative to the time of publication:
For Whom the Bell Tolls
All Quiet on the Western Front
The Charioteer


message 34: by Susanna - Censored by GoodReads (last edited May 24, 2013 03:59PM) (new)

Susanna - Censored by GoodReads The Count of Monte Cristo needs to go - Dumas was writing about his own time. (His lifetime: 1802-1870. Novel setting: 1815-about 1835.)


message 35: by Markbckr (new)

Markbckr I am not entirely clear what to consider when voting for a book. Am I saying simply that I thought it was a great book, or that I think it should be high on the list? My rating already signifies my opinion, so I am assuming the latter. I think it is difficult to vote then since I have read only around 10% of the books. I would appreciate others' perspectives on voting.


message 36: by Sanne (new)

Sanne Can I ask what A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century is doing on the list? As far as I know, it's nonfiction (unless someone discovered a great fictional storyline in there?).


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Sanne wrote: "Can I ask what A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century is doing on the list? As far as I know, it's nonfiction (unless someone discovered a great fictional storyline in there?)."

Deleted -- definitely nonfiction.


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Markbckr wrote: "I am not entirely clear what to consider when voting for a book. Am I saying simply that I thought it was a great book, or that I think it should be high on the list? My rating already signifies my opinion, so I am assuming the latter. I think it is difficult to vote then since I have read only around 10% of the books. I would appreciate others' perspectives on voting."

There are no ground rules that are set in stone, and people vote for various reasons. Courtesy towards the list creator's intentions would suggest a careful check whether any additions you make to the list are within the list description/topic (indeed, adding a book outside those bounds might cause it to be deleted again), but other than that, it's really up to you. Most people try to stick to books that they have actually read, or are at the very least seriously considering to read -- but again, that's just a rule of thumb; and similarly, there is no hard and fast rule how to sort the books you're voting for.

My own approach basically comes down to "these are books I think should be on this list," and whenever I do vote -- unless it's a "closed" list, i.e., one where the list creator has specifically asked that no books be added -- I try to add one or more books to those already on the list. If it's a list calling for the addition of books by my favorite authors, those authors may find themselves fairly high up in the order of my additions, but I may just as well sort my votes in a manner tailored to the list's topic, or chronologically (by approximation), or in any other way.

Other folks just go through what's already on the list and vote for the books they like -- in the order in which they appear on the list at the time of their voting. Yet others vote (and sort their votes) for other reasons and in a different order altogether. As I said, there really are no hard and fast rules, with the sole exception that any additions to the list should at least stick to the list's topic ...


message 39: by Xenophon (new)

Xenophon Hendrix Considering the WWII happened within Wouk's lifetime, should The Winds of War be considered historical fiction?


Themis-Athena (Does not and never will own a Kindle) Xenophon wrote: "Considering the WWII happened within Wouk's lifetime, should The Winds of War be considered historical fiction?"

Decidedly not. Removed.


message 41: by Chris (new)

Chris Bumpas Scarlet Letter - Not historical fiction.


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Hmm. Setting of novel: 1600s. Nathaniel Hawthorne's lifespan: 1804-1864.

Sounds like it qualifies to me.


message 43: by Chris (new)

Chris Bumpas Well I guess my definition of historical fiction is a little different. To me historical fiction weaves a fictional story around true historical events. For example, Ken Follet's Pillars of the Earth weaves a story around the Anarchy in England after the sinking of the White Ship. The Scarlet Letter doesn't really do anything like this as it is just a story of an adulteress that happens to be set in the 1600s.
In my opinion just because a novel is set in a time before the author's lifespan doesn't make it historical fiction. There has to be true history in it.


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads The list creator did not include that criterion, however.


message 45: by Chris (new)

Chris Bumpas I guess the creator of this list sucks then.


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Just explaining why I'm not removing it.


message 47: by Dawn (new)

Dawn Should Oliver Twist be on the list? (not sure if it's set during Dickens' lifespan)

And A Song of Fire & Ice definitely shouldn't be!


Susanna - Censored by GoodReads Dickens only wrote 2 historicals: A Tale of Two Cities and Barnaby Rudge (set in 1780).

A Song of Fire & Ice is incredibly wrong; I'll remove it.


message 49: by Susanna - Censored by GoodReads (last edited Nov 08, 2013 09:36AM) (new)

Susanna - Censored by GoodReads My instinct on "The Mayor of Casterbridge" is to remove it, by the way, as I don't recall that having a setting that Hardy would have conceived of as "historical."

ETA: That goes for "Jude the Obscure" as well.


message 50: by Jules (new)

Jules I am not sure why A Song of Ice and Fire is here, that's fantasy, no historical fiction.


« previous 1
back to top



Anyone can add books to this list.